Jump to content
Stefani Tee
opinion

CEREMONY || Lady Gaga music videos megarate

Featured Posts

IrishMonster
Just now, Enzo said:

Just Dance first :lolly: 

:what:

LADY GAGA, RIHANNA & KESHA ❤️
  • LMAO 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Enzo
Just now, PinkPop said:

21. Million Reasons

 

Overall Score: 4.197297

source.gif

Highest: 8.5 @Andreu

Lowest: 0 @dllcll, @BradleyCooper, @Daenerys

 

Comments:

@DiamondKing- She could have done so much more with this.

@Glittertinks- Listen, I understand what she tried to tell us here. But I hate the technical side of this video, the camera types are changing with makes it look like something is off and some scenes look so staged and dishonest… I think this could have done much better, I would have preferred a simple video only with her in the pink suit tbh, those are the best scenes. 

@RudraCNG - I mean, the parts where she is wearing the pink dress playing guitar are actually nice, but I just can't with the rest of it.

@OpenHeartedMonster - It's decent. It's not that bad that many people claim it to be

@imitalian - Wow. I think I've never been that disappointed in a Gaga mv ever. I was really about to unstan. I like to pretend it doesn't exist. I would have preferred a whole mv with just the pink look. 

@Enzo - really undeserved hate towards it. it's not as bad as people say

@IrishMonster - no explanation needed

@Inferno- i think its a cute video. it gets an absurd amount of hate which is just wild to me. it looks fine. it may be simple but shes had videos that were crammed with imagery that were ultimately much worse off for it. so to me, this video was everything it needed to be. could it have been something else? I guess but. what we got wasnt "bad".

@Talenti– Anyways-

@AndiGaga – No. Boring.

@MANiCURE 6 - There are cool shots but nothing really memorable.

@Oriane - We can all agree that this one is bad. Funnily, it has the exact same flaws as G.U.Y, but because G.U.Y was high budget, has a beautiful setting, crazy outfits etc, suddenly people think it’s a masterpiece. The shots are even better-looking here than in G.U.Y, they’re basic but decent. If the video had only consisted of the shots where she’s singing and playing the guitar, it would have been nice, unfortunately the rest of the video with the questionable story makes it bad...

@Didymus- A disaster and undoubtedly her worst video to date. The solo shots with her guitar are actually really nice and memorable but everything else is a giant mess, from her fillered up mirror reflection face which just looks comically unlike her to her horrendous "emotional" acting, to the "love you sis and here's a rosary" let's-call-it-a-storyline, this is really a low point in her artistry. I feel no ambition, no effort, no creativity,... It might be meaningful to her and her friends and family but as a music video this is shockingly badly executed.

poor thing

Lady Gaga did her own makeup in this picture but I’ll be sure to let her know how much you hate it xoxo

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
IrishMonster
1 minute ago, PinkPop said:

21. Million Reasons

 

Overall Score: 4.197297

source.gif

Highest: 8.5 @Andreu

Lowest: 0 @dllcll, @BradleyCooper, @Daenerys

 

Comments:

@DiamondKing- She could have done so much more with this.

@Glittertinks- Listen, I understand what she tried to tell us here. But I hate the technical side of this video, the camera types are changing with makes it look like something is off and some scenes look so staged and dishonest… I think this could have done much better, I would have preferred a simple video only with her in the pink suit tbh, those are the best scenes. 

@RudraCNG - I mean, the parts where she is wearing the pink dress playing guitar are actually nice, but I just can't with the rest of it.

@OpenHeartedMonster - It's decent. It's not that bad that many people claim it to be

@imitalian - Wow. I think I've never been that disappointed in a Gaga mv ever. I was really about to unstan. I like to pretend it doesn't exist. I would have preferred a whole mv with just the pink look. 

@Enzo - really undeserved hate towards it. it's not as bad as people say

@IrishMonster - no explanation needed

@Inferno- i think its a cute video. it gets an absurd amount of hate which is just wild to me. it looks fine. it may be simple but shes had videos that were crammed with imagery that were ultimately much worse off for it. so to me, this video was everything it needed to be. could it have been something else? I guess but. what we got wasnt "bad".

@Talenti– Anyways-

@AndiGaga – No. Boring.

@MANiCURE 6 - There are cool shots but nothing really memorable.

@Oriane - We can all agree that this one is bad. Funnily, it has the exact same flaws as G.U.Y, but because G.U.Y was high budget, has a beautiful setting, crazy outfits etc, suddenly people think it’s a masterpiece. The shots are even better-looking here than in G.U.Y, they’re basic but decent. If the video had only consisted of the shots where she’s singing and playing the guitar, it would have been nice, unfortunately the rest of the video with the questionable story makes it bad...

@Didymus- A disaster and undoubtedly her worst video to date. The solo shots with her guitar are actually really nice and memorable but everything else is a giant mess, from her fillered up mirror reflection face which just looks comically unlike her to her horrendous "emotional" acting, to the "love you sis and here's a rosary" let's-call-it-a-storyline, this is really a low point in her artistry. I feel no ambition, no effort, no creativity,... It might be meaningful to her and her friends and family but as a music video this is shockingly badly executed.

@DiamondKing @Animal Claws

giphy.gif

LADY GAGA, RIHANNA & KESHA ❤️
  • LMAO 3

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
DesertWolf

How can TLIAT be higher than MR? That's not even a proper music video, more like a recording session, even the C2C videos were closer to the music video status 

screen-shot-2017-05-25-at-6-35-25-am-149

I'm breaking the years 'cause I don't feel anything
  • LMAO 1
  • Thanks 3

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
IrishMonster
Just now, RudraCNG said:

The Lady is a Tramp next :vegas:

tenor.gif?itemid=10875831

LADY GAGA, RIHANNA & KESHA ❤️
  • LMAO 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
PinkPop

20. The Lady Is a Tramp with Tony Bennett

 

Overall Score: 4.97973

tumblr_nw88lvtBLt1ueqeo8o1_500.gif

Highest: 10 @rumours, @OpenHeartedMonster

Lowest: 0 @IrishMonster, @DesertWolf, @Cello

 

Comments:

@DiamondKing- Why was this included? Nnn still more visually pleasing than The Edge of Glory.

@Oriane - It’s a bit weird to rate it (where are C2C songs anyway?) but it’s not a bad video, it just does its job well, Tony and Gaga are cute. I love how she looks very classy and very jazz but still has her Born this Way makeup, it’s just so Gaga.

@RudraCNG-  Nothing special about it but it's nicely set up.

OpenHeartedMonster - They look so happy

@imitalian- Loved the look and their chemestry. An odd collaboration in the Middle of the BTW era but she was still on brand 

@Enzo- HER BEST VIDEO okay but I like it

@Inferno- very cute

IrishMonster - MR is more entertaining than this and I was prepared to give it my 0 until I saw this

@Talenti - I mean, it’s a jazz video... as far as videos go it really isn’t that good. (Inb4 it gets top 5)

@MANiCURE 6 - Gaga looks very good and happy here but nothing memorable.

@Andreu- it's what it had to be but this doesnt mean i like it

  • Like 2
  • YAAAS 4
  • Sad 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Curunir

TEOG next, sorry not sorry :ohwell:

Edit: nvm :neyde:

Edited by Curunir
  • LMAO 3

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Enzo

why TLIAT is here but the CTC videos aren't ?????

Lady Gaga did her own makeup in this picture but I’ll be sure to let her know how much you hate it xoxo
  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
OpenHeartedMonster

I really hope I’ll make it to the end of this ceremony. I have to do other things for next 40mins 😫

But so far I’m shocked

  • Like 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
RudraCNG

Now that we got rid of the trashy videos the megarate ceremony can actually start :vegas:

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...