Jump to content

US Charts Discussion (Part 2)


Americano
 Share

Featured Posts

Americano

Are you serious? It didn't even take me long to like it, I just did upon first listen.

And it's not like you'll deny that the singles management was off.

I actually liked all of the single choices.

Judas bombed, but it seemed like it would've been a hit. I don't see any way it wouldnt have been released eventually.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Americano

    844

  • Valentino

    567

  • boysboysboys

    471

  • Ozzy8923

    455

jhonyguy04

Wide Awake is taking off huge on radio, that's surprising to me.

ONE DIRECTION - One Thing: 8.826 (- 0.043)

Flop?

I dont see wide awake anywhere in top 40

Link to post
Share on other sites

boysboysboys

I actually liked all of the single choices.

Judas bombed, but it seemed like it would've been a hit. I don't see any way it wouldnt have been released eventually.

Well, I don't.

I hate that Judas was released at such an uncomfortable time (Lent, and after the Express Yourself bull).

I hate how EOG was placed right at the middle, almost ending all curiosity, and that it was released at a time when the charts handled many spiking songs.

I hate that You and I, a slow song with a slightly specific audience, was released at this point when a mainstream comeback was utterly necessary.

Finally, I hate that Marry the Night, a big song that's part of the soul of the album, had to be the fifth as well as the one to suffer flophood.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Americano

Well, I don't.

I hate that Judas was released at such an uncomfortable time (Lent, and after the Express Yourself bull).

I hate how EOG was placed right at the middle, almost ending all curiosity, and that it was released at a time when the charts handled many spiking songs.

I hate that You and I, a slow song with a slightly specific audience, was released at this point when a mainstream comeback was utterly necessary.

Finally, I hate that Marry the Night, a big song that's part of the soul of the album, had to be the fifth as well as the one to suffer flophood.

They didn't have a choice with TEOG. It was #1 on iTunes worldwide.

You and I did fine in the US, and needed the album hype/TEOG-tail off to be able to even take off here.

MTN failed on its own merits.

Link to post
Share on other sites

boysboysboys

ughh....we can't compete with katy. she owns us. iam sad.

She can't own us if we aren't even in the running, tbh.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Americano

ughh....we can't compete with katy. she owns us. iam sad.

Katy is hardly owning anyone with her re-release, lol.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I hate that You and I, a slow song with a slightly specific audience, was released at this point when a mainstream comeback was utterly necessary.

Finally, I hate that Marry the Night, a big song that's part of the soul of the album, had to be the fifth as well as the one to suffer flophood.

MTN had the best chance in Europe, so she was smart to release in November when she had promo there.

Likewise, it was better to have Yuyi for the VMAs.

If MTN was as appealing as WHYB, being 5th wouldn't matter.

Link to post
Share on other sites

jhonyguy04

You guys are delusional!! She already has 8 hits from her most recent era, and we only managed to get 3!! And she is about to outsell born this way.

The only thing we have is the tour, which we slayed the b---h but still. I am scared.

Link to post
Share on other sites

boysboysboys

They didn't have a choice with TEOG. It was #1 on iTunes worldwide.

You and I did fine in the US, and needed the album hype/TEOG-tail off to be able to even take off here.

MTN failed on its own merits.

They had a choice, seeing that they were able to suppress Scheisse. TEOG has this burnout effect for the whole era that I can't adequately explain yet, but I promise I will.

Yuyi was gaining on such low momentum. EOG was flopping in Youtube and a handful of songs were doing better in the charts.

MTN shouldn't have failed, and it can't just by itself. Not, of course, that I think it should have ever been sacrificed.

Link to post
Share on other sites

jhonyguy04

What people don't understand is that the reason YUYI was released is because when the album was just released, it made it the highest on itunes not including the pre-album songs. I think it went higher than hair, which was a pre-album song. let's just accept that mtn is floppy and thats it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

boysboysboys

If MTN was as appealing as WHYB, being 5th wouldn't matter.

I can't at people putting WHYB over MTN :fail:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Runway

You guys are delusional!! She already has 8 hits from her most recent era, and we only managed to get 3!! And she is about to outsell born this way.

The only thing we have is the tour, which we slayed the b---h but still. I am scared.

Gaga has Grammys, Katy doesn't

Gaga has cultural Impact, Katy doesn't

Gaga's BTWB will be one of the 10 highest grossing tours in history, Katy... well...

The only thing Katy has that Gaga does not are disposable radio hits that no one will remember in 10 years

There's nothing to be scared about :nacho:

Edited by Kimberly
Link to post
Share on other sites

Arturo

What people don't understand is that the reason YUYI was released is because when the album was just released, it made it the highest on itunes not including the pre-album songs. I think it went higher than hair, which was a pre-album song. let's just accept that mtn is floppy and thats it.

What the **** is wrong with you?

You're telling us to accept Marry the Night as floppy as if we're delusional and think it was a hit.

WE ALL KNOW IT FLOPPED.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share


×
×
  • Create New...