Unpopular opinions on Gaga's songs

[Garcia 11]

7 minutes ago, KEVIN STEVE said:

I disagree with all of this

- Million Reasons is great

- Shallow, Poker Face and Bad Romance are excellent, but not in her top 10

- MANiCURE would've flopped, just like Venus

- Animal is a mess, Teeth is a masterpiece

It's ok, it's an "unpopular opinions" thread 

 

They're always a mess. 

[barnabesk 1,230]

Just Another Day is the best song on Joanne

[RenegAde 20,237]

2 hours ago, Franch Toast said:

Basically all of this (are you my twin?), but to add to it/elaborate: 

Joanne is one of her best and coherent albums. When I listen to it, there are only one or two songs I skip. The only other album about which I can say that is The Fame Monster (which is my favorite album). That said, Joanne doesn't necessarily have my favorite songs (though I love Angel Down and Just Another Day), and the songs I like most are on other albums. 

I would rather her release an album with acoustic/jazz & piano versions of her hits than LG6. And aside from the songs she regularly performs at J&P already, I'd like to see her add Dope, Gypsy, Hair, Speechless, and ARTPOP.

Summerboy should've been a single, released during, you guessed it, summer. Such a fun bop. I wish she'd perform it live. 

I'd prefer LG6 to be rock/metal rather than dance pop, but whatever it is, I'm okay with her taking her sweet time. 

The live version of Hair performed at the piano is so much better than the album version.

Hair is a better anthem of self-acceptance than Born This Way. 

Speaking of Born This Way, I know LG is well-intentioned, but I wish she'd update the lyrics to get rid of "oriental," "chola," and "transgender life." Yeah, she was going for rhyme, but she's talented enough to come up with something else. Her best friend and hairdresser are Asian American for crying out loud – why did no one tell her that at least in the U.S., most people of Asian descent aren't fond of being referred to as "oriental"? These lyrics undermine the intent of the song for me. 

@LVbuttondown already said it, but just to reiterate: Dope is so much more compelling of a song than I Wanna Be With You, and yes, her "textured" voice is part of it. I Wanna Be With You reminds me too much of the Bud Light commercial "this Bud's for you" or the Barry Manilow song ""This One's for You." 

I like Is That Alright? better than Always Remember Us This Way, though both are wonderful songs.

 

If you want piano versions of her hit watch enigma 

[G U C C I 5,570]

1 hour ago, Mordred said:

I want your love is one of her best song/cover

 

 

THIS. 

So good and the video 

[HeavyCapiLover 4,389]

3 hours ago, KEVIN STEVE said:

Stop that, please. Just because you disagree doesn't mean it's a blasphemy. You're being a little too extra.

Hey that's humor (the teeth one offended me a little bit lmao) but I love being extra I was born this way 

[Widows Kiss 7,818]

John Wayne and A-YO are awful songs

[AJRocketMan 2,684]

Of course, this pops up. Someone always starts this thread every month. There have been infinite “unpopular Gaga opinions” threads on GGD.

[bpmMonkey 7,366]

Scheiße isn’t that hard to spell. 
scheibe means plate in german, schiebe means push. 
 

 More: I don’t really want her to release „Act II“, or LG5 etc. nowadays. Don’t get me wrong, at some point it would be interesting to see her ideas, but it’s like reading your Facebook posts from 2010.. do you really stand by what you said back then, feel the same way about your ex bf from 10 years ago or want to be a firefighter by 2015? 

[Franch Toast 27,727]

40 minutes ago, RenegAde2888 said:

If you want piano versions of her hit watch enigma 

Oh, I do. Both that as well as Jazz & Piano. But I'd love high-quality audio recordings from a studio. Maybe after LG6 she'll do something like that. 

[brucee 1,690]

-I think the second part of Joanne is perfection (though A-Yo is perfect and so is the song Joanne)

Sinner's Prayer and Hey girl : underrated af

-I loved Americano a lot when it came out, the piano performance was everything.

-Monster is Swine before Swine

-Perfect Illusion is about the fans

 

[Mr S 8,781]

"Dope" is a good song and a good vocal. Yes a good vocal.

"I Want Your Love" is what LG5 should have been. Doing her own thing, in her own lane, but fresh/edgy.

I'm still waiting for something truly great lyrically from Gaga.

[Mr S 8,781]

The fact that most of her recent output has 3-5 co-writers on it bugs me. 

The fact that she shared her Oscar with 3 other men bugs me.

[Queen Gloria 3,464]

I can't stand The Queen from Born This Way. People rave about it being their favorite under appreciated/forgotten gem of a track, but I think it's just utter crap. I'm sorry. From the production to the lyrics to the whole vibe of it, it just doesn't connect with me. 

 

[Ronk 14,928]

14 hours ago, Andreu said:

I am Glad Gaga changed IWBWY to dope

That's unpopular with me.  I love IWBWY.

[Gypsy Life 118,907]

Heavy Metal Lover is in her top 10 worst songs.