Mechanical Horses - Gaga Shades Katy

[Neal 768]

You didn't get what I said. Everything was already done in this world, especially in pop culture, because pop culture is pretty repetitive. Your point of view is based on being a Gaga fan and maybe you don't realize that these are many artists that do stuff much more creative than Gaga does, which is much harder to compare to others.

Btw, look at pics of Gaga even few months before she "became" Gaga. Was she really such a "weiro" she always claims to have been?

But there was no "Gaga" before she became Gaga. When she broke out, she wasn't like Madonna at all. However, Katy changed her image to cater to the audience that Gaga was building up to.

PRISM release dates? Gay rights bandwagon? Anyone?

[degenerate 526]

Is GUY rising?

[feelitinmybones 0]

True, but I believe at the time Katy said she wasn't talking about Gaga. Whether that's true or not is debatable, but in general Katy has been really nice towards Gaga. There was a recent radio interview she did in Australia where she defended Gaga against a DJ who was trying to pit them against each other. That really gave me a high opinion of her and to see Gaga say something like this is very sad.

Also, Gaga can't really talk about copying tbh. ArtRAVE is a carbon copy of Katy Perry's general aesthetic and everybody knows it.

Not going to lie you completely lost me at the last bit :sweat:

[Ellie Goulding 8]

Gaga needs to decide if she wants to be the preacher from BTW or the bad b---h from TF. Trying to juggle both makes her look extremely two faced and hypocritical. 

[freebit 6,135]

spill, this fanbase is soft as hell 

IKR? Never on a fansite have I seen so many allowing their fave to be shaded over someone else. Like when that Lana diss song leaked, people were trying to be all "oh don't you be dragging Lana!!1!! This was years ago!" I was like We're like the liberals/democrats of the fandom world tbh, allowing ourselves and our fave to get railroaded. I think its because we all feel the need to distance ourselves from the crazy, death-threat-sending twitter stans, so we overcompensate.

[Vanilla 660]

Online kindness is about not bullying people. It doesn't mean you can't stand up for yourself. I can't at you children not understanding the difference. She did not name call or bully, she stated facts that you closet Katy Keene stans can't handle.

 

Again, defending yourself and your work does not violate the rules of online kindness. If she had called her Katy Keene and accused her being a reductive talentless wanker, then yes, she'd be in the wrong. But she didn't say anything like that. She stated something factual.

 

It's only shady to people because it's true. No one would be crying "SHADE SHADE!!" unless there was some basis in reality for the accusation. FACT.

 

Hop off your mechanical high horse if you can't tell I was clearly joking you "Child"

[superman 32]

and not you ppl acting like katy s album sold circles around gaga s lol. bey crashed her effortlessly so poor katy her supposingly biggest era being overshadowed by beyonce without her moving her finger.

[NewUsername 11,056]

Gaga really shouldn't have went there but some people in this thread are being ridiculous . They want to defend Katy now and say they are embarrassed for Gaga bu the next minute they will be shading her.

 

Plus the hardcore katy fans on this site need to really get off their high horse when all they do in every post and thread is shade Gaga and defend Katy everyday. You can't really have it both ways.

a mechanical one?     sorry, I couldn't just NOT go there :p

[Neal 768]

Online kindness is about not bullying people. It doesn't mean you can't stand up for yourself. I can't at you children not understanding the difference. She did not name call or bully, she stated facts that you closet Katy Keene stans can't handle.

Again, defending yourself and your work does not violate the rules of online kindness. If she had called her Katy Keene and accused her being a reductive talentless wanker, then yes, she'd be in the wrong. But she didn't say anything like that. She stated something factual.

It's only shady to people because it's true. No one would be crying "SHADE SHADE!!" unless there was some basis in reality for the accusation. FACT.

SLAY on this post. Pin this please. Educate the Katy Keene stans.

[Morphine Prince 103,594]

19 pages  

 

YESSS. 

[Slayer 9,227]

I don't think she was either, more like pointing out a trend she set rather than "oh look at Katy with no ideas"

 

But it's b---hy. And the complete antithesis of the ENTIRE POINT of this era.  :toofloppy:

[Tommy Monster 816]

She finally stood up for herself   and it was about time 

[Crash 11]

It's like nobody can do anything vaguely similar to Gaga without being labelled as an unoriginal copycat. Sigh.

And the reverse is also true, she can't do anything without someone pulling out stuff from Madonna, Grace Jones, etc

[chris777 112]

Online kindness is about not bullying people. It doesn't mean you can't stand up for yourself. I can't at you children not understanding the difference. She did not name call or bully, she stated facts that you closet Katy Keene stans can't handle.

 

Again, defending yourself and your work does not violate the rules of online kindness. If she had called her Katy Keene and accused her being a reductive talentless wanker, then yes, she'd be in the wrong. But she didn't say anything like that. She stated something factual.

 

It's only shady to people because it's true. No one would be crying "SHADE SHADE!!" unless there was some basis in reality for the accusation. FACT.

 

And some of you crying "Shade!" are probably some of the most shady people who ever lived you just won't admit. It takes one to know one.

then Madonna's shade never should have bother anyone. 

after all she just said reductive

[Nullvoid 71]

Wow Madonna sure was shady with Katy.. 

Edited May 8, 2014 by mralexv