Jump to content
question

Did Gaga lie again?


Notthebling

Featured Posts

Notthebling

So I listened to the MTN demo recently (http://picosong.com/Wnav/), which sounds almost like a first draft from the song. Piano session, and signing few lyrics, but the song was in early production.

However, if I remember correctly, Gaga stated in an interview (that I can't find), that MTN was created with Fernando Garibay, who played her the beat. She said she started crying and started signing... She said the lyrics came to her mind right away, and that was how the song was created. 

There is NO beat in what we hear. I do believe that, when creating the song, the stripped down version comes first (piano-voice), and then you add the beat,synths,drum to it.

I can't picture this session being recorded after Gaga heard the instrumental Garibay had created.

 

Is this too much of a reach, of was the story of how MTN was created a romanticized lie from Gaga?

Discuss. 

Dat - doo - deet - doe. Dat - doo - deet - doe, dat - doo - deet - doe. Baby let's get high, John Wayne
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 36
  • Created
  • Last Reply
TheFameMoister

latest?cb=20161126134955

Gaga? Lie? Why, she'd never do that...

 

:trollga:

Buy The Fame Moister on iTunes
Link to post
Share on other sites

Ryusei

My thought is (because of the file names) that that was a recording session maybe or more of a session to focus on how they want the vocals to be and stuff like that. I mean.. why would she lie about that 

Musery
Link to post
Share on other sites

SpookyKid

this is a recording session, not the FIRST recording

Life has a hopeful undertone |-/
Link to post
Share on other sites

LordEnigma

I mean, she probably meant that when she heard the beat - it was a "aha!" moment.

Dont take everything so literal :selena:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Notthebling
3 minutes ago, Alexander Levi said:

I mean, she probably meant that when she heard the beat - it was a "aha!" moment.

Dont take everything so literal :selena:

 

Just now, Marine Olerk said:

why would gaga lie about that ?

Omg you guys are so rude i'm so sorry i wanted to discuss this. This is a Gaga forum, this is a place for us to discuss and exchange because I doubt i could ask this to any of my friends. 

Seriously the amount of rudeness here is unbelievable :fthis:

Dat - doo - deet - doe. Dat - doo - deet - doe, dat - doo - deet - doe. Baby let's get high, John Wayne
Link to post
Share on other sites

JoanneMonster

Gaga really needs to do something interesting so you guys stop doing threads like this :toofunny:

I See You
Link to post
Share on other sites

Marine Olerk
Just now, Notthebling said:

 

Omg you guys are so rude i'm so sorry i wanted to discuss this. This is a Gaga forum, this is a place for us to discuss and exchange because I doubt i could ask this to any of my friends. 

Seriously the amount of rudeness here is unbelievable :fthis:

 JpT8aK1.gif

Link to post
Share on other sites

LordEnigma
Just now, Notthebling said:

 

Omg you guys are so rude i'm so sorry i wanted to discuss this. This is a Gaga forum, this is a place for us to discuss and exchange because I doubt i could ask this to any of my friends. 

Seriously the amount of rudeness here is unbelievable :fthis:

I was explaining it? :selena:

dont be so sensitive over something that wasn't even sassy to begin with :selena:

Link to post
Share on other sites

AVeryGagaHolyDick
1 minute ago, Notthebling said:

 

Omg you guys are so rude i'm so sorry i wanted to discuss this. This is a Gaga forum, this is a place for us to discuss and exchange because I doubt i could ask this to any of my friends. 

Seriously the amount of rudeness here is unbelievable :fthis:

Nothing's rude though :excited2:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Oriane

This is clearly not the moment of creation, the song is almost finished and she's testing and asjusting a few things before the final recording (I believe some parts are actually in the final recording).

The only GGD member who can read / Credits to Celloo Deng for the profile pic!
Link to post
Share on other sites

Blade
11 minutes ago, Ryusei said:

My thought is (because of the file names) that that was a recording session maybe or more of a session to focus on how they want the vocals to be and stuff like that. I mean.. why would she lie about that 

I agree with you but I also think that the lyrics maybe didn't come to her right away. When she heared the beat she probably got an overall idea about the song & some lyrics but I doubt that she had every lyric in her head right away.

Link to post
Share on other sites

JustaMonster
2 minutes ago, vocalqueef said:

I agree with you but I also think that the lyrics maybe didn't come to her right away. When she heared the beat she probably got an overall idea about the song & some lyrics but I doubt that she had every lyric in her head right away.

Yeah its the same when she says she wrote Just Dance in 10 minutes. It doesnt mean the song was written, recorded, and produced in 10 minutes it just means she had an idea of the lyrics she wanted to add as well as stuff like the chord proression and overall sound of the song.

Hands up to the sky, I'm about to fly!
Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...