Gagas body now...

[AnglerfishbraBENUS 5,734]

In shape doesn't mean skinny! It is healthy if not healthier to have meat on your bones people. Stop being so shallow.

She's also TINY in stature. You're acting like she's 6'4 and this curvy

[Gaga Ate My Ass 173]

In shape doesn't mean skinny! It is healthy if not healthier to have meat on your bones people. Stop being so shallow. She's also TINY in stature. You're acting like she's 6'4 and this curvy

It would be funny if she really was 6'4"

[Sakrai 4,759]

I don't think there was any chance for this topic to not be a mess. But then again, it's never a good idea to talk about somebody else's weight.

It also saddens me to read some of the opinions written here, especially from Gaga fans.

I think she looks beautiful in that picture, and If you don't agree, saying 'i prefer her body here and here' was enough. Anything else is unnecessary. :kissga:

[Ara Gem 44]

SKINNY-GA aka MONSTERBALL-GA>>>>>>>>>>

 

 

 

this IS my favorite look of hers, she looks amazing, but honestly she was not healthy at all so i'm happy that she is now tbh 

[Lady Palutena 3,147]

Another thread full of boys talking as if they're the authority on the female physique? I loved how absolutely every idiot hating her figure and calling her unfit or unhealthy was 99% of the time male back when the forum still posted genders beneath member titles.

 

But seriously, you're talking about a woman who has had severe problems with bulimia and self-esteem since she was a teen. On her fan forum. DISSING HER FIGURE. If that's not true ugliness, I don't know what is. You know what, you skinny boys out there? Women's bodies are not at all like men's OR teenager's. Women put on extra weight four times as easily as men do because it's of biological features such as, you know, breasts and hips that facilitate child-bearing and child-rearing. Women also have a more difficult time losing weight than men because our bodies see a sudden lack of nutrition as meaning there's a crisis going on, so better store the calories as much as possible! Women have periods (GASP) that can make them gain up to 10 pounds for a week or more every single month. Contraception makes most women easily gain 5-15 pounds. Gaga herself has said she's on antidepressants, another med that causes weight gain (and again, proven to be more dramatic in women).

 

But women are still expected to be as "fit" as 15-year-old, one-piece-of-celery-a-day runway models who haven't gone through puberty and most likely never will get their period regularly (bad diets/starvation prevent puberty and about 32% of high fashion models don't get their periods because their body has too little nutrition) while chubby middle-aged dudes or teenage boys can fawn over them or trash them if they're not sacrificing their health and mental well-being for their bodies and getting serious health problems or picking up eating disorders, anxiety and depression on the way.

Thank you Nissa, this is the type of info these "idealists" need to read. :applause:

[aaronyoji 2,054]

I wish you guys wouldn't use the monster ball as an example of Gaga's perfect body.

She's said before that she was starving herself, especially during the theater tour

this! thank you. i cringe when people post pics of her fame/fame monster body and are like "yaaaas slay" im like "yes, slay when she was throwing up and skipping meals and fainting form exhuastion to look that way, slay, indeed" even in the pokerface music video, people say she was super toned then but she wasnt, her legs had no thigh muscle at all, she was just skinny for the sake of it, and unnaturally. 

[Gaga Ate My Ass 173]

this! thank you. i cringe when people post pics of her fame/fame monster body and are like "yaaaas slay" im like "yes, slay when she was throwing up and skipping meals and fainting form exhuastion to look that way, slay, indeed" even in the pokerface music video, people say she was super toned then but she wasnt, her legs had no thigh muscle at all, she was just skinny for the sake of it, and unnaturally.

I agree she was skinny and starving herself in the fame monster era but I disagree with her being skinny in poker face. Her legs were huge (in a lovely way), her face was round and overall had a curvy body but she lost weight in the fame monster and became skinny bony.

[XoXoJoanneGaga 629]

Is there a source for her starving herself and passing out? I don't remember her saying that

 

People really overthink this stuff though. The thread's about when her body looked best, and it obviously looks best when she's slim and fit, it's as simple as that. She gets fit every time she does promo or a video, she looks just as skinny in the GUY video as she did during The Monster Ball. It's obviously not hard for her, and I'm sure she'll look great during the next album cycle. Who cares if she puts on a few pounds while touring a jazz record.

[Staryu 6,162]

Skinny or with curves, Gaga still looks amazing.  

[Prometheus 1,494]

People can be healthy and have curves.

 

I think Gaga looked the most conventionally beautiful during TMB, but I think she said she was starving herself. I don't want that. Watch the Born This Way video and compare her now. It is crazy. She's still beautiful.

[devoured-heart 21]

I disagree with the idea that the majority of the people posting in this thread are doing so with the sole intention of bashing Gaga. The topic of discussion is not drastically different from one titled 'Gaga's Wig Now', obviously people will have their opinions on the various hairstyles Gaga has worn and should be entitled to share them respectfully. Obviously one is more taboo than the other therefore I can understand people being upset.

One person may like Gaga's body when she was thinner, another person may appreciate her at the weight she is now whilst another when Gaga is heavier. I don't see what the problem is as long as they are not being billigerent or spiteful about it.

From my perspective, judging from some of the defensive responses in this thread, nobody on this forum has the right to judge Gaga's body. Not a single person, whether they have the best intentions or not, because nobody in this thread knows Gaga's attitude towards food as of now or anytime for that matter. If people are unable to compliment her at her skinniest then same must go for when she is at any size or shape surely. The same rule goes for her personal relationships, mental health, fashion choices, career path etc.

If somebody could elaborate then I would appreciate it because I thought contributing opinions and personal views was the whole purpose of a forum.

[Gaga Ate My Ass 173]

I disagree with the idea that the majority of the people posting in this thread are doing so with the sole intention of bashing Gaga. The topic of discussion is not drastically different from one titled 'Gaga's Wig Now', obviously people will have their opinions on the various hairstyles Gaga has worn and should be entitled to share them respectfully. Obviously one is more taboo than the other therefore I can understand people being upset.

One person may like Gaga's body when she was thinner, another person may appreciate her at the weight she is now whilst another when Gaga is heavier. I don't see what the problem is as long as they are not being billigerent or spiteful about it.

From my perspective, judging from some of the defensive responses in this thread, nobody on this forum has the right to judge Gaga's body. Not a single person, whether they have the best intentions or not, because nobody in this thread knows Gaga's attitude towards food as of now or anytime for that matter. If people are unable to compliment her at her skinniest then same must go for when she is at any size or shape surely. The same rule goes for her personal relationships, mental health, fashion choices, career path etc.

If somebody could elaborate then I would appreciate it because I thought contributing opinions and personal views was the whole purpose of a forum.

You said no one has the right to judge gaga then you say "I thought contributing opinions and views was the purpose of this forum". Expressing opinions and views IS judging. Even when you say nice things about gaga you're still judging her. I think what you mean is that theres a difference between constructive criticism and flat out being an asshole and I agree. You can say "I prefer Gagas body in the fame monster era" instead of saying "ewww shes fat now (no one will ever say this since shes in great shape) she looked way better in btw era". Or "I'm not fond of this dress, maybe she should wear a different or sunglasses with it" instead of "ewwww that dress is disgusting, flop!!!"

[angelduuh 508]

I don't like it.

[devoured-heart 21]

You said no one has the right to judge gaga then you say "I thought contributing opinions and views was the purpose of this forum". Expressing opinions and views IS judging. Even when you say nice things about gaga you're still judging her. I think what you mean is that theres a difference between constructive criticism and flat out being an asshole and I agree. You can say "I prefer Gagas body in the fame monster era" instead of saying "ewww shes fat now (no one will ever say this since shes in great shape) she looked way better in btw era". Or "I'm not fond of this dress, maybe she should wear a different or sunglasses with it" instead of "ewwww that dress is disgusting, flop!!!"

I said "judging from the defensive responses in the thread." If the general consensus among the fans on this forum is that judging Gaga is wrong, then surely nobody would have the right to express their opinion of her in any way shape or form.

I agree with your views on being ignorant when sharing views wholeheartedly though.

[heavyMetalGAGA 65]

Yea, she was definitely sick during TMB trying to be too thin. Those videos of her almost passing out in Europe on stage are really sad and scary. I'm glad she seems to be more in control of her weight and her musical direction nowadays.