Huffington Post: Something Was Off About Lady Gaga’s VSFS Performance

[shane_c 480]

Sounds like she tried to change the way she sings the song I guess because its a runway. She freestyled some parts and it didn't work. Some parts really do sound pretty bad. She should have just sung it normal.

[Rugbyguy 144]

11 hours ago, asana15 said:

How can a self-respected "journalist" write a legitimate article based on a YouTube-posted and then "quickly removed" performance anyway? It's like a detective would base his case on a evidence that doesn't exist. The show officially hasn't even air yet, but this kind of careless, haste statement is already shaping up public opinion. How do you know, which song, what performance will make the final cut on Monday? CBS, Interscope should take stand against such irresponsible unacceptable "reviewing".

Your being a tad naive here man. Everyone is entitled to an opinion. The general consensus is that it wasn't her best performance. You can't blame the journalist. 

[shane_c 480]

It actually sounds better unedited than it does in clips.

[high heeled fem 3]

13 hours ago, RainbowBlonde said:

Even Perez Hilton praised her performance 

welll there u go LOL!!! it means huff can **** off

 

but song sounmds odd is it a diff version of the song

[He8MyHeart 9,765]

Just watched it and it does sound a little flat to me. But by no means a 'bad' performance.

[aaronyoji 2,054]

well it was off. the tone of the overall performance and what she tried to do to the song that's already set in its sub categories of genres, ended up hindering the performance. it was pitchy, her runs where unnecessary, runs are NOT a symbol of vocal talent. no. they aren't. just because you can tumble around a note in key doesn't make you talented. 

[Galactic Mess 1,393]

Not her best vocally, but it was still very good, and the setting and outfits were gorgeous.

They've obviously published this just to get our clicks lol

But they ain't getting mine 

[monsterdino 31,991]

Why yall shading Huffington Post when yall said the same thing when the video came out?

Like wtf?  I don't understand u guys....

[Bt1 5,213]

They are right. Something wasnt right. 

[SEANGT 5,263]

She got lost in the song. Didn't have enough rehearsal probably. Simple as that. Her talent was shining but the way the song was laid out was awkward

[NewYorkCity 10,536]

Tbh she was off at some points. But she also delivered really good vocal moments. 

The only problem of this performance is when you compare it to her own performances. Still slays her contemporanies. 

[Whispering 18,865]

Yet, the video of this performance is going viral and MR has jumped up on iTunes.

The GP and casual fans are enjoying the performance. 

[Red 97,982]

Million Reasons, that's what is "off"

[Phoenix 17,395]

Ha dope vocals slowly getting her

[Joshie S 6,068]

Yeah I noticed she was a bit off, but she still pulled it off, in her own Gaga way. I think we just expect so much from her so we notice her flaws a lot more than everyone else.