Rate Joanne

[Irrelevant 20,282]

Spoiler

1. Diamond Heart - 10

2. A-Yo - 10

3. Joanne - 10

4. John Wayne - 10

5. Dancin' In Circles - 10

6. Perfect Illusion - 10

7. Million Reasons - 8

8. Sinner's Prayer - 8

9. Come To Mama - 7

10. Hey Girl - 4

11. Angel Down - 10

12. Grigio Girls - 10

13. Just Another Day - 10

A solid 9 for me  But I don't listen to it that much, but (most) of the songs are great  Just not replay material for me 

[Irrelevant 20,282]

29 minutes ago, Torsoface said:

8. Angle Down

 

When your protractor falls to the ground but the people just stand around

[heygirl 842]

1 hour ago, Venusfly said:

It's a 6 for me.

I really do appreciate the raw unfiltered vibe the album gave, you can tell she had a lot of fun making it and how uncalculated it is, it's just a compilation of some tracks she felt like doing that don't necessarily tie into a specific theme.

That's also kinda where it falls for me though, it doesn't feel like an album 3 years in the making and I felt like it came at the wrong time in her career, it was set to be a huge deciding moment not just in her career but in the pop music atmosphere

I also as a personal preference just don't really enjoy the genres, but that's not her problem. I was kinda hoping for a hard rock kinda theme and I remember the 3 second PI snippet got me hyped up to that because I thought all my anticipations were true

Overall its a solid album but it just isnt tied together as much as I'd like it to be and I'm not a fan of the genres, but I think it's still a good addition to her discography and it certainly lives up to her other albums despite its differences.

this. (although I still adore PI)

[Fernster7 7,922]

9, without a doubt. It's my favorite Gaga album after Born This Way and I would give it a 10 if Perfect Illusion and Hey Girl didn't exist. 

[crisTEAne 21,059]

9.

the reasons it's not perfect for me are that

(1) it took a few weeks for a-yo to grow on me; 

(2) sometimes i can listen to hey girl and feel the vibe it's radiating, sometimes i must skip it;

(3) grigio girl is the epitome of emotional ambivalence: there was a time when i was listening to it on repeat, but now i'm only able to listen to it when i'm in a certain mood. 

otherwise, DH and JAD are probably in my top10 gagz songs.

[lost in limbo 6,035]

9.5

It's an amazing, fun, yet sad album that Gaga loved to do, and I love every single song in it, but it's no. 4 in my overall Gaga albums list (TFM, ARTPOP and BTW rule bish, bye).

[Mary Jane Wayne 1,997]

1 hour ago, OMonster said:

7.5

  Hide contents

The first half of the album would get an 8 from me... but the second half (minus Angel Down and Sinners Prayer) probably falls to about a 5 or 6. Hey Girl, Just Another Day, Come To Mama, Grigio Girls... they're all very solid songs and I absolutely love listening to them - but they're just not very Gaga to me. They're just songs. Nothing special.

The holy trinity of John Wayne, Dancing in Circles and Perfect Illusion easily makes it a worthwhile album, though. You've then got Diamond Heart, A-Yo and Million Reasons... they are also really impressive, too. 

 

 

Hey Girl, Sinners Prayer, Angel Down are AMAZING. Come To Mama is kind of...trash