'Katy Perry has more self-written songs in her debut album than Gaga.'

[Coop 15,354]

Does it matter?  

[Enhsa 2,043]

JOKE

LAMAO HAHHHHHHHHHH

[Jjang 2,262]

 

​No, because that's the point of being a ghost writer...

I didn't say she does hire them, but the possiblity of her actually doing that wouldn't shock me.

[HausOfNena 1,712]

[Fiona Apple 13,006]

It's because Gaga gives credit even to people that barely help her.. Gaga actually writes all of her songs alone.. ShadyMusicFacts says BS all the time.

[LaXian 25]

Pointless comparison. Yes Katy is a good songwriter but not a great one. And this is where quality not quantity comes in ... I am certainly not a KP hater, on the contrary I like to bop to KP. But let's not compare their debut albums nor the songwriting of each... TF had a lot bigger impact than OOTB so let's not ... And a lot of KP's hits are because of the production anyway, not only the songwriting.

[1986 629]

... Do you ever feel..

... like a plastic bag..

...drifting through the wind..

 

[Dunk96 2,526]

​

[blacklistedd 599]

So she wrote Ur So Gay all by herself? WOW. I wouldn't brag about it. Its like Nicki Minaj bragging about writing her own raps, thank you for Stupid Ho and Anaconda btw. Masterful lyricism right there.

[Haroon 49,685]

She wrote Ur So Gay herself? WOW. I wouldn't brag about it. Its like Nicki Minaj bragging about writing her own raps, thank you for Stupid Ho and Anaconda btw. Masterful lyricism right there.

​But why just focus on the negative  One questionable song doesn't negate the rest of an artist's written discography  

[Mast 980]

Idk why y'all are getting so pissed about this. It's true  . Question her input all you want, but her name is in the credits.

[blacklistedd 599]

​But why just focus on the negative  One questionable song doesn't negate the rest of an artist's written discography  

Not that I should need to state this for the record but I probably should considering where this conversation is taking place. Discussing Katy Perry's legitimacy on a Gaga forum with Gaga fans can unfortunately render my opinion invalid and I have to say that before I even considered myself a fan of Gagas I was not very keen on Katy. So not one ounce of my lack of respect for her as a pop artist can be attributed to me liking Lady Gaga. Just have to say that first.

Look, I think Katy has a couple of alright pop songs that I dont mind. Enough to count on one hand. But overall everything shes released to me is as hollow as pop can get, not even just her musical output but who she is as a pop culture figure and everything inbetween. I don't respect her music, I don't like it, and I don't respect her. Shes nothing imo. I don't care if she writes it all by herself. That doesn't mean anything to me if I don't respect the output.

[Yanko 9,860]

It's technically true though?  

 

Katy Hudson self written songs: 4

The Fame self written songs: 0

 

I'm aware that Gaga gives songwriting credit to the producers, but technically speaking the tweet is true. And even then: WHO CARES? Tired of Monsters being so butthurt over Katy. 

 

 

​this

roa applause thing was 2 years ago let it go 

[User 352]

Should probably be a joke 

In general, one should distinguish songwriters and producers. Gaga don't work with songwriters or song writer teams like StarGate.

Gaga only works with producers, because she don't want to sing words from others - which i found good. I also like that she works with unknown producers like White Shadow.

 

[Yanko 9,860]

So she wrote Ur So Gay all by herself? WOW. I wouldn't brag about it. Its like Nicki Minaj bragging about writing her own raps, thank you for Stupid Ho and Anaconda btw. Masterful lyricism right there.

​you know she has a lot more songs

i ahte when people say **** about nicki and they only bring up stupid hoe and anaconda