Telephone vs. Rain On Me

[4th Time Around 4,455]

This is actually really close, Telephone is more iconic even though Rain On Me is a slightly better song in my opinion 

[River 115,002]

43 minutes ago, Gagaism said:

Which is fine, humans won’t have much time left anyways 

such a lovely news

[Duella Dvil 10,424]

The one with the Grammy

[TwistedTeeth 2,172]

I would've picked Rain On Me if it were a solo act. Telephone is iconic, there's more hype to it, the music video is unforgettable, it has Beyonce on it Telephone is that girl.

[Zombiecat 16,461]

telephone is way more iconic but rain on me is probs like my 3rd fave Gaga song 

[RochestrMonstr 3,107]

Both are among my lowest rated duets for her. Telephone is much better though. 
 

ROM always seemed like it should have been so much better with all that vocal talent between the two women. 

[VasilisVas 5,134]

Telephone without a doubt. I never cared much for rain on me. 

[steven 5,865]

I like Telephone but ROM is one of her best produced songs

[KennyRichie 1,969]

Both for me, like they are iconic on their own 

[Nycboy 1,054]

TELEPHONE. 

1. The music video shook the planet

2. Beyonce singing grand central stay-shunnn

3. Gaga was at one of her creative PEAKS 

4. ROM sounds oddly impersonal to me. Maybe it’s all the instrumental parts? 

[Anderson123 38,042]

Telephone is one of her most iconic singles and collaborations but my love for it comes and goes. It’s probably my least favorite song from The Fame Monster and I don’t hate it but it’s a bit meh for me right now. 

I want to vote Rain On Me because it slaps but at the same time I look at it and put it next to Telephone and realize that Rain On Me just like all of Chromatica sounds like a song that follows a formula (a very good one), while Telephone feels more Gaga or edgier, idk how to explain it. Rain On Me could’ve been written for other popstar while no one other than Gaga and Bey fit Telephone even if that’s still one of my least favorite singles. 

[Economy 49,363]

I actually like Telephone. Catchy as hell and dunno why it gets as much indifference or even hate as it does tbh

[Chlorine 47,976]

Ray Non Meigh is the winner

[A Fried Egg 8,487]

5 hours ago, Catnikko said:

telephone is way more iconic but rain on me is probs like my 3rd fave Gaga song 

Rain On Me is also my 3rd fave Gaga song 

Edited September 19, 2024 by Roronoa

[SevenWonder 4,296]

ROM is an objectively better pop song. By far (for me). But Telephone was such a moment - even if the song is kinda so-so.  

A bit of a toss up for me.