Jump to content
opinion

Thinking Positively about PI (for haters!)


boysboysboys

Featured Posts

boysboysboys

I've been trying to see what others find wrong about it, haters and not, and it just turns out to more or less be the same thing that helps the song. Like, I would know that and say if a song isn't good for pop listeners (ex. Applause is not singable), but Perfect Illusion is amazing. Just my opinion, but it's not a bad song! 

For one thing, this song can't not be loud. It's literally Gaga's voice that is carrying the song and the only way you can feel the vibe is if it's UP and slightly uneven. Imagine if she sung this song like Bloody Mary :neyde:

The song is very raw and that's the personality of it. Nearly all of Bruno's songs are around this type. 

I get why her voice is shrill when she sings the "lahhhve" note. Even then, with all of these things, the song has a very solid melody and it sticks in your head so well. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, boysboysboys said:

I've been trying to see what others find wrong about it, haters and not, and it just turns out to more or less be the same thing that helps the song. Like, I would know that and say if a song isn't good for pop listeners (ex. Applause is not singable), but Perfect Illusion is amazing. Just my opinion, but it's not a bad song! 

For one thing, this song can't not be loud. It's literally Gaga's voice that is carrying the song and the only way you can feel the vibe is if it's UP and slightly uneven. Imagine if she sung this song like Bloody Mary :neyde:

The song is very raw and that's the personality of it. Nearly all of Bruno's songs are around this type. 

I get why her voice is shrill when she sings the "lahhhve" note. Even then, with all of these things, the song has a very solid melody and it sticks in your head so well. 

Her voice isn't shrill. This is shrill: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fnJdpN1GGh4

Link to post
Share on other sites

I mean I like the song, I really do. What makes me sad is that I've had to really try to like it (unlike any other song she has put out). The saddest part to me is seeing what this song could have been (in my complete and utter opinion)

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, EberGaga said:

This song is really not in a positive situation actually...Be objective.

I'm not loving the way this word is being used lately. You can't state an opinion and then say "be objective" :sharon: doesn't work like that :sharon:

Oh, I'm just visiting-
Link to post
Share on other sites

boysboysboys
3 hours ago, M83 said:

The song is a disaster in every way it could have been. On top of that this doesn't even feel like an era. 

Pls elaborate :koons:

Why is this a disastah :koons:

Link to post
Share on other sites

OmgSum1Actually

Even Applause was better in my opinion, I don't think this song will become a hit.

I like the song because I kinda forced myself into liking it, listening to it many times. This song belongs to ARTPOP. :queenga:

 

Kill me.

Shameless selfpromo
Link to post
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, Resquid said:

I'm not loving the way this word is being used lately. You can't state an opinion and then say "be objective"  doesn't work like that 

The song is a little bit doing a bad job...And this is the truth......Objective truth

Link to post
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, EberGaga said:

The song is a little bit doing a bad job...And this is the truth......Objective truth

Songs don't do "jobs", they're songs ffs what are you talking about :saladga:

Oh, I'm just visiting-
Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...