Does Gaga over-exaggerate her contributions to songs?

[LilVenusian 579]

- With 3 whole tracks on the album popping up as pretty much finished instrumentals i'm really starting to question gaga's claim that she co-produces all her songs. I also think she could have possible lied about producing Venus "all by herself", after finding in the linear notes that Madeon and Nick Monson also had significant contributions to the arrangement/production.Also, when she first started doing promo for Applause I was impressed when she said that only her and DJWS wrote Applause, but was then disappointed to find out that it had some 6 other random ass co-writers    

 

 Is gaga being shady and taking more credit than is due? Not trying to bash gaga but this is obviously and interesting point of discussion, since her claims don't really add up to the facts. I also think its important to talk about this since alot of this fanbase judges other artists like Katy Perry for having teams of songwriters and producers, when Gaga pretty much did the same thing on ARTPOP...

[Essence 235]

She writes her songs. And it's more than just melody and lyrics. You guys forget about her intense harmonies that are embedded into the instrumentals? Venus anyone?? If anything she deserves more credit for her contributions. She lives and breathes those songs.

And don't you dare compare her contributions to Katy's because we all know who has more input.

[Houdini 103]

when you look closer, among her 4 albums, she only wrote 2 songs by herself, speechless and you and i

of course she takes a major part of the song writing but she claims so hard that she writes all her songs and stuff but actually she has wrote only 2 songs only by herself..

 

but for the production, i'm sure she has the last words and she's very involved into it that's for sure

[Yanko 9,860]

 

 

 

 

 

why do you care anyways?  who cares? 

[GreenEyes 1,056]

She's made it clear she gives credits to anyone who is with her In the room during the song writing process.

[Free Bitch 106]

3?

 

Donatella, Mary Jane Holland and...?

[Yanko 9,860]

when you look closer, among her 4 albums, she only wrote 2 songs by herself, speechless and you and i

of course she takes a major part of the song writing but she claims so hard that she writes all her songs and stuff but actually she has wrote only 2 songs only by herself..

 

but for the production, i'm sure she has the last words and she's very involved into it that's for sure

lol no she writes all of her songs but then she shows them to producers and stuff and they make some adjustment to the song, that means co writing

[Cody Draco 2,531]

When it comes to the songs I'm pretty sure she does a million times more than people like Selena Gomez, Britney Spears, Miley Cyrus, Beyonce, etc.

 

[artpopmess 369]

Sis sit down

[LilVenusian 579]

3?

 

Donatella, Mary Jane Holland and...?

Aura

[Houdini 103]

lol no she writes all of her songs but then she shows them to producers and stuff and they make some adjustment to the song, that means co writing

in this case, every artist are co-writers. it's easy to look at the booklet and say ''ah she wrote all her songs and show to the producer and they adjust it and it's called co-writing'' because all artist are quoted as co-writers.

[Yanko 9,860]

- With 3 whole tracks on the album popping up as pretty much finished instrumentals i'm really starting to question gaga's claim that she co-produces all her songs. I also think she could have possible lied about producing Venus "all by herself", after finding in the linear notes that Madeon and Nick Monson also had significant contributions to the arrangement/production.Also, when she first started doing promo for Applause I was impressed when she said that only her and DJWS wrote Applause, but was then disappointed to find out that it had some 6 other random ass co-writers    

 

 Is gaga being shady and taking more credit than is due? Not trying to bash gaga but this is obviously and interesting point of discussion, since her claims don't really add up to the facts. I also think its important to talk about this since alot of this fanbase judges other artists like Katy Perry for having teams of songwriters and producers, when Gaga pretty much did the same thing on ARTPOP...

 it is known that katy does what her team tells her to do she is really not organic gaga is more organic dont compare those 2 please  (didnt want to sound shady but you asked for it)

 

 

 

And don't you dare compare her contributions to Katy's because we all know who has more input.

[Memo 176]

On ARTPOP maybe but overall I don't think so

[Yanko 9,860]

in this case, every artist are co-writers. it's easy to look at the booklet and say ''ah she wrote all her songs and show to the producer and they adjust it and it's called co-writing'' because all artist are quoted as co-writers.

mileys wrecking ball was written by others not miley u can check the booklet 

[RegiRey 443]

co-writers get credit for even 1 word. co-producers get credit for 1 note or a synth AND for arranging the song, such as Nick M.