Jump to content
opinion

One thing that bothers me about Gaga's role in AHS


Katie14

Featured Posts

hoeslay

And she said she would never wears jeans:laughga:

"My fans would kill me if they ever saw me barefoot or in jeans or in flats." All of which she did/wore a year later 

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 91
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Saint Laurent

Also, she doesn't have to have auditioned for Ryan, that's why he employs a casting team. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

PartySick

There are multiple writers and casting directors on every set. Ryan is a busy man. Probably someone else had her come into read for them, to see if she could handle a main role or not.

 

 

:yes: AHS is one of the most popular shows, I doubt they'd take in some scrub just 'cause she's got a big name. I'm guessing she auditioned, there was just no drama around it so no one reported it :cryga: 

I would love to see her audition, though. "Give me the grunt you'd give if you were thrusting a knife into someone's throat." :omg: 

You're stinky
Link to post
Share on other sites

Whispering

yet he hasnt seen her act... (well no he has cause shes already filming but you know what i mean) 

That doesn't mean that there weren't other people available who did see her read, to know what she could handle and how they saw her fit into the show.

Link to post
Share on other sites

RAMROD

We just know that much, and make assumption based on that little information.

We never know if there are bigger picture to that.

We never know why Gaga does what she did.

So it is pretty weak reason on why we have to discuss this but to discourage people from taking her acting debut for TV seriously.

Inb4 the first reason she did this was she was poised seeing Kinney acting since she have been on his TV series set so often.

And she have this opportunity and juat use it.

Either way, people change, for many reasons.

Even if she don't want to, sometimes she will have to.

(ノ◕ヮ◕)ノ✧*:・゚ dancin' until i'm dead (*´艸`*) ♡♡♡
Link to post
Share on other sites

That doesn't mean that there weren't other people available who did see her read, to know what she could handle and how they saw her fit into the show.

imo ryan should have seen her act 

i mean she is the lead :rip:

but like i said i dont really care about this 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Bad Bromance

I'm just really excited to see her in action.  I'm not sure there are auditions for AHS, though.  Doesn't Ryan Murphy tailor the roles of the characters with certain actors/actresses in mind anyway?  At least that's what I thought I read somewhere.

I don't care what you think about unless it is about me.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Katie14

People change, even celebrities. There is really nothing wrong with changing one's mind and sometimes it is for the better.

I get that. People can change their minds. It bothers me because this seemed to be almost like a moral code that she was following. I very much agreed with her and respected her for having that view and now it seems like she doesn't feel that way anymore.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Whispering

"My fans would kill me if they ever saw me barefoot or in jeans or in flats." All of which she did/wore a year later 

She broke her hip. Her body is in pain, so she has had to change her shoe choices sometimes. How dare she! 

Also, people change their minds or just decide what they said two, three, seven years ago was stupid or didn't make sense anymore! 

It's so bizarre that fans expect Gaga to never change her thoughts over seven or eight years. Is it immature thinking, or lack of life experience that causes Gaga fans to not understand or relate to simple life changes? Can they not see how they have changed in the last five to seven years and apply that to other people? 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Katie14

imo ryan should have seen her act 

i mean she is the lead :rip:

but like i said i dont really care about this 

Is it actually confirmed that she is the lead? I thought she was one of the main characters.

Link to post
Share on other sites

hoeslay

She broke her hip. Her body is in pain, so she has had to change her shoe choices sometimes. How dare she! 

 

This was before she broke her hip...this was during The waiting between TFM and BTW.....

Link to post
Share on other sites

Whispering

imo ryan should have seen her act 

i mean she is the lead :rip:

but like i said i dont really care about this 

That's not how it always works, though. There are casting agents and casting departments for every show. There are multiple writers and producers at different levels. You have to trust those people, and many of these people have been with Ryan for years and years and on multiple shows. If Ryan felt like Gaga couldn't handle a big part, after consulting with his people, he would be making Gaga a smaller part of the upcoming season. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Whispering

I get that. People can change their minds. It bothers me because this seemed to be almost like a moral code that she was following. I very much agreed with her and respected her for having that view and now it seems like she doesn't feel that way anymore.

Gaga called and didn't demand a part, but asked if there was a place for her. That isn't going against a "moral code". Then, we don't know the extent to which she had to audition for her leading role. Once again, Ryan is not the only person that can see castings and readings. How do you know she didn't go in and read for anyone or with anyone in this process? 

All we know is that Ryan didn't initially see Gaga read...other than that, we have no more information. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...