Gaga's tweet indicates PI about heartbreak?

[SchwineLove 1,374]

"My lungs of heartbreak"? What heartbreak? What causes her heartbreak? She never describe a heartbreak in her interview when explaining PI's meaning.

*this is my first thread sorry if wrong section or already discussed lol

[SamJ 8,008]

I think her heart had broken in many ways sadly but whatever she is on about she is surely tackling it head on in this song! I cant wait for her to do this in concert it will be electrifying!!!

[FATCAT 60,077]

She'd had like 5 bad breakups, half of her discography is about Luc

She's protecting Taylor, but it's probably about him in a subtle way.

[Laceface 2,964]

I personally think most of her songs are about her love life but she chooses to explain the alternate description because she obviously doesn't like discussing it. I mean her songs can be interpreted in multiple ways but the rawness and passion has to come from somewhere close to her heart. 

[Dangerous Man 9,245]

Heartbreak from all the betrayal of her friends and fans,

[hELXIG 43,038]

She was probably thinking of Taylor at the time. I still think that she connects to the song herself because of their separation, but because she still loves him she avoids linking the song with relationships so he doesn't get dragged into it.

[hELXIG 43,038]

1 minute ago, Dangerous Man said:

Heartbreak from all the betrayal of her friends and fans,

Oh that's a good point! Remember how she lost lots of friends after she broke her hip because she realised some of them didn't actually care about her as a human being, only her as a rich famous pop star? 

[CheapGin 561]

Uhm yeah have you heard the lyrics? It wasnt love, it was a perfect illusion...sounds heartbreaking to me. Gaga is a singer and performer shes not going to sing it with the interpretation that its about an instagram filter even if it is, the song is still about heartbreak.

[KURUSHITOVSKA 20,451]

This is about fans' betrayals for sure

[littlepotter 75,146]

12 minutes ago, Laceface said:

I personally think most of her songs are about her love life but she chooses to explain the alternate description because she obviously doesn't like discussing it. I mean her songs can be interpreted in multiple ways but the rawness and passion has to come from somewhere close to her heart. 

So Applause is about a man clapping on ha booty?

[SchwineLove 1,374]

2 minutes ago, CheapGin said:

Uhm yeah have you heard the lyrics? It wasnt love, it was a perfect illusion...sounds heartbreaking to me. Gaga is a singer and performer shes not going to sing it with the interpretation that its about an instagram filter even if it is, the song is still about heartbreak.

yeah obviously, I know, but she never really describe it was about her heartbreak whatsoever, her narration in the tweet that she sings of her lungs of heartbreak makes me wonder about her true feeling/meaning when singing the lyrics. I think she doesn't want to explicitly tell the real meaning behind the song. If it is really about Taylor, I dunno, it's just sound too angry and "ragey" when they are still in good terms in relationship

[SchwineLove 1,374]

6 minutes ago, KURUSHITOVSKA said:

This is about fans' betrayals for sure

You know, I'm starting to think this is true, but I really really don't want to believe it

[Glittertinks 12,459]

Heartbreak can come in many different forms. It could be friends, it could be family, it could be her fans or Taylor, we don't know. I mean, a lot has happened during the ARTPOP Era, not only fans but friends left her in this time I guess the song is not about a specific heartbreak per se.

[CheapGin 561]

1 minute ago, SchwineLove said:

yeah obviously, I know, but she never really describe it was about her heartbreak whatsoever, her narration in the tweet that she sings of her lungs of heartbreak makes me wonder about her true feeling/meaning when singing the lyrics. I think she doesn't want to explicitly tell the real meaning behind the song. If it is really about Taylor, I dunno, it's just sound too angry and "ragey" when they are still in good terms in relationship

In one of the radio interviews recently she talked about how she was going to have to sing this song on every tour for the rest of her career and about the place it takes her to and where she needs to go, so I think its more than Taylor. Maybe she channels the Luc days 

only kidding, but I think singing is a lot like acting in a lot of ways, so for her it could just be the lyrics that are enough

[SarahYuko 1,002]

3 minutes ago, SchwineLove said:

You know, I'm starting to think this is true, but I really really don't want to believe it

Same here. The more I think about it, it seems like she's referring to the betrayal of a lot of fans (obviously not all of us), especially since the video points more to the perfect audience as being a perfect illusion. I don't wanna believe it tho, it's gotta mean something else.