People drag Gaga for the dumbest reasons...

[Chamaquito 1,186]

Beyoncé debuted “Formation” at the Super Bowl. Its peak position was #10 (three months later). Justin Timberlake debuted “Filthy” at the SB. Its peak position was #9. Gaga debuted “Million Reasons.” And its peak position was #4If I were you, I wouldn’t pay mind to anyone

[dollardays 3,866]

2 minutes ago, TheShameMonster said:

How can life be what they want it to be...

You're frozen, when your Stan card is showing 

[LittleMonster20 9,858]

Just now, MaryJaneHolland said:

Yes, it is. MR was one.

Let's just call it 'former-underperformance' then because it turned out succesful eventually.

[Ziggy 11,867]

7 minutes ago, Sirius094 said:

The superbowl would have happened in any case, Joanne or not. Let's not act like she got the Superbowl because of Joanne or the Superbowl was a part of the Era  and Million Reasons before the Superbowl was a flop (peaking at #52 on the BBHOT100)

Except that it warrants mentioning that a lot of her time and resources were devoted to the Super Bowl so we can't say what promo would have looked like without it since, seemingly, it was all tailored to fit around her schedule for that.

[corvus albus 38,031]

1 minute ago, Chamaquito said:

Beyoncé debuted Formation at the Super Bowl. It’s peak position was #10. Justin Timberlake debuted Filthy at the SB. It’s peak position was #9. Gaga debuted Million Reasons. And it’s peak position was #4If I were you, I wouldn’t pay mind to anyone

Well Filthy actually debuted on #9 before the SB. After its debut it tumbled down the charts. After the SB it reached #53 again to hold it one more week on the Hot 100.

[Chamaquito 1,186]

2 minutes ago, corvus albus said:

Well Filthy actually debuted on #9 before the SB. After its debut it tumbled down the charts. After the SB it reached #53 again to hold it one more week on the Hot 100.

Which is worse because after the SB, I would’ve expected the song to peak higher than how it did in January.

[corvus albus 38,031]

Just now, Chamaquito said:

Which is worse because after the SB, I would’ve expected the song to peak higher than what it did in January.

I know

Spoiler

I even liked the song

 

[shame 25,360]

15 minutes ago, Yo GagaGaga said:

I mean they said that they picked her immediately after they heard Joanne, so its not like it had nothing to do with it. And Million Reasons going from a peak of #52 to #4 just proves the OP's point that it didn't flop bc people didn't like it, it just didn't have the exposure it needed to be successful

THIS. You put it in a better way in less than 3 sentences

[Mikolaj 11,635]

People drag Gaga for the dumbest reasons because they do not have any legit ones  one can't whine about meat dress forever

[Schizophonic 7,015]

over here in germany people still come up with a possible p*nis and the schnizel dress to drag gaga.

[LGMonster95 13,704]

I have a twitter account for like 7 years and one thing that i learned from it is that stan twitter is garbage, toxic etc if it's one aritst that has their moment on a specific time most people would do anything to put them down so then they could praise their favs, most of the time inventing all kinds of idiotic excuses. There's a reason why Gaga had the biggest boost in sales after the SB, it's because she did an AMAZING show, this success wasn't handed to herself, she EARN it. And by the way the very same people were saying before her Super Bowl that if she performs Million Reasons she's gonna make everyone bored, that the song will flop even more because "this type of songs doesn't work for SB" guess who laughed later and also guess who's mad right now and inventing more excuses....

[Eggsy 8,280]

It all started with the Meat Dress.. 

Spoiler

ps @Chamaquito not to sound thirsty but is that you in the profile pic?

 

[shame 25,360]

1 hour ago, LGMonster95 said:

I have a twitter account for like 7 years and one thing that i learned from it is that stan twitter is garbage, toxic etc if it's one aritst that has their moment on a specific time most people would do anything to put them down so then they could praise their favs, most of the time inventing all kinds of idiotic excuses. There's a reason why Gaga had the biggest boost in sales after the SB, it's because she did an AMAZING show, this success wasn't handed to herself, she EARN it. And by the way the very same people were saying before her Super Bowl that if she performs Million Reasons she's gonna make everyone bored, that the song will flop even more because "this type of songs doesn't work for SB" guess who laughed later and also guess who's mad right now and inventing more excuses....

This times a thousand. I bet those little chartsters dragging MR and praying she doesn't sing it at the SB are the same ones defending and worshipping that song for saving the era  Queen of always breaking everyone's expectations and proving them wrong  

Btw, I didn't know u ran that account! It's one of the few Gaga accounts I followed all the time before I joined this cult site 

[Matangi 3,050]

2 hours ago, SolidSnake said:

Look I've worked at major stores whose main business is CDs. During my time only TWO albums received such a large push to the point where everyone wanted copies. 25 and Joanne. No other pop albums came close.

well that's cool for your store, but that's totally anecdotal evidence. Numbers would say otherwise...

In the US, 25 sold about 20 times more than Joanne in its first week. 3.4 million to 170 thousand

[LGMonster95 13,704]

16 minutes ago, TheShameMonster said:

This times a thousand. I bet those little chartsters dragging MR and praying she doesn't sing it at the SB are the same ones defending and worshipping that song for saving the era  Queen of always breaking everyone's expectations and proving them wrong  

Btw, I didn't know u ran that account! It's one of the few Gaga accounts I followed all the time before I joined this cult site 

Oh thanks, that means a lot