Jump to content
achievement

r/Music praises Joanne


kvnrp

Featured Posts

reddit.com/r/music isn't really known to love Gaga, or most other pop artists (r/popheads is the place for that), but I would say about 90% of comments on the Joanne album discussion thread are positive about it.

Here are some comments from that thread:

Spoiler

@Admin it would be nice if Reddit comments could be embedded :lana:

u/robboadam:

"Wow......ok, so I did not expect that. I saw the reviews and thought this was gonna be pretty mediocre but there's something so fresh and different about this.

Like, I'm sorry, but this woman could've hired loads of writers to make her loads of hit current singles and instead she does this?

Balls. She has balls. I like balls."

u/frostPanic-:

"She's always been super talented, compositional wise and vocally, it's nice that she's finally in a position where she can do whatever she wants because this album is rad."

u/angular_js_sucks:

"This is a really ballsy record considering her career needed a pop/dance comeback, she could have easily hired the current "in" producers ('The Chainsmokers') and made some quick hits.

Too bad due to her image, this album will be overlooked by many."

u/KometBlu:

"One of the best record this year, and by far her best.

It feels raw, real and above all genuine, which is a rarity to see among pop stars as big as Lady. The blend of rock, pop, folk and country works stunning on Mark Ronson/BloodPop-led production, which is nothing less than brilliant, just like the lyrics that are both more relatable and more substantial than any of her previous work.

Highlights would include that gorgeous acoustic title track, Beck co-written dance number Dancin In Circles, thought-provoking Angel Down, super fun John Wayne and Million Reasons, that just may be her best ballad ever.

NFL reportedly booked her for Superbowl immediately after they've heard the album, and I can see why. Very excited about that performance!"

 

Everyone seems to love this album :firega:
Even if we don't get a 90 on Metacritic, we can be so proud of this album :whitney:

Link to post
Share on other sites

BLACKOUTbritney

I don't want to be negative but those reviews seem like gay stans posing as straight reddit users :air:

The fact they quite a few include how "ballsy" the "record" is almost giving that "yeah bro I'm so straight" vibe :air: and they seem to be really well informed on Gaga 

Slay none the less, they aren't lying :giveup: 

Link to post
Share on other sites

malazam

Nice! but I only care aboiut my moms opinion.

 

another shot before we kiss the other side
Link to post
Share on other sites

Just now, BLACKOUTbritney said:

I don't want to be negative but those reviews seem like gay stans posing as straight reddit users :air:

The fact they quite a few include how "ballsy" the "record" is almost giving that "yeah bro I'm so straight" vibe :air: and they seem to be really well informed on Gaga 

Slay none the less, they aren't lying :giveup: 

inb4 ATRL raided Reddit threads about Joanne :rip:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Squeeshy Keety

Somebody get these hoes on Metacritic :grr:

 

EDIT: This is only 90% a joke. They were more object and at least stayed on topic :nails:

Spoiler

cmjHD010008635.jpg

:neyde::neyde::neyde::neyde:             :neyde:             :neyde::neyde::neyde::neyde:

:neyde:             :neyde:             :neyde:             :neyde:

:neyde:             :neyde:             :neyde:             :neyde::neyde::neyde:

:neyde:             :neyde:             :neyde:             :neyde:

:neyde::neyde::neyde::neyde:             :neyde:             :neyde::neyde::neyde::neyde:

 

 

They / Them 🏳️‍🌈
Link to post
Share on other sites

DeanWinchester
3 minutes ago, BLACKOUTbritney said:

I don't want to be negative but those reviews seem like gay stans posing as straight reddit users :air:

The fact they quite a few include how "ballsy" the "record" is almost giving that "yeah bro I'm so straight" vibe :air: and they seem to be really well informed on Gaga 

Slay none the less, they aren't lying :giveup: 

You can see their reputation points or something like that when they joined yea?

Flyin' like a 1000 Doves
Link to post
Share on other sites

Reviews and review sites are meaningless because stans for gaga and stans for her 'rivals' alter the objective critics

Link to post
Share on other sites

It's stripped down enough for the GP not to have their heads confused by "HURR DURR SHE'S LOOKING FOR ATTENTION SO = NO TALENT? ? ?? ? ?? ? DAE ROCK ONLY REAL GENRE???"

Oh well, congrats for them.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just now, Chic said:

It's stripped down enough for straight men not to have their heads confused by "HURR DURR SHE'S LOOKING FOR ATTENTION SO = NO TALENT? ? ?? ? ?? ?"

Oh well, congrats for them.

Maybe this thread is for you :emma:

"Why does Gaga get so much hate?"
https://www.reddit.com/r/Music/comments/58mxkt/why_does_gaga_get_so_much_hate/

It's basically the same story over and over again:
People see her in meat, think she's "too edgy", maybe like a few singles but when they are shown some piano performances or basically anything from 2015 to today, they finally see her talent and like her now.

Link to post
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, kvnrp said:

Maybe this thread is for you :emma:

"Why does Gaga get so much hate?"
https://www.reddit.com/r/Music/comments/58mxkt/why_does_gaga_get_so_much_hate/

It's basically the same story over and over again:
People see her in meat, think she's "too edgy", maybe like a few singles but when they are shown some piano performances or basically anything from 2015 to today, they finally see her talent and like her now.

These people are the same to like "real music" because it's more "intellectually provocative" but they lack the required amount of intelligence to understand that theatrics does not equate to a covering up of a lack of talent. It's embarrassing.

Link to post
Share on other sites

DeanWinchester
4 minutes ago, Chic said:

These people are the same to like "real music" because it's more "intellectually provocative" but they lack the required amount of intelligence to understand that theatrics does not equate to a covering up of a lack of talent. It's embarrassing.

:applause:

i must say at the very least though, more people are getting woke

Flyin' like a 1000 Doves
Link to post
Share on other sites

robboadam

OMG.

Not me being found out.

:icega:

 

EDIT: Sistrens, we can't let this get out. I can't deal with BuzzFeed calling me up for an interview.

Link to post
Share on other sites

DeanWinchester
1 minute ago, robboadam said:

OMG.

Not me being found out.

:icega:

And Not you announcing it :toofunny:

Flyin' like a 1000 Doves
Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...