[POLL] Best Gaga Producer?

[Xenoqueen 10]

23 minutes ago, Wet Fire said:

1. RedOne, especially for Just Dance, Love Game, Poker Face, Bad Romance, Alejandro, Judas & Scheiße.

2. Fernando Garibay, especially for Dance in the Dark, Marry the Night, Born This Way & The Edge of Glory.

3. BloodPop, especially for Rain on Me, Alice, 911 & Babylon.

All fantastic producers. 

 

911 was Madeon. Don’t give that clown credit for Chromatica’s best song!

[Bradley 46,101]

1 hour ago, Sour Candy said:

RedOne. You can love or hate him, but Gaga's succes is his merit 

Are you from Azerbaijan?

Maybe you're straight and we should not call you sis?

[Andreu 35,612]

1 hour ago, Sour Candy said:

it is what is 
please don't even try with exhausting arguments aka she is hard-working and creative
they are so many talented people in the industry, who are even better than Gaga in some aspects, but they don't get their chance to shine
without the commercial sound of RedOne back then, she would've not been famous, that's a fact 

and why is RedOne's material as a lead not only pretty much trash but also commercially unsuccessful, to the point the album he wanted to release five years ago is still nowhere to be seen?

[Agunimon 9,664]

1 hour ago, Sour Candy said:

it is what is 
please don't even try with exhausting arguments aka she is hard-working and creative
they are so many talented people in the industry, who are even better than Gaga in some aspects, but they don't get their chance to shine
without the commercial sound of RedOne back then, she would've not been famous, that's a fact 

I agree. RedOne contributed massively to her rise and gave her the early career hits she needed, and I am sure she is fully aware of his contributions to the development of her early career. I wonder where she would have gotten if RedOne wasn't assigned to her projects. Her success earlier in her career granted her a lot of artistic freedom in her music that she was able to express afterwards.

Unfortunately he kind of fell off over the years and just repeats the same sounds these days.

[TimisaMonster 27,203]

Honestly without RedOne...we'd have no Gaga to this day...respect gives him the trophy

[Wet Fire 2,255]

1 hour ago, Xenoqueen said:

911 was Madeon. Don’t give that clown credit for Chromatica’s best song!

It was Bloodpop and Madeon.

[Xenoqueen 10]

43 minutes ago, Wet Fire said:

It was Bloodpop and Madeon.

Was it, though? 

[Wet Fire 2,255]

3 hours ago, Xenoqueen said:

Was it, though? 

Umm...yes 

[LittleMonster20 6,806]

Madeon. He produced my favorite songs (911, Mary Jane Holland).

Would like for him to produce more!

[LGMonster95 13,702]

Don't get me wrong, all of Gaga's producers deserves a lot of credit for what they did (I think my fav is DJWS because he is the most versatile producer out there). But Gaga herself deserves the same amount of credit because she also has a major influence on how her songs should sound like 

[mr wayne 472]

Garibay, RedOne & DJWS: the holy trinity 

Honorable mentions to Zedd & Madeon.

[HausOfAntonio 4,274]

Madeon HANDS. DOWN. What they made together is magic, absolute perfection. I wish he would be a main collaborator in a future album. 

[littleboyblue 604]

Gaga's melodies >> 

But I give it to Ronson. He lends her some maturity and groundedness. A combo of BURNS, Madeon, and Mark Ronson is my wet dream for LG7.

ETA: I detest BloodPop for the simple fact that he robbed us of proper choruses in Chromatica. (Okay, no clue if it was his idea but it was on his watch, and his preference for those pseudo-vocals kinda gives it away)

Edited January 13 by littleboyblue

[shoful 12,621]

I think we can all agree it’s not Bloodpop or Mark Ronson 

[Peter Parker 15,443]

Glad to see Fernando winning, he’s very underrated