Jump to content
A Star Is Born
opinion

RedOne is overrated

Featured Posts

Hyperballad   Paws Up 2,318
Hyperballad
3 minutes ago, KingRedd said:

What is with this site and feeling the need to deem people “overrated” lmao

I like redone 

alot of stans hype him up as some amazing groundbreaking producer that Gaga needs when in reality his music is just regular 2010’s pop that doesnt age well :vegas:

3 minutes ago, SKANK said:

Her collaborations with RedOne resonate with the public more than anything else she ever has done, which is something that is important to her. 

Elton John has been collaborating with the same song writing partner for fifty years.

Continuing to write songs with RedOne does not mean creative stagnation. 

They are a great team. 

they make amazing pop music, but as we saw from Joanne and ARTPOP... she’s more than a typical “pop artist” and alot of the producers she’s chosen to work with are really great and creative 

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
SKANK   Paws Up 6,724
SKANK
15 minutes ago, Hyperballad said:

alot of stans hype him up as some amazing groundbreaking producer that Gaga needs when in reality his music is just regular 2010’s pop that doesnt age well :vegas:

they make amazing pop music, but as we saw from Joanne and ARTPOP... she’s more than a typical “pop artist” and alot of the producers she’s chosen to work with are really great and creative 

 

Joanne was written and produced by a team of hit makers. Bloodpop - fresh off his hit with Justin Bieber. Mark Ronson - fresh off his hit with Bruno Mars. Hillary Lindsey - fresh after her “Girl Crush” hit. And of course, RedOne.

It’s wasn’t as big of a creative risk as you think it was. 

 

  • Like 5
  • Thanks 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
PhillipBagshaw   Paws Up 1,204
PhillipBagshaw
1 hour ago, Hyperballad said:

i dont want to sound like im HATING on him and i do love his work on her albums but constantly working with him wouldnt be evolving it’d be like trying to recreate past success :gum:

Yeah I definitely understand that, I just don't think is work is entirely overrated, but I think the idea of the work they can make is overrated. 

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
reversewarhol   Paws Up 403
reversewarhol

Fans only want Gaga to work with him again because they want a hit. I think we ALL know Gaga’s best work are DJWS produced songs 

  • Like 2
  • LMAO 1
  • Sad 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
THEORACLE64   Paws Up 544
THEORACLE64

Scheiße exists so no, he’s not. His best work is with Gaga though honestly - she just brings the best out in him. 

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 2

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
L E O   Paws Up 1,325
L E O

Go listen to Joanne if you think that Bad Romance, Boys Boys Boys Just Dance, LoveGame, Money Honey, Paper Gangsta, Poker Face, Alejandro, Monster, So Happy I Could Die, Hair, Judas and motherf-cking Scheiße are not of your liking. But don't mistake your opinion and taste, which are of course valid, with facts. 

Y'all need to learn to respect people's work, even if you don't like it (which I find it hard to believe considering the numbers of songs he produced, but hey, taste...)

2 hours ago, reversewarhol said:

Fans only want Gaga to work with him again because they want a hit. I think we ALL know Gaga’s best work are DJWS produced songs 

Or maybe we want him because we consider his work with Gaga the best instead, and we have more fun listening to his produced songs? 

I know I'd dance to Scheiße over ANY Gaga song, anyday.

  • Like 2
  • YAAAS 2

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Defmix100   Paws Up 321
Defmix100
4 hours ago, Hyperballad said:

i dont want to sound like im HATING on him and i do love his work on her albums but constantly working with him wouldnt be evolving it’d be like trying to recreate past success :gum:

People in creative industries often work together because they can create gold, it doesn't mean they both aren't evolving together. Think of Christopher Nolan and Hans Zimmer or Quentin Tarantino and the late Sally Menke. Gaga can bring out new sounds from Redone like she always did, he hasn't made songs for other artists that sound like BR or SHICD and that is because of her

  • Thanks 2

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Craig Barnes   Paws Up 8,483
Craig Barnes
5 hours ago, Hyperballad said:

I dont get how alot of us want her to work with him when his music now is very dated :ph34r: 

shouldnt Gaga be evolving instead of just trying to make an album of bops, i mean i love The Fame - Born This Way but i think another album with Redone would just sound... bad? :madge: 

i’m not trying to seem like crazy stan that wants her to do what I want her to do but Sophie and alot of people shes working with make amazing and awesome music 

i just cant comprehend how some of us just want her to stay stuck trying to repeat her past success :nails: 

with that said, I personally just want Gaga to do what she feels and wants.. albums always turn out great when the artist has control (ex: Velvet Rope, Ray of Light, Impossible Princess, Hounds of Love) 

I agree 100% 

  • Like 1
Guess who's back back back back back again

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Craig Barnes   Paws Up 8,483
Craig Barnes
5 hours ago, Der Meister said:

 

This song was made in 2009... if anything this proves the point that he is over rated. 

I don't want Gaga to go back and do sounds that she has already done 8-10 years ago. And we been knew RedOne re-uses his sounds to create songs. 

Guess who's back back back back back again

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Craig Barnes   Paws Up 8,483
Craig Barnes
1 hour ago, L E O said:

Go listen to Joanne if you think that Bad Romance, Boys Boys Boys Just Dance, LoveGame, Money Honey, Paper Gangsta, Poker Face, Alejandro, Monster, So Happy I Could Die, Hair, Judas and motherf-cking Scheiße are not of your liking. But don't mistake your opinion and taste, which are of course valid, with facts. 

Y'all need to learn to respect people's work, even if you don't like it (which I find it hard to believe considering the numbers of songs he produced, but hey, taste...)

Or maybe we want him because we consider his work with Gaga the best instead, and we have more fun listening to his produced songs? 

I know I'd dance to Scheiße over ANY Gaga song, anyday.

Scheiße is good... but not that good

Guess who's back back back back back again

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
GagaUnderYou   Paws Up 1,324
GagaUnderYou

RedOne hate will not be tolerated. In addition to Gaga’s work ethic, he is a huge part of why Gaga’s music sounded fresh in 2008, and solidified her role in pop music. In my opinion, he’s always saving his best for Gaga. I’m sure they have tons of unreleased that sound amazing!

  • Like 5

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hyperballad   Paws Up 2,318
Hyperballad
5 hours ago, SKANK said:

 

Joanne was written and produced by a team of hit makers. Bloodpop - fresh off his hit with Justin Bieber. Mark Ronson - fresh off his hit with Bruno Mars. Hillary Lindsey - fresh after her “Girl Crush” hit. And of course, RedOne.

It’s wasn’t as big of a creative risk as you think it was. 

 

who said it was a risk :oprah: All i said is that she’s more than what we’ve seen from hers and RedOne’s music.. RedOne’s Instrumental rarely dives into different genres besides dance-pop and while she’s primarily ‘dance-pop’ shes shown she’s shown that she can pull of genres like electronica, country, EDM, and jazz 

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
GhettoFabulous   Paws Up 14,741
GhettoFabulous

I wouldn’t say he’s “overrated” but he’s not ALL that I mean imo I mean even though some of my most favorite Gaga songs were produced by him I appreciate her branching out and working with others I mean I wouldn’t mind if there was a new redone song I’d love to hear how they’d work together now :lolly:

BΔK

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
pop music