One thing Gaga is really good at

[VANTABLACK 7,793]

15 minutes ago, Thomas P said:

When her songs aren't amazing, or as groundbreaking as she normally is, she is able to make a video that stops the world with its beauty.

Take Judas for example. The song is okay, but the video just about killed me. It's one of my favourite videos of all time. She did the same with GUY.

The one problem I have is that Gaga has less than 20 music videos. She needs more. 

So this has been another rendition of random threads made by Thomas P.

I JUST WATCHED JUDAS ITS BEEN SO LONG WAS ABOUT TO MAKE A THREAD TO PHRASE IT TOO THE GODS BUT JUST SAW THIS THREAD.  ITS SO BEAUTIFUL.A WORK OF ART. IT MAKES THE DWUW LEAK LOOK LIKE TRASH.

[littlepotter 75,083]

11 minutes ago, Mr Ricky said:

Take. that. BACK.

I'd been wondering if you were the producer mr. ricky but now im sure bc of the gif

Where Poker Face choir version at  

[Slayer 9,227]

It's funny you say that, I watched Judas for the first time in years yesterday and it's such an incredible video. But I do think the song is amazing too.

[Lextyr97 19,879]

Judas is definitely one of the best songs on Born This Way. It's amazing. The video just made it better. It's easily one of my favorite music videos ever. That choreography>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> The Imagery>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Everything about Judas was great.

[JoanneMonster 9,026]

What's wrong with you guys? Judas and G.U.Y are both amazing songs and videos! A good example would be telephone, not one of her best songs but one of her best music videos

[SpookyKid 15,153]

Judas is one of her best songs 

[Impostor 4,114]

If she starts making thousand of videos then they stop being unique

[abductee 162]

What. a. mess.

[Nut Varmit 4]

the only thing she's really good at is feeding her stupid ****ing horse and making us wait unnecessary time periods 

[BibleThisWay 4,370]

40 minutes ago, Thomas P said:

Take Judas for example. The song is okay

[Oriane 20,935]

4 hours ago, Ferrer Zorola said:

 

what is wrong with GUY's mv according to you? it's definitely better than some of her more iconic ones like the edge of glory, yoü and I and just dance besides she had never looked that hot in a video since Poker Face. The video also has iconic scenes, like, seriously, what's wrong with it? it only helped a sort of bland song come to life and made it badass 

It's so messy... Her worst video I think. Videos like Just Dance or The Edge of Glory may be more simple, but they're technically good and clean. (And The Edge of Glory's aesthetics are very beautiful)

I'm going to list some of the things that bother me, there are plenty more :

- I like the idea of the beginning, but it's too long. The whole thing "I'm a fallen angel, I'm climbing up this hole, I take this arrow from my chest, I'm a victim" is exagerrated. The transition with a landscape is clearly just there for the sake of making a transition. She takes nearly two minutes to finally get to the castle and things happen.

- The entrance in the castle is weird. The guys in black who take her are acting like robots (the way they walk, wait for her to fall to react and go to her). And again the transition exterior/interior of the castle is weak. And the whole thing is cliché, all these people who are just randomly dancing or posing, the way they make her reborn with the pool... If she was supposed to enter a kind of world where creativity and art were embraced, there were 1000 better ways to show that.

- For ARTPOP it's still ok, but putting Venus here was a bad choice. The video doesn't follow the rhythm of the song, it's kind of frustrating.

- The real housewives, really ? I know it's supposed to be ironic but this part is still cringy.

- That horrible green screen with Andy Cohen's face...

- Some shots are not really beautiful... Especially the long shots, as the pool.

- And some shots are just being put there to fill the video but nothing happens.

- Nothing is happening during the first verse and chorus.

- Second verse : too bad she's just doing a basic sexy thing, every pop star could have done that. It's just "look I'm a pop star, I'm blonde, sexy and surrounded by men". Disappointing given all the deep things she put in her other videos.

- Weird editing at 4:56.

- Another horrible green screen at 5:33.

- The look she does at 7:15 really makes me cringe.

- And another landscape at the end because they didn't know how to end...

- And WTF with the credits at the end.

Overall there are good ideas but the writing is not deep enough. Many moments are just plain, a lot of shots could have been better. The whole thing just makes me think of another basic music video by any popstar, half of the things we see are meaningless. 

Surprisingly it becomes better towards the end.

The only part I like is the bridge, especially the second part. Pure Gaga, a lot of cuts, beautiful shots and elements with a meaning.

[Ethan 2,051]

6 minutes ago, Oriane23 said:

It's so messy... Her worst video I think. Videos like Just Dance or The Edge of Glory may be more simple, but they're technically good and clean. (And The Edge of Glory's aesthetics are very beautiful)

I'm going to list some of the things that bother me, there are plenty more :

- I like the idea of the beginning, but it's too long. The whole thing "I'm a fallen angel, I'm climbing up this hole, I take this arrow from my chest, I'm a victim" is exagerrated. The transition with a landscape is clearly just there for the sake of making a transition. She takes nearly two minutes to finally get to the castle and things happen.

- The entrance in the castle is weird. The guys in black who take her are acting like robots (the way they walk, wait for her to fall to react and go to her). And again the transition exterior/interior of the castle is weak. And the whole thing is cliché, all these people who are just randomly dancing or posing, the way they make her reborn with the pool... If she was supposed to enter a kind of world where creativity and art were embraced, there were 1000 better ways to show that.

- For ARTPOP it's still ok, but putting Venus here was a bad choice. The video doesn't follow the rhythm of the song, it's kind of frustrating.

- The real housewives, really ? I know it's supposed to be ironic but this part is still cringy.

- That horrible green screen with Andy Cohen's face...

- Some shots are not really beautiful... Especially the long shots, as the pool.

- And some shots are just being put there to fill the video but nothing happens.

- Nothing is happening during the first verse and chorus.

- Second verse : too bad she's just doing a basic sexy thing, every pop star could have done that. It's just "look I'm a pop star, I'm blonde, sexy and surrounded by men". Disappointing given all the deep things she put in her other videos.

- Weird editing at 4:56.

- Another horrible green screen at 5:33.

- The look she does at 7:15 really makes me cringe.

- And another landscape at the end because they didn't know how to end...

- And WTF with the credits at the end.

Overall there are good ideas but the writing is not deep enough. Many moments are just plain, a lot of shots could have been better. The whole thing just makes me think of another basic music video by any popstar, half of the things we see are meaningless. 

Surprisingly it becomes better towards the end.

The only part I like is the bridge, especially the second part. Pure Gaga, a lot of cuts, beautiful shots and elements with a meaning.

You're nitpicking at a lot... Like you went in wanting to hate the video. 

[Oriane 20,935]

21 hours ago, Ethan said:

You're nitpicking at a lot... Like you went in wanting to hate the video. 

I would be nitpicking if I watched closely every little detail... These things are just blindingly obvious, that's why I don't like the video.