Would you still stan for Gaga if she wasn't such a good live singer?

[Iwontell 7,312]

Maybe...I mean, when I started liking her her voice was usually so attuned you couldn't even tell what it sounded like...

[Yoro 566]

yes, her music and talent was what attracted me but what kept me going was her kindness and sweet personality. 

[Bloody Matt 5,357]

I wouldn't stan so hard. That's for sure. 

[GloZell Green 11,723]

I guess so, but a bit less. Her talent did not truly get recognized until TSOM, which also helped her get worldwide recognition. She would've been seen as another performer if she couldn't sing. If she wasn't so talented "Talent Always Wins" wouldn't exist  

[NewYorkCity 10,536]

Yeah but like 70%. I stan for her as an artist and as a singer. So, the fact that she wouldn't sing well would take away a very important part of why I admire her and cry watching her performances.

 

[eifulien 2,969]

Yeah definitely, just not as much. If I can like Rihanna then Gaga would also get a pass without that voice. The thing with Gags is that she is just an all-round person. She has the talent to wirte, play and sing. She is THE entertainer when she is on stage. And she has a strong personality that you either fall in love with or start hating her for being who she is. But I can't honestly imagine her without any of that. She is ALL that and that's why she is the only person I truly stan for.  

[Harry 26,836]

I mean, it depends how bad she was... I became a 'fan' before seeing any live performances but part of the appeal for me is that she can be so theatrical but is also incredibly talented vocally and musically.

If all the music was the same I'd probably still stan, but maybe not so hard. I mean, I always knew she was a good singer from the beginning, but I consider her a far superior vocalist now than I did a couple of years ago and I started stanning for her in 2009/10. So I probably would.

[Angel Down 2,807]

I would definitely like her but OH GOD NO I COULD NOT LIVE WITHOUT THAT TREMENDOUS VOICE.
 

[Neight Shayde 7,925]

i would, but not as much as how i stan for her today.

[ComeToMama 4,351]

I guess for me it's not a matter of would I still like her.

I don't think I ever would have began to stan for her if she wasn't a good live singer. Her ability to sing live is the main reason I love her so much and brag about her. 

Now let's say something happened to her voice now and she couldn't sing like she used to, of course I'd still be here.

[Impostor 4,114]

Of course I would. I don't like Gaga just because of her voice cause duh I've been listening to her since the auto-tuned The Fame. I love her songs, her style and her concepts, and I really identify with her, so nope I wouldn't give a **** if her voice was not good live. Also, her performances are never just about the voice (at least from TF to ARTPOP), for example the iconic Paparazzi performance at the VMAs which was auto-tuned.

[PaperIz 7,346]

Britney is my fave. I've gotten over lip syncing long ago  

[REALITY 76,705]

I would. There are many other aspects about Gaga that made me become a fan, though, if she didn't have the ability to sing as well as she does, it would just make her another 'pop star'. And we all know she's anything but just another ordinary pop star. 

[Diamond Heart 4,400]

One of the things that draws me to Gaga is her amazing vocals and talent. 
I think id still stan her but no where near as much as i do at the moment lol 

[PartySick 160,427]

I think I would. I love being blown away by powerhouse vocals as much as the next guy but it was her personality and artistic side that really drew me to her, as well as her activism and willingness to speak up about things that bothered her or things that she thought were wrong

I mean, I'm a Britney Spears stan because of how she pulled out of that massive chasm a few years ago. Her resilience, strength, and continued down-to-Earth attitude is why I love her.