Jump to content
question

What Song Was More Successful? Judas vs You and I


KatieJudasGaga4

Featured Posts

KatieJudasGaga4

I see people already commenting You and I, but here are my reasons :) Yes You and I sold more and is certified higher, but this is only the US. Here are my facts:

Judas-

2x Platinum- United States

Platinum- Australia

Platinum- Sweden

Silver- United Kingdom

Gold- Italy, Japan, Spain, New Zealand

 

You and I-

3x Platinum- United States

Gold- Australia, New Zealand

 

Chart Positions-

Judas

Australia- 6

Austria- 6

Belgium (F)- 6

Belgium (W)- 10

Brazil- 2

Canada- 8

Czech Republic- 10

Denmark- 10

Finland- 3

France- 5

Germany- 23

Greece- 7

Hungary- 3

Ireland- 4

Israel- 6

Italy- 3

Japan- 3

Luxembourg- 2

Netherlands- 5 

New Zealand- 12 

Norway- 3 

Portugal- 5

Scotland- 5

Slovakia- 4

South Korea- 1

Spain- 6

Sweden- 7

Switzerland- 8

United Kingdom- 8 

United States- 10

 

You and I-

Australia- 14

Austria- 8

Belgium (F)- 104

Belgium (W)- 104 

Brazil- 19

Canada- 10

Czech Republic- 26

French- 98

Germany- 21

Hungary- 24

Ireland- 32

Isreal- 5 

Italy- 19 

Japan- 8

Lebanon- 5

Netherlands- 83

New Zealand- 5

Scotland- 18

Slovakia- 18

South Korea- 66

Sweden- 32

United Kingdom- 23

United States- 6

 

Judas Spotify Streams: 60,769,692

You and I Spotify Streams: 48,896,683

 

Judas Youtube Views- 305,566,412

You and I Youtube Views- 129,869,221

 

Judas has appeared in more Year-End Lists than You and I, but You and I has the longevity in charts, but Judas peaked higher.

What Do You guys think?

 

tumblr_p5e8z9ePvd1qff2ilo6_500.gif       vs      tumblr_mj1pywYrwL1ra0d77o1_500.gif

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 42
  • Created
  • Last Reply
SlaeUrAnus

I would say Judas.

Despite it ‘flopping’, it was still a top 10 hit internationally, but I think You and I is the better song, and it aged better too imo. 

However, if Judas was released as the lead single, it would have smashed. 

In my messy era.
Link to post
Share on other sites

REALITY

Well according to the numbers, obviously Judas, but a lot of my classmates say that they've heard and loved You and I, and tbh most of them haven't heard of Judas. So from a more pragmatic point of view, You and I, but from a statistical point of view, Judas.

Also, Judas was really controversial so I don't know if you'd really qualify that was "more successful."

🦠🧙‍♀️🥀📸🎉👻🕺🧟💊💖☎️🔪👤🐺🌱🌎
Link to post
Share on other sites

My Enigma Heart

Tbh, Judas is almost like a household song name in my country but not for the right reasons. It was controversial, yes. So I guess it's more successful. I still remember the backlash. Oh, the backlash... :messga:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Pop Music

Judas even though It was so controversial. But after the BTW era ended I have heard You and I on the radio MUCH more than judas. So judas was more successful but You and I had better longevity 

Pop Music and Lady Gaga forever!
Link to post
Share on other sites

KatieJudasGaga4

I never heard You and I on the radio and I live in the US lol, I heard Judas a lot when it was released until radios stopped playing it.:messga:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Heard Judas more than You and I, never knew You and I existed until my cousin sang it in the karaoke :messga: Judas is so controversial in here lol

GAGA || TAYLOR || BJÖRK || KENDRICK || LANA || NICKI || MADONNA || KANYE || BEYONCÉ || MARIAH || MCR || KATE || RINA || CHARLI || FIONA
Link to post
Share on other sites

KatieJudasGaga4
12 minutes ago, SlaeUrAnus said:

I would say Judas.

Despite it ‘flopping’, it was still a top 10 hit internationally, but I think You and I is the better song, and it aged better too imo. 

However, if Judas was released as the lead single, it would have smashed. 

Wouldn't call Judas a flop tho, G.U.Y and Marry The Night are great songs, but they flopped. Judas underperformed, but flop is like Slumber Party flop (I love the song, deserved better). Like Judas did very well in Spain and South Korea and debuted in the top 10 in over twenty countries and reaching the top 10 in 30+ countries and is 2x Platinum, wouldn't necessarily say it flopped, just underperformed than usual.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Luke78619

Worldwide, I think Judas, I don't think too many people have heard of You and I in the U.K. 

insta: good_lukeing | I have nothing else to promote
Link to post
Share on other sites

KatieJudasGaga4
4 minutes ago, Widows Kiss said:

My flop country paying dust to Judas. :madge:

Germany ?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Reginald

The GP in my area of the US absolutely devoured You and I. I've sang it at karaoke several times and the whole bar always knows every word. 

Same with Million Reasons. 

Personally, I prefer Judas though. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

AVeryGagaHolyDick

World wide, Judas of course. It sadly didn't have any longevity though

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...