Is "911" at Chromatica ball proof that Gag needs a full metal album?

[Staryu17 4,023]

Like, seriously look at the material - 

also honourable mentions to "Perfect illlusion" and "dancin in circles" 

[Borisapillar 5,259]

Honey that ain’t metal that’s tinfoil but we do love it

[Anderson123 26,267]

Well, we know she's got the vocals for it and actually likes and understands the genre.

As for the 911 metal thing, I just don't see it. There's some Metal influences on Born This Way.

Edited December 3, 2022 by Anderson123

[catsounds 8,871]

no

[Reality 60,737]

911 isn’t metal though…

[TheFame Monster 8,033]

Not metal, but a full on industrial pop album

Songs like 911, MTN, BJ+AF, Electric Chapel, Bloody Mary, John Wayne, MJH, PI

[Staryu17 4,023]

56 minutes ago, Reality said:

911 isn’t metal though…

I'm aware, but the stage vibe is (sorta)

[StressedOut 470]

I'd love for her to dive into some more metal/punk/goth/industrial vibes omg 

[NashvilleGAGA 74]

1 hour ago, TheFame Monster said:

Not metal, but a full on industrial pop album

Songs like 911, MTN, BJ+AF, Electric Chapel, Bloody Mary, John Wayne, MJH, PI

Does ScheiBe count too? If so your list is all of my favorites. Maybe HML too

[DoctorScent 609]

I don't understand fans that want Gags to do a rock or metal album when you hardly could stream Perfect Illusion, Brown Eyes, Again Again and Electric Chapel

[Mother of Puppies 30,050]

9 minutes ago, DoctorScent said:

I don't understand fans that want Gags to do a rock or metal album when you hardly could stream Perfect Illusion, Brown Eyes, Again Again and Electric Chapel

I guess most want dark electronic pop music with industrial vibes and rock/metal aesthetics (and rock vocals)

Edited December 3, 2022 by Mother of Puppies

[DoctorScent 609]

18 minutes ago, Mother of Puppies said:

I guess most want dark electronic pop music with industrial vibes and rock/metal aesthetics (and rock vocals)

Oh I get that. We want another Born This Way. I'm in <3

[TimotheeChalamet 1,117]

A full rock or metal album would be a great suit for Gaga but neither 911 or Born This Way have nothing to do with that (except very light influences on some tracks). As for the aesthetic, she's been dressing in leather over a red background since The Monster Ball I think 

[Blackout19 6,527]

We need Joanne 2.0, Born To Die, Chemtrails Over The Country Club type of album

[Tinnitus15 41,636]

Let that metal album rest. It IS NOT gonna work