Jump to content

Remember when everyone called BTW a flop?


GagaUnderYou

Featured Posts

  • Replies 53
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Brooke Hoegan

yeah, but ARTPOP will never be like BTW in quality...  BTW >>>....>>> AP

 

and I'd rather stick to critics opinion on these albums than some pressed know-it-all monsters who would lick Gaga's ass if needed :manicure:

+ don't even start on arguing that critics were biased or media bandwaggoning this era or don't know sh.it cause it's just

:emma:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah it always happens,

BTW era "OmGgG such a FLOP TFM was AOO MUCH BETTER"

ARTPOP era "omFgg such a FLOP BTW was the better album"

And I've heard people said TF wa better than TFM on TFM era so it's just the circle of life of little flopsters not appreciating Gaga, I bet they'll be praising ARTPOP once album 5 comes

Link to post
Share on other sites

Tropico

yeah, but ARTPOP will never be like BTW in quality... BTW >>>....>>> AP

and I'd rather stick to critics opinion on these albums than some pressed know-it-all monsters who would lick Gaga's ass if needed

+ don't even start on arguing that critics were biased or media bandwaggoning this era or don't know sh.it cause it's just

Was this directed at me after yesterday? Is so that's just childish. :roll:

---

ARTPOP and BTW are my top 2 favorite albums. :yes:

But I have no doubt in my mind if the album had been critically acclaimed everyone would be like "omg totes the best yas slays TFM yaaas Gaga best album evah yay!" :later:

ARTPOP's concept + music is way better than her first 2 albums. :manicure:

And I am so sure that if TFM had flopped y'all would hate it. :sharon:

♢ Social Justice Enthusiast ♢
Link to post
Share on other sites

Brooke Hoegan

Was this directed at me after yesterday? Is so that's just childish. :roll:

omg nooo :toofunny:

yesterday my problem was with the way you speak, I underlined some expressions I wasn't okay with BUT

 

I completely forgot about it by now, chill man, don't wanna fight :hug:

 

---

to me, personally, TFM was the second album that clicked perfectly with me, I was so young back then... I didn't even know it was popular, so its success didn't matter at the time I felt in love with it

BTW is sonically not so nice to me but it had great energy and lyrics + message

 

I'll finish just by saying that AP isn't as good, it lacked smth (to me and not only to me) and it shows by its reception. I respect your opinion tho, I also like that album very much, but not as much as TFM and BTW

 

it only bothers me that some people (not saying you) tend to belittle critics here because Gaga said they don't matter. they know what they're doing and she just seemed hurt saying that

 

again, nothing personal, I don't even remember who said what, really :hug:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Phlop

Problem, Hold On we're going home, Fancy, Talk DIrty..... all R&B/Hip-Hop songs that slayed the billboard hot 100

R&B is the new pop nowadays....

She performed DWUW everywhere and it didn't reach the top 10. The public wasn't here for it before it's video anyway. People KNEW the song, almost everyone I know, knows it so that's saying enough.

It would've slayed without R. Kelly.

BYE
Link to post
Share on other sites

bionic

His verse smells like urine

 

68vzl.gif?w=580

 

:giveup:

 

 

---------------------

 

I don't think people (myself included) realised how lucky we were with the BTW campaign until the extra messy handling of ARTPOP happened. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Tropico

omg nooo :toofunny:

yesterday my problem was with the way you speak, I underlined some expressions I wasn't okay with BUT

I completely forgot about it by now, chill man, don't wanna fight :hug:

---

to me, personally, TFM was the second album that clicked perfectly with me, I was so young back then... I didn't even know it was popular, so its success didn't matter at the time I felt in love with it

BTW is sonically not so nice to me but it had great energy and lyrics + message

I'll finish just by saying that AP isn't as good, it lacked smth (to me and not only to me) and it shows by its reception. I respect your opinion tho, I also like that album very much, but not as much as TFM and BTW

it only bothers me that some people (not saying you) tend to belittle critics here because Gaga said they don't matter. they know what they're doing and she just seemed hurt saying that

again, nothing personal, I don't even remember who said what, really :hug:

Oh. My mistake then. I guess I'm a bit too defensive then. :ohno:

And lol everything after "-----" wasn't directed at you. That was just in general.

And tbh I don't mind if people don't like ARTPOP as much but when people call it "trash" and stuff then I just get mad.

So yeah! No hard feelings! :hug:

♢ Social Justice Enthusiast ♢
Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...