If Gaga Released A "Greatest Hits" Album...

[Gagaloo911 12,959]

Agreed with OP, minus Judas and DWUW I think and with 2 or 3 new songs. 

[KatieJudasGaga4 67,907]

3 minutes ago, Gagaloo92 said:

Agreed with OP, minus Judas and DWUW I think and with 2 or 3 new songs. 

Judas was a hit tho, a bigger one than You and I & Million Reasons.

[Gagaloo911 12,959]

2 minutes ago, KatieJudasGaga4 said:

Judas was a hit tho, a bigger one than You and I & Million Reasons.

Yea but I'm not so sure about 4 singles from BTW and I think Gaga would go with it over Judas. But who knows.

Then there has to be something on there from Joanne and MR was the only real hit from it. 

[culturalbaptism 2,283]

13 minutes ago, KatieJudasGaga4 said:

Is "The Cure" a hit ?

No, it's a streaming hit.

[KatieJudasGaga4 67,907]

22 minutes ago, Gagaloo92 said:

Yea but I'm not so sure about 4 singles from BTW and I think Gaga would go with it over Judas. But who knows.

Then there has to be something on there from Joanne and MR was the only real hit from it. 

I put 4 singles from The Fame tho..Also, Judas is appreciated more outside the US.

[RichAssPiss 4,472]

Gaga has had 15 official singles (not including charting promo singles) that peaked in the top 20 of the Hot 100. I think that is exactly the right number of songs and threshold for inclusion. Leaves room for two or three new songs. 

1. Just Dance

2. Poker Face

3. LoveGame

4. Paparazzi

5. Bad Romance

6. Telephone

7. Alejandro

8. Born This Way

9. Judas

10. The Edge of Glory

11. You and I

12. Applause

13. Do What U Want

14. Perfect Illusion

15. Million Reasons

[Gagaloo911 12,959]

8 minutes ago, KatieJudasGaga4 said:

I put 4 singles from The Fame tho..Also, Judas is appreciate more outside the US.

I mean that's true. To be fair though, BTW wasn't as big as The Fame and The Fame was HUGE so I could see all its singles getting on a greatest hits album.

[Bradley 56,422]

I actually don't like the idea of a greatest hits album, it feels like an easy way to make money without offering anything new.

[NNES 5,769]

1. Born This Way

2. Bad Romance

3. Paparazzi

4. LoveGame

5. Judas

6. Poker Face

7. Just Dance

8. Alejandro

9. Applause

10. Do What U Want (Xtina Version)

11. Yoü and I

12. Telephone

13. The Cure

14. Million Reasons

15. The Edge of Glory

[InsomniaMonster69 2,953]

1. Bad romance (remastered)

2. Telephone (remastered)

3. Pokerface (remastered)

4. Just dance (remastered) 

5. Born this way (remastered)

6. Applause (remastered)

7. Do what u want (feat. Xtina)

8. The cure (AMA version)

9. Yoü and I (remastered)

10. Papparazzi (VMA version)

11. Perfect Illusion 

12. Marry the night (acoustic)

13. The edge of glory (acoustic)

14. Million reasons (JWT version)

15. Till it happens to you 

16. Alejandro (remastered)

17. John Wayne 

18. Judas (remastered)

19. G.U.Y. (remastered)

20. Lovegame (TFMB tour version)

 

 

[Hyperballad 4,268]

1. Poker Face 

2. Alejandro 

3. Just Dance 

4. Telephone 

5. Born This Way 

6. Paparazzi 

7. The Edge of Glory 

8. Bad Romance 

9. Applause 

10. LoveGame 

11.  Judas 

12. Million Reasons (maybe just U.S. and U.K. Editions? ) 

13. New Single #1 

14. New Single #2 

[FfFfFfFF 54,014]

6 hours ago, KatieJudasGaga4 said:

Judas was a hit tho, a bigger one than You and I & Million Reasons.

Internationally yes.

OT: The tracklist for a greatest hit album will have for sure: Just Dance, Poker Face, LoveGame, Paparazzi, Bad Romance, Telephone, Alejandro, Born This Way, The Edge of Glory, You and I, Applause and Million Reasons

Other options with less probability: The Cure, Do What U want (solo or featuring Christina Aguilera) - but I doubt she still wants to give attention to this track because of controversy anyway, Perfect Illusion

Other options with even less probability: Judas, Marry The Night, Hair, Venus, Dope, Eh Eh (Nothing Else), Speechless, Joanne (Piano Version), A-YO

As fan favorites she could add Dance In The Dark, Teeth, Mary Jane Holland, Venus, Bloody Mary, Scheisse or Joanne.

And also some new songs.

 

[iCpro 14,846]

I’d prefer it to include some of the biggest fan favourites too, because they’re just a different type of “hit” in my opinion:

1. Just Dance

2. Poker Face

3. LoveGame

4. Paparazzi

5. Bad Romance

6. Telephone (ft Beyoncé)

7. Alejandro 

8. Dance In The Dark

9. Born This Way

10. Judas

11. Scheiße

12. The Edge Of Glory 

13. Yoü and I

14. Marry The Night

15. Applause

16. Venus

17. Do What U Want (ft Christina Aguilera)

18. Perfect Illusion

19. The Cure

20. Million Reasons

 

I know that’s quite long so maybe a standard edition could cut some of the lesser hits and fan favourites out.

[Gagadonna 10,801]

1. Bad Romance

2. Poker Face

3. Paparazzi 

4. Telephone

5. Alejandro

6. Born this Way 

7. The Cure 

8. Just Dance

9. Applause

10. The Edge of Glory

11. Million Reasons 

[Suspiria 10,683]

I think in this age of streaming and Youtube a greatest hits album is kind of redundant. Everyone can easily access any of these songs, even if they didn't own the album it came out on.

A greatest hits album would just mean she had duplicates of each song on her spotify.