Charts Discussion - Pre-order 'A Star Is Born' soundtrack!

[Madam Margolyes 7,783]

wtf does this tweet even mean 

[GABEL 1,853]

2 minutes ago, Madam Margolyes said:

wtf does this tweet even mean 

it means it's weird but in a good way

[bloody g 31,746]

3 minutes ago, Madam Margolyes said:

wtf does this tweet even mean 

I like it, the more the controversy the bigger the buzz. Better than "oh this movie is going to be huge". I would totally watch a movie with that description. Let's see what other people have to say about it.

[Madam Margolyes 7,783]

 

[mister max 18,480]

The second screening started

[bloody g 31,746]

Btw tag yourself, I'm girl crying and saying "I believe in love again" 

[gag 22,449]

Two differing reactions from two people on AwardsWatch:

"I just came out from the screening. Sad to say the film it is not good; some likeable moments, but the direction is pretty didascalic and the story itself is... ordinary (the way Cooper handled it). It’s very close to the Streisand version, and has all its strength in Gaga’s good performance. Never heard her so powerful, vocally. And acting is decent, too. 2 out of 5 for me, nothing memorable. And Legend Elliot is WASTED. He’s so magnetic in the few scenes he’s given."

"****. I don't know if the exhaustion amplifies this but have to wipe away tears before Coen after this one, seriously extremely moved by the beautiful and devastating chemistry between the two leads. The film is far from being flawless though."

[Bradley 59,226]

2 minutes ago, gag said:

"I just came out from the screening. Sad to say the film it is not good; some likeable moments, but the direction is pretty didascalic and the story itself is... ordinary (the way Cooper handled it). It’s very close to the Streisand version, and has all its strength in Gaga’s good performance. Never heard her so powerful, vocally. And acting is decent, too. 2 out of 5 for me, nothing memorable. And Legend Elliot is WASTED. He’s so magnetic in the few scenes he’s given."

This gives me anxiety.

[nattuggla 21,799]

Tbh I think that ASIB overall won't be highly praised (higher than 90 on RT and MC) however it could still end up good like in the range of high 70/low 80.... I just don't want to have too high expectations and get disappointed afterwards.... 

[gag 22,449]

I'd say overall consensus is positive but not huge acclaim... which was to be expected TBH. I'm just glad people are really liking the music.

[nattuggla 21,799]

Just now, gag said:

I'd say overall consensus is positive but not huge acclaim... which was to be expected TBH. I'm just glad people are really liking the music.

 

14 minutes ago, gag said:

Two differing reactions from two people on AwardsWatch:

"I just came out from the screening. Sad to say the film it is not good; some likeable moments, but the direction is pretty didascalic and the story itself is... ordinary (the way Cooper handled it). It’s very close to the Streisand version, and has all its strength in Gaga’s good performance. Never heard her so powerful, vocally. And acting is decent, too. 2 out of 5 for me, nothing memorable. And Legend Elliot is WASTED. He’s so magnetic in the few scenes he’s given."

"****. I don't know if the exhaustion amplifies this but have to wipe away tears before Coen after this one, seriously extremely moved by the beautiful and devastating chemistry between the two leads. The film is far from being flawless though."

Yeah there is another one from Awardswatch:

The movie was just okay. I was bored sometimes. Bradley is good, Sam Elliott is great. GaGa she’s a great singer but I am not impressed at all by her performance.

[Bradley 59,226]

2 minutes ago, gag said:

I'd say overall consensus is positive but not huge acclaim... which was to be expected TBH. I'm just glad people are really liking the music.

I think we should wait for official reviews instead of just reading Twitter tweets.

[Fame IV 4,426]

4 minutes ago, Bradley said:

I think we should wait for official reviews instead of just reading Twitter tweets.

Exacly. There will be tons of opinions, keep in mind every critic is subjective.

[Fame IV 4,426]

7 minutes ago, nattuggla said:

 

Yeah there is another one from Awardswatch:

The movie was just okay. I was bored sometimes. Bradley is good, Sam Elliott is great. GaGa she’s a great singer but I am not impressed at all by her performance.

How can we trust a person that still writes "GaGa"? Critics don't do their homework...

[Azor Ahai 18,861]

Ugh I'm so worried!!! Here's hopin for at least 70 on Rotten and Metacritic!