Huffington Post: Something Was Off About Lady Gaga’s VSFS Performance

[Bad Monster Kid 13,140]

Just now, Delusional Aura said:

What's wrong with Judas? . Don't come for the revelations of the Bible you demon! ! ! 

Nothing. It's in my top 3.

I'm saying it cause he is a fan yet put out this article. He's Judas. 

[asana15 16,648]

How can a self-respected "journalist" write a legitimate article based on a YouTube-posted and then "quickly removed" performance anyway? It's like a detective would base his case on a evidence that doesn't exist. The show officially hasn't even air yet, but this kind of careless, haste statement is already shaping up public opinion. How do you know, which song, what performance will make the final cut on Monday? CBS, Interscope should take stand against such irresponsible unacceptable "reviewing".

[tonythewitch 450]

The only weird thing is not from gaga, but the concept of singing while models are walking the runway is so strange to me.
https://vk.com/video390240078_456239026

[MJHolland 12,725]

1 hour ago, Bad Monster Kid said:

Not her strongest but not her worst. I'd give that to the Perfect Illusion acoustic she did during some radio interview.(Ryan Seacrests show I think)

That doesn't count as a performance lol 

Im a Gaga super fan and I haven't even heard it.

[Fahs 183]

They're right. It wasn't as good as Gaga can make it sound. There were times she was off-key. 

[Bad Monster Kid 13,140]

3 minutes ago, MJHolland said:

That doesn't count as a performance lol 

Im a Gaga super fan and I haven't even heard it.

Well consider yourself lucky. 

[Whispering 18,865]

I've only heard and seen sections and it seemed fine. Where is this full version that people here have heard? 

[Bad Monster Kid 13,140]

8 minutes ago, Whispering said:

I've only heard and seen sections and it seemed fine. Where is this full version that people here have heard? 

It's been taken down already. 

[SummerGirl21 787]

2 hours ago, MJHolland said:

It quite fair considering it was the worst performance vocally she's had the entire era, and probably for the past few years of we're counting c2c 

Mess at the fans who think Gaga can do no wrong, it was pitchy and underwhelming 

agreed. She was sharp most of the time. **** happens. 

[Emvee 8,367]

2 hours ago, Bradley Cooper said:

I listened to that performance for 5 times to see what was less satisfying in comparison with other Million Reasons performances and I realised that the biggest factor is how she wasn't on sync with the instrumental. I'm not sure what caused that because that's a problem only Rihanna usually has, never Gaga, so I'm guessing she's either too nervous, which is again, unusual considering she performed at the Superbowl, Grammys, Oscars which are way bigger shows or didn't have time to rehearse properly for that performance considering she's preparing her halftime show, or it could be a technical problem within her earpiece.

The other thing that would've improved the performance which is not her fault is the volume of the mic, I find the instrumental way louder than the vocals, so hopefully the VEVO performance will fix that because remember the VEVO Dive Bar videos are way better in terms of audio than the livestream's. But taking into account all these, I think she needs more practice because her idea of changing the melodies a bit is actually fresh and interesting. It just needs polishing.

I think the problem is that Million Reasons is an unusually slow song for Gaga coupled with high energy settings... she naturally wants to speed it up, but it comes across as rushed. 

[Whispering 18,865]

1 hour ago, Bad Monster Kid said:

It's been taken down already. 

 I found it and watched it twice. There were a handful of off notes, but nothing to write an article over. Actually, I found the version to be both interesting and enjoyable. 

Also, the interaction with the angels added to the overall presentation and performance. I don't know what this guy was talking about with this complaint. I've seen this guy's name and pic on another harsh and uncalled for article during this era. 

[Oriane 20,953]

"her rendition on the runway left much to be desired vocally"

I'm sorry WHAT ? Her vocals are still getting better and better, and this performance showed some new skills we didn't hear from her previously.

[Jamie 608]

I have to admit that she is off-key at the end of most verses... 

 

 

[Delusional Aura 5,129]

2 hours ago, Bad Monster Kid said:

Nothing. It's in my top 3.

I'm saying it cause he is a fan yet put out this article. He's Judas. 

Oh okay... Makes sense 

[MJHolland 12,725]

1 hour ago, SummerGirl21 said:

agreed. She was sharp most of the time. **** happens. 

Exactly. Doesn't mean she isn't a killer performer, but we can't ignore when it's not as good as I could be