Jump to content

Should Gaga have kept ARTPOP going?


idldte

Should Gaga have kept ARTPOP going?  

80 members have voted

  1. 1. Should Gaga have kept ARTPOP going?

    • Yes! She should have made more music video/done more performances on TV!
      55
    • No! It's best that she ended the era early.
      25


Featured Posts

Quark

Rubbish. The lyrics couldn't be easier to understand. Girl. Under. You. "I don't need to be on top to know I'm worthy because I'm strong enough to know the truth". The entire song is explained in the bridge. And the sound isn't current. It's futuristic EDM/electro-pop. Like it doesn't fit in the past. It sounds very fresh for a pop star. Not to heavy EDM like selfie but not to easy like a britney song. You're just saying that because it didn't do well. G.U.Y. Is a great song.

Actually I think that GUY is heavier EDM than Selfie. Selfie is more of the same EDM that we have been hearing for the past 2, while GUY has heavier and more edgy synths.
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 59
  • Created
  • Last Reply

AGREED!

She should have released it as ARTPOP Act I with 8 tracks and worked on more better music for ACT II that would be released later this year.

ARTPOP ACT I (November 2013)

01. VENUS

02. GUY

03. SEXXX DREAMS

04. DO WHAT U WANT

05. ARTPOP

06. DOPE

07. GYPSY

08. APPLAUSE

ARTPOP ACT II (November 2014)

01. AURA

02. SWINE

03. *NEW TRACK*

04. *NEW TRACK*

05. *NEW TRACK*

06. *NEW TRACK*

07. *NEW TRACK*

08. *NEW TRACK*

GOOD-****in-BYE to sub par tracks such as Jewels'n'd--gs, MANiCURE, Donatella, Fashion and Mary Jane Holland.

Bye

Link to post
Share on other sites

Tropico

No, it doesn't sound fresh. It doesn't sound really all that current. Plus it sounds like a weaker mixture of some of her other songs. Applause was the right first single and it proved it by staying strong for many months and it was used by shows on TV as intros. I heard it everywhere. GUY would have put her dead in the water.

You're right... It doesn't sound current... It sounds a head of the game. This is a whole new game. This album is an electro-pop sound like no other. Especially songs like G.U.Y., Aura, MJH, Applause and Donatella. It's the perfect blend of edm and pop music. It doesn't sound loud and irritating like a lot of EDM these days. It also doesn't sound to bubblegum pop like Eh, Eh. It's a perfect balance. Show casing her vocals while still giving fresh new beats.

Sounds like something which'll be huge.

Actually I think that GUY is heavier EDM than Selfie. Selfie is more of the same EDM that we have been hearing for the past 2, while GUY has heavier and more edgy synths.

Are you being serious :sharon:? G.U.Y. Is just a very dance emphasised dance pop track. It's no where neeeeeaaaaarrrr as hardcore as SELFIE. SELFIE is just a lash of EDM strips. G.U.Y. Is the most EDM in the intro and ending. The verses are just catchy beats.

♢ Social Justice Enthusiast ♢
Link to post
Share on other sites

PopBitch

I think ARTPOP, the song, sounds fresh and unlike anything else out there.  That's the song that should be a single.  I've said it before.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hexxx

It ended with DWUW tbh.

Lady Gaga/ Madonna/Lana /Azealia Banks/ Jazmine Sullivan/ DEEE-LITE/ Moko
Link to post
Share on other sites

Quark

You're right... It doesn't sound current... It sounds a head of the game. This is a whole new game. This album is an electro-pop sound like no other. Especially songs like G.U.Y., Aura, MJH, Applause and Donatella. It's the perfect blend of edm and pop music. It doesn't sound loud and irritating like a lot of EDM these days. It also doesn't sound to bubblegum pop like Eh, Eh. It's a perfect balance. Show casing her vocals while still giving fresh new beats.

Sounds like something which'll be huge.

Are you being serious :sharon:? G.U.Y. Is just a very dance emphasised dance pop track. It's no where neeeeeaaaaarrrr as hardcore as SELFIE. SELFIE is just a lash of EDM strips. G.U.Y. Is the most EDM in the intro and ending. The verses are just catchy beats.

First of all, dance pop is also EDM. And Selfie is not hardcore at all. What I would consider hardcore EDM is something like Aura or MJH.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Tropico

First of all, dance pop is also EDM. And Selfie is not hardcore at all. What I would consider hardcore EDM is something like Aura or MJH.

MJH? Honestly :fail:? It is not hardcore. And Aura? That's not hardcore either.

Listen to Martin Garrix... He is hardcore.

And dance pop and EDM are quite different... Dance pop is more about making you get up and dance but more focused on the vocals. And EDM is mostly focused on the beat and raver vibes.

♢ Social Justice Enthusiast ♢
Link to post
Share on other sites

pachinko

Stop hoping for her to suddenly get her groove back. Inspiration comes best when it's organic, not when you sit down and force it out.

THIS.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Elizabeth

The ARTPOP era hasn't ended as far as I'm aware. She's still on tour supporting the album, and there potentially might be more singles. We don't know for sure. I'm happy for her to do whatever she feels is best. Gaga is the artist. 

 

 

 ARTPOP isn't my favourite album however if she stuck with her original plans I would have respected ARTPOP a lot more.

I think that's a really unfair comment. It's obvious from the little we know, that due to what was going on within her team/management around the start of the era, and the personal effects that had on her, it would've been impossible to stick to whatever her original plans for the era were. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think that's a really unfair comment. It's obvious from the little we know, that due to what was going on within her team/management around the start of the era, and the personal effects that had on her, it would've been impossible to stick to whatever her original plans for the era were. 

 

It's a completely fair comment. Every era has its issues, but she never let them stop her until now. Why let them ruin the ARTPOP era?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Emvee

It ended with DWUW tbh.

So G.U.Y. doesn't count cause it flopped?

SXSW and Roseland didn't happen, I guess. :smh:

In fact, Gaga isn't even on tour. She has retired to her big mansion and stacks of money and won't make a new album until her team of writers and producers make one for her.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Elizabeth

 

It's a completely fair comment. Every era has its issues, but she never let them stop her until now. Why let them ruin the ARTPOP era?

I disagree because I think the circumstances surrounding the issues and the reasons for those issues were different to anything in previous eras. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Paper Gangsta

If she had promoted G.U.Y. properly, it could have easily gone to no.1

Also, I feel that ARTPOP should have been released as an EP. If she got rid of some songs, it would be a far more respected album. I'd have made G.U.Y. the first single this era and PROPERLY promoted it. Then Do What U Want, which was going great with the GP, but it would have done so much better if it had a MV or more promotion.

You are overrating G.U.Y. There is no way it would do better than Applause

Link to post
Share on other sites

Quark

MJH? Honestly :fail:? It is not hardcore. And Aura? That's not hardcore either.

Listen to Martin Garrix... He is hardcore.

And dance pop and EDM are quite different... Dance pop is more about making you get up and dance but more focused on the vocals. And EDM is mostly focused on the beat and raver vibes.

I have listened to Martin Garrix and only some of his songs are hardcore. And once again, EDM is just the main label/title for many categories of electronic dance music. The categories include dance pop, dubstep, trap, house, techno, ect. So dance pop and EDM can't be different because they are the same thing. And as far as Aura and MJH goes, I guess that we just have different opinions as far as what hardcore is o<(0_0)>o.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...