Can Gaga really afford to make another non-pop album?

[ryanripley 86,575]

1 minute ago, AndyGa said:

It's simple af without being sensitive he said he wanted RockGa I said PopGa is better 

Plus lets be real All Gaga's career is either solely pop or pop influenced (aside from 2014) she's a pop artist are we gonna force ourselves to love another genre because our queen switched to 

And yes I know Gaga so well she's my life idol but when it comes to her career I know she was on top of the world when she was unique artistic and experimental within her limits and the other side of her that took herself so serious as the goddess of love acted as she's 60 and recorded Jazz (which I still totally admire tho because she's Gaga duh) and ya'll call it experimental af received the weakest sales lowest reviews and mostly negative reception. So it's ok to say we want the POP queen to slay.

Well that went serious and awkward but " do you know who lady gaga is ? " annoyed me as the popga is better thing to you 

but to some of us think rockga is better  which was my point

walking around like your opinion is fact gets annoying fast  

[AndyGa 322]

43 minutes ago, SolidSnake said:

What is with people on this site and hits? Shes already passed into the status of cultural icon, she doesnt need hits to survive. She will still sell out shows regardless, and people will still pay huge bucks to book her. You people just want to stick to generic club dance songs and its annoying. Shes much more talented and versatile than that. Stick with Ariana Grande she is more your speed. I dont mean that as an insult, I legitimately am recommending her, she gets hits, she stays in the pop girl box, and has a ton of rap features. That is clearly what Gaga is trying to avoid and her fans should support her in the endeavor  

She's 32 not 60. First she won't survive with 10 yo hits for long. Secondly she's abandoning her talent if she depended on her older hits and not using her talent to be an A lister as a musician and a voice in the world when she's still so young. Or that quote is the new excuse .

[AndyGa 322]

6 minutes ago, ryanripley said:

but to some of us think rockga is better  which was my point

walking around like your opinion is fact gets annoying fast  

Ok Ryan you're a culture icon here so I'll lose anyway 

Now go stream BTW aka her best album 

[ryanripley 86,575]

Just now, AndyGa said:

Ok Ryan you're a culture icon here so I'll lose anyway 

Now go stream BTW aka her best album 

i already streamed Joanne  

[Bling 31,377]

Yes. 

/thread

[Pacify Him 9,073]

She should do either rock, metal, or experimental tbh

Pop music is so bad as long as it has Ariana Grande all over it. Pop music is over

[AndyGa 322]

2 minutes ago, ryanripley said:

i already streamed Joanne  

Good still will give her money to create LG6 aka BTW 2 

[ChvVolk 2,306]

BTW is super experimental and has a bit of RockGa so idk why I keep reading that BTW is solely pop. It is her best record tho. 

[SolidSnake 2,804]

15 minutes ago, AndyGa said:

She's 32 not 60. First she won't survive with 10 yo hits for long. Secondly she's abandoning her talent if she depended on her older hits and not using her talent to be an A lister as a musician and a voice in the world when she's still so young. Or that quote is the new excuse .

My point is she if she keeps experimenting and gaining the favor of music critics and fans in other genres she wont need hits, She will become extremely respected and each one of her albums will get hype. She doesnt need hits to stay relevant with the GP and culture as a whole. You have A LOT of reading to do. 

[SolidSnake 2,804]

1 minute ago, ChavaWM said:

BTW is super experimental and has a bit of RockGa so idk why I keep reading that BTW is solely pop. It is her best record tho. 

BTW is not experimental lol. Tbh none of her stuff is THAT experimental. ARTPOP is the closest. 

[SolidSnake 2,804]

19 minutes ago, ryanripley said:

but to some of us think rockga is better  which was my point

walking around like your opinion is fact gets annoying fast  

Ryan my attitude is rubbing off on you! Be careful!

[ryanripley 86,575]

Just now, SolidSnake said:

Ryan my attitude is rubbing off on you! Be careful!

king, i've been like this since day 1

i used to be worse, i have the WPs to prove it

i am now toned down, calm, constructive, patient, the elusive chanteuse

[giskardsb 12,565]

20 minutes ago, AndyGa said:

She's 32 not 60. First she won't survive with 10 yo hits for long. Secondly she's abandoning her talent if she depended on her older hits and not using her talent to be an A lister as a musician and a voice in the world when she's still so young. Or that quote is the new excuse .

The funny thing is that you consider pop music to be the best expression of her talent.  

[AndyGa 322]

11 minutes ago, SolidSnake said:

My point is she if she keeps experimenting and gaining the favor of music critics and fans in other genres she wont need hits, She will become extremely respected and each one of her albums will get hype. She doesnt need hits to stay relevant with the GP and culture as a whole. You have A LOT of reading to do. 

All I know is the last time she tried to be experimental ARTPOP happened and that made her lose a lot most important thing is her health so I don't see how critics favoured her. Don't let Joanne fool you it's a beautiful album but it's not that messy aka " experimental " and that's why she got positive reviews good sales too but not ground breaking . That's the most suitable time for her to come back real BIG in music and continue a streak of huge success after the healing process for her and her reputation with Joanne no time to try new messy stuff or keep living in the shadows of Poker Face and Born This Way. Also the fans of different genres aren't so welcoming for a new artist stepping into there scene they take it as a desperate or flop attempt.

[AndyGa 322]

9 minutes ago, giskardsb said:

The funny thing is that you consider pop music to be the best expression of her talent.  

Bad Romance and Born This way are mainly pop so yes I do . And 90% of people agree that that's her best and most acclaimed work.