HARLEQUIN 70 on MC

[Finneas 792]

As long as it stays green it’s fine

[artd0me 702]

Why care about critics’ opinion, when she’s praised by legends and her peers 🤷🏼‍♂️

[Debithius 5,824]

Metacritic isn't even meta anymore? So why do we care about their ratings even if it's good or not?

[weed 73,484]

The critics can choke

always trying to dim her shine

[Anderson123 38,042]

Not trying to drag anyone but it’s so random to see how critics reviews work now or wondering how old they are or how much of the love for an artist affects that. Something like Harlequin would be much higher if it were a Beyoncé project but then there’s also Brat with 95 which is a bit repetitive in it’s lyrics and a fun club record. You just don’t know what to expect anymore. 

[HelloHangoverz 17,409]

no non-pop Gaga record will ever be a hit with the critics. she's first and foremost a pop artist to them and they're not gonna do the kind of work required to properly adjust/appreciate Gaga when she's non-pop

[southpaw773 3,184]

She’s a top streamer worldwide which I think matters more than some MC numbers but it’s interesting! 

[Mister G 10,346]

I think we all are enjoying the body of work which says more than these critics. Who cares what they have to say? Her legacy is legendary and that's all that matters.

[InTheCloset 19,112]

we about to get dragged so much i fear

lets hope other critics give it a full score and it reaches a 90

Spoiler

im delusional 

 

[RAMROD 108,611]

1 minute ago, InTheCloset said:

we about to get dragged so much i fear

lets hope other critics give it a full score and it reaches a 90

  Hide contents

im delusional 

 

65 isn't bad at all. It's still in the green meaning more positive than negative aka wide acceptance 

 

[chathonnete 708]

40 minutes ago, Reality said:

Gaga’s Metacritic ratings have always been fairly low. Out of her solo albums, Chromatica’s the highest and that’s at 79. TF has a 71, TFM has a 78, BTW has a 71, ARTPOP has a 61, and Joanne has a 67. They’re all too low imo 

I'm a massive Gaga fan, but except for BTW I find these ratings pretty accurate when it comes to production, and the quality of music. More than 80 is an impressivly high note. Only BTW deserves more than 80 in my opinion. 
 

However, if tours, visuals, music videos and live performances were included in the rating, I don't see one Gaga album that deserves under 70 

[chathonnete 708]

I listened to it this morning and I would say it's not that much something we've never heard from Gaga. 65 is a pretty good grade and it will rise I'm sure ! 
 

I feel like the universe is pushing Gaga to release LG7, people are ready for it, waiting for it, and it will be her highest rated album, I'm sure of it !!

[erfaan 2,789]

41 minutes ago, gfarabello said:

Agreed. This album is equivalent to Beyonce's Cowboy Carter in terms of genre-crossing, which got a 91 on metacritic.

Cowboy Carter was literally such a bad album and this is coming from a huge bey fan. 

[Ladymars 3,719]

5 minutes ago, chathonnete said:

I'm a massive Gaga fan, but except for BTW I find these ratings pretty accurate when it comes to production, and the quality of music. More than 80 is an impressivly high note. Only BTW deserves more than 80 in my opinion. 
 

However, if tours, visuals, music videos and live performances were included in the rating, I don't see one Gaga album that deserves under 70 

Kinda agree 

but what I hate the most is the most basic, cover filled album like cowboy carter did 91 which is so inflated let’s be honest that album deserves 55 at the most 

this critic don’t judge the body of work. They only give great numbers to those artists who they perceive as goddes aka Beyoncé or who they are popular or in fashion right now (brat )

[chathonnete 708]

1 minute ago, Ladymars said:

Kinda agree 

but what I hate the most is the most basic, cover filled album like cowboy carter did 91 which is so inflated let’s be honest that album deserves 55 at the most 

this critic don’t judge the body of work. They only give great numbers to those artists who they perceive as goddes aka Beyoncé or who they are popular or in fashion right now (brat )

I agree, also I think critics are afraid of fans. If they were 100% honest the grades would be lower often. Gaga's fanbase is respectful and don't attack low critics, which is good