Ryan Murphy asks fans which story they'd like to see in AHS

[Enigma 7,182]

Just now, Luke78619 said:

Oooh what did the DMs say exactly?  I must’ve missed this

OT: I wouldn’t want piggy man again, we’ve already had that. Bloody Mary sounds like it could be cool if he were able to put a unique spin on it, rather than just a family haunted by her and learning about her last  

I couldn’t imagine a Plague season, he normally focuses on people and evil within, but plagues aren’t really a part of that.. unless we’re talking about deliberate spread of plagues or supernatural plagues idk

Xmas horror sounds shite  I love Sirens and Aliens

wish I could find it again but he dmed one fan saying by the sand would be something fans have been asking for, and in another dm he says "one word : aliens" (it does sound made up so it could have been, but last time I heard of it everyone seemed to believe it was legit)

[hieronymus 8,147]

4 hours ago, thedirtymonster said:

I'd love to see a mini-series for a Christmas Horror Story. But for an entire season? I'd say sirens, Bloody Mary, or plague. Honestly, there could be a mini-series about a modern American Christmas where a family goes apeshit on each other a la the movie Ready or Not and it could be awesome. They could bring in some 23 and me DNA test buls#!t where one of them took the test and learns some family secret, then tells one member to give them a heads-up about the drama, and then they turn on each other. It would be great. Lol!

You should check out this if you haven't seen it already.

 

Also Apocalypse used the 23 and Me thing to find the "special DNA" of the 2 characters that were only in like 3 episodes all season, but given the prevalence of those tests these days and Ryan Murphy's bonner for repeated themes, I can see it getting used again to cause drama.

[ELECTROHEART 6,428]

Something about a serial killer on Grindr 

[imnotyourbabe10 5,995]

1) Water/creature horror. Lovecraftian and/or sirens.

2) Desert/Western and aliens. Brothel perhaps?

3) Snow/winter or mountain landscape horror

[Bebe 16,562]

I don’t usually vibe aliens and sci-fi but I feel like it could be interpreted in an interesting way in the AHS universe 

[MonsterPaws 2,631]

16 hours ago, adoga said:

Plague omg that would be so cool

Agreed! It's Aliens or Plague for me. The latter would be great for social commentary on some of the stuff we saw during the pandemic (e.g. influencers holding parties, anti maskers etc).

[zakariah 11,556]

aliens is so boring, piggy man has been done to death in ahs already imo, they had that 1 x’mas episode in asylum so i’m over that idea already & plague might be too much like apocalypse

I think the most interesting ones would be either Sirens or Bloody Mary

[Sneaky Oliver 20,081]

How can they make a plague season if the show is called AMERICAN horror story though? 
 

I voted for Sirens. Give me AHS: Leviathan