Closed: Chart Discussion: Joanne / Million Reasons

[mister max 18,480]

Was UK chart thread active tho?

I vote for general chart thread and gaga chart thread seperate!

[Haroon 49,685]

Just now, SomethingMore said:

Some members actually contacted Arturo and even tagged him here but he ignored them, so it's great you stopped by, thanks for your help! 

Aww that's alright  If there's ever an issue or a suggestion about how this is run or anything then definitely do bring it up to the mods by making a thread in the Support section. The mods most knowledgeable about this stuff (through experience or past knowledge) will be brought into the discussion and we'll take points on board and try to work our best at it so it becomes the most comfortable experience for the majority of the users of this section  

[viniferrett 16,684]

#57 (=) Million Reasons *re-peaked*

[TEANUS 15,427]

12 minutes ago, Florin said:

Why a 0,25 should be considered good on the impact day?

We don't see the effect from impact day until tomorrow

[Americano 31,061]

14 minutes ago, Florin said:

Why a 0,25 should be considered good on the impact day?

Not sure-- That's not the impact day number though, so also confused about the question  

[SomethingMore 1,701]

5 minutes ago, mister max said:

Was UK chart thread active tho?

I vote for general chart thread and gaga chart thread seperate!

It wasn't as active as this thread of course, but the section was more organised with that thread existing as seperate discussion was made in that thread. 

I remember 4 years ago we had US thread, UK thread and even Canadian thread, and it was working back then. I believe they closed the Canadian thread cuz it wasn't as active.

[mister max 18,480]

12 minutes ago, SomethingMore said:

It wasn't as active as this thread of course, but the section was more organised with that thread existing as seperate discussion was made in that thread. 

I remember 4 years ago we had US thread, UK thread and even Canadian thread, and it was working back then. I believe they closed the Canadian thread cuz it wasn't as active.

inb4 US, UK, WW and Gaga all different 

[Americano 31,061]

i like it this way because during the AMAs etc its stupid to have one thread for Gaga and another for everyone else

[Gypsy Life 118,907]

30 minutes ago, Haroon said:

Would you guys be okay with it returning to how it was, as in 3 separate threads for the 3 separate chart discussions?  Gaga Charts, UK Charts, General Charts  

I don't see how anyone can be discussing any of them at the moment without it getting very messy and constantly drowned out by other chart discussion which isn't even in the same ball park  People who want to just discuss Gaga should have their own place. People who want to just discuss the UK's charts should have their own place. And people who want to discuss the charts overall (which was basically mostly Billboard's various charts and others) should have their own place  

When we had separate threads, we used to go off topic in all of them anyway. I say let's keep it as one.

[Haroon 49,685]

Just now, Gypsy Life said:

When we had separate threads, we used to go off topic in all of them anyway. I say let's keep it as one.

Yeah but going off-topic here would be affecting a larger number of users because 3 different bases are in 1 place  Whereas going off-topic in 1 thread dedicated to 1 base isn't as big of a deal (although still don't do it guys  )

[Bt1 5,213]

15 minutes ago, TEANUS said:

We don't see the effect from impact day until tomorrow

Wow. I didnt know that. :)) Of course I know that this is for yesterday, but we just saw it. Can I say that I dont like that? Can I say that I dont like how radio goes? Thank you. 

 

 

[JusKeepBreathin 19,311]

3 minutes ago, Haroon said:

Yeah but going off-topic here would be affecting a larger number of users because 3 different bases are in 1 place  Whereas going off-topic in 1 thread dedicated to 1 base isn't as big of a deal (although still don't do it guys  )

I like it better with the threads separated. As much as I love Gaga I miss the predictions and discussions about other artists on the charts and I love Joanne but I'm getting Joanne charts overexposure.

[Bt1 5,213]

22 minutes ago, Americano said:

Not sure-- That's not the impact day number though, so also confused about the question  

Yes, these are the numbers made public on the impact day. We can discuss the adds later or tomorrow.

[Bt1 5,213]

Btw, at the moment MR is 500 on radio or something like that. If old songs will be measured it will probably be 1000. 

[Gypsy Life 118,907]

10 minutes ago, Haroon said:

Yeah but going off-topic here would be affecting a larger number of users because 3 different bases are in 1 place  Whereas going off-topic in 1 thread dedicated to 1 base isn't as big of a deal (although still don't do it guys  )

Honestly, if you go through the last 500 pages, we're all like 10-15 members that post over and over again. The rest of the forum don't care about charts and don't post here anyway.

The way it was before was:

Gaga era: General Charts thread is dead, and non-Gaga discussions just automatically happen in the Gaga thread.

Gaga on a break: the other way around.

I don't mind 2 threads, but off topic conversations will happen quite often in both threads and it'll be no different than the case we have now anyway.

By the way, less than 1% in this 500 page thread are general discussions too.