ENIGMA or Coachella?

[ThisGuyTony 30,627]

Both of these shows mix her hits with fan favorites but which one did you enjoy more, whether it be the setlist, vocals, visuals, choreo, etc? 

 

[iowa cyrus 566]

Anything that has GH and DITD in the setlist is a winner, periodT!

[hausofcy 20,325]

As much as I loved her Coachella set it seemed more "polished" than enigma. She was GP friendlier which is understandable cause you're playing at a festival. With Enigma she seems to have embraced her crazy side again which i enjoy so much. Only thing missing from it is Venus squeezed in somewhere.

But the intro she did for coachella blows enigma's intro away 

[Didymus 34,379]

Enigma, by far.

Coachella started out good but after BTW it was pretty boring and unimpressive. At least with Enigma it feels like it's a show designed to entertain from start to finish. Coachella was "should I walk off to a different show" temptation imo, at Enigma I'd just have fun throughout despite being bored by some of the numbers.

[Didymus 34,379]

8 minutes ago, hausofcy said:

But the intro she did for coachella blows enigma's intro away 

Omg no That Coachella intro was so frenetic and annoyingly overblown. I adore the Enigma opening. Less is often a lot more.

Just my opinion

[ARTPOPRS 1,431]

13 minutes ago, hausofcy said:

As much as I loved her Coachella set it seemed more "polished" than enigma. She was GP friendlier which is understandable cause you're playing at a festival. With Enigma she seems to have embraced her crazy side again which i enjoy so much. Only thing missing from it is Venus squeezed in somewhere.

But the intro she did for coachella blows enigma's intro away 

I agree. Plus she started filming as Ally which is obvious in her attitude at the show (and we know how much of a method actor she is), she seemed much more friendly and... girl next door? Enigma you call tell is “Gaga”. 

[REALITY 76,602]

Coachella was great, but Enigma is a spectacle. I know a lot of people didn't like it at first (and there are still a lot of people who don't), including myself, but the show is really a grower. Once you just stop to appreciate how well it's made and just how weird, trippy, and 'GAGA' it is, you really grows on you. 

[Thomas P 18,479]

Enigma demolishes Coachella and this is coming from someone who mostly enjoyed Coachella. 

We got Ally for Coachella, and we got Gaga for Enigma 

[FentyGa 14,340]

Coachella's setlist, Enigma's visuals.

[KatieJudasGaga4 67,907]

Coachella Setlist + Aura, GH, Shallow, Judas and Paparazzi / not the Remix of MR and remove Teeth

Enigma Visuals

I prefer Enigma because it has a story line and Coachella doesn't, but loved both

[Magneto 13,432]

Enigma, but with Coachella's set list 

[gagaisitalian 3,573]

I voted Enigma simply because her Coachella performance should have been much better than it was and that's the tea. A first headlining Coachella performance for any artist should be something marvelous and at least try to be game-changing (i.e. Beyoncé). Gaga's was sadly a bit uninspired.

Now before you drag me, I enjoyed her Coachella performance and it was good. But, it should have been something that I still think about to this day. I have Bey's Coachella performance album on my iPhone and I'm still shook by the marching band arrangements and the mixing of her songs.

[blackcoffee 1,264]

Coachella, based solely on the much better setlist (weekend 1 only...Yoü and I is my fave Gaga track, so I need it in a setlist) and my preference for the visuals (I’m not a fan at all of the video game/anime/manga visuals...it’s just not my thing)

[Oriane 21,068]

So where are all the Enigma haters now ?

I'll say it again, at Coachella there was something off. The setlist is better but she didn't seem to be fully there and I can't think of another time where she was also like this.

[evgenigerm2 4,056]

35 minutes ago, gagaisitalian said:

I voted Enigma simply because her Coachella performance should have been much better than it was and that's the tea. A first headlining Coachella performance for any artist should be something marvelous and at least try to be game-changing (i.e. Beyoncé). Gaga's was sadly a bit uninspired.

You know Gaga was offered the slot like 2 weeks before the festival took place and she had 14 days to craft the whole show and then rehearse - setlist, visuals, outfits, choreograhy, vocals. Beyoncé on the other hand had more than a year.