Rate The Songs Joanne Performed!

[chromasine 5,439]

15 minutes ago, Chic said:

A-Yo - 2/10

Sinner's Prayer - 2/10

Million Reasons - 3/10

This guy's *this* close to leaving the fanbase  Sad yet cackable

[Glamourpuss 29,062]

Sinner's Prayer - Loved it. It seems to me like it's one of those tracks that fans either hate or really love, like Electric Chapel. Maybe 7/10

A-Yo - I'm not really into it to be honest but I have only listened to it once. It reminded me alot of MANiCURE which isn't a bad thing because at least it's a comparison to the same artist. But I can't imagine it being a favourite of mine. 6/10 

Million Reasons - I liked it. I listened to the dive bar performance and then the studio version she released. I think it's lacking a little something that could have made it blow up huge but other than that it's got a nice feel to it that pulls on the heart strings. It has potential but I'd have to hear it a few more times. 7/10

Perfect Illusion - I liked the other performance of it at The Moth nightclub in London but this one didn't really work. I wish she'd talk less in songs, like shut up telling the crowd to scream or whatever she says and just sing the song instead. Bitch, I'll scream when I want to.  5/10

[ARTPOPNick 3,486]

A-YO; the live version like a 3 or 4/10, but that could change after I hear the studio version

Sinner's Prayer: 6/10 but again, the audio didn't do the song justice

Million Reasons: 8/10, but thanks to the studio version, not because of the live version, otherwise it would have been a 6.5 or 7

PI: 8/10 

So conclusion: I need to hear the studio versions and I'm not gonna listen to any of those live performances again until after the album.

[Chic 20,830]

6 minutes ago, jinko said:

This guy's *this* close to leaving the fanbase  Sad yet cackable

Guy's?

I'm not leaving the fanbase. I'm intrigued by the album, specifically Diamond Heart. The studio versions may be even better. I'm just stating my honest opinion. Am I being negative? Yes. But I'll get over it.

You're one to talk about leaving the fanbase - pretty much all of your posts are negative towards other people.

[ARTPOPNick 3,486]

Just now, Chic said:

Guy's?

I'm not leaving the fanbase. I'm intrigued by the album, specifically Diamond Heart. The studio versions may be even better. I'm just stating my honest opinion. Am I being negative? Yes. But I'll get over it.

I understand you, I feel the same, it isn't love at first sight this time, but after going through all those eras I'm never gonna leave the fanbase... (I hope)

[8Bit Heart 66]

Sinner's Prayer was a bit of a non event for me. This is my opinion so don't come for me, hihi. 

I'd rank it as such: Million Reasons = A-Yo > PI > SP 

[herassisfamous 1,405]

Well I most definitely stan A-YO and I most definitely will be "on my knees" while Sinner's Prayer playing. AND WE NEED TO TAKE A MOMENT TO SHOW RESPECT TO MILLION REASONS cuz right now I have a million reasons to laugh but we have a PERFECT ballad to cry with so I AM CRYING MY ASS OFF. 

[StarryNight 10,106]

PI and MR are amazing, I won't judge other 2 before we hear studio versions. Ayo might be bop I just hope it doesn't sound like MANiCURE

[ThatAsianGuy 2,365]

Im a bit disappointed at Ayo tho. Gaga said its her favorite but it sounds alot like MANiCURE. Hopefully the album version could pull it off.

[PMKKARDASHiAN 8,570]

PI: 8/10

MR: 5/10

SP: 3/10

AYP: 3/10 

[ModernEcstasy 9,085]

Okay, point number 1 I'd like to make is....I can't stand the fact that she's asking to be called Joanne. If someone in my family began to ask millions to start calling them the name of a lost loved one, I'd be fuming!

anyway....onto the music. 

When I woke up and watched the full half hour set, I was very unimpressed. Very disappointed and very upset. I can't stand country music!

However, after watching it for a 3rd time, I can now say that I rate the music 10/10. I love it. My favourite is A-Yo. I like million reasons The least (but that's because I'm not a ballad kinda guy). But that doesn't mean to say I don't like it. 

Very excited to hear more. 

Off Topic: Do you think she may change her choice of songs for the next show? Those songs seemed very Nashville to me. 

[TopDomBoy 1,182]

47 minutes ago, MaryJaneHolland said:

It was lav! I'm here for a re-invention and making different music. The album will still be pop, with a lot of musical influences and I'm here for it! I would've preferred more dance records, but as she's releasing these slower songs, I'm getting used to them and like them.

1. A-Yo (if this is not the second single, I'll cut a bitch)

2. Sinner's Prayer

3. Million Reasons 

MR 3? 

[TopDomBoy 1,182]

1. Million Reasons 9/10  

 

2. Sinners Prayer 6/10  

 

3. A-Yo 2/10. 

[chromasine 5,439]

15 minutes ago, Chic said:

Guy's?

I'm not leaving the fanbase. I'm intrigued by the album, specifically Diamond Heart. The studio versions may be even better. I'm just stating my honest opinion. Am I being negative? Yes. But I'll get over it.

You're one to talk about leaving the fanbase - pretty much all of your posts are negative towards other people.

This guy is --> guy's [just got contracted, no biggie ]

Thank you for going through my posts tho, I guess I just love talking shiz  

[Monster Voices 1,024]

So faaar it's this -

Million reasons 8.5/10

Sinner's Prayer 6.5/10

A-yo 4/10

But We all know how the studio versions can differ greatly from the live ones. Only thing strange for me is that PI seams to be the only actual pop song but I am eager to broaden my horizon and they are all very good songs.