Jump to content
Follow Gaga Daily on Telegram

ROUND 8 - Plus/Minus - Battle Royale of Gaga's discography


Gerrard174
 Share

Featured Posts

degenerate

So i have to take off 2 points of some flop songs and give the 2 points to other songs?

Basicalleh. But give them to songs that you like obviously, or songs that deserve to be higher. Same with songs that deserve to be lower

And yayyy mah songs in the lead!

Edited by degenerate
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 897
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Gerrard174

    131

  • Guille

    63

  • misanthrope

    49

  • Pure Adrenaline

    47

Telephone >> Judas

Someone needs to kill Judas.

Gurl, bye Maybe video-wise but song-wise Judas murders Telephone. Gaga even has a hard time listening to Telephone.

"My people… need to let our bitchiness out. Otherwise, it turns to bile and poisons us"
Link to post
Share on other sites

Telephone: 2

Just Dance: 8

Monster: 8

Judas: 8

Government Hooker: 12 (+1)

Alejandro: 10 (-1)

Bloody Mary: 10 (+1)

Poker Face: 10

Marry the Night: 11

So Happy I Could Die: 9 (-1)

Scheiße: 16

Dance in the Dark: 18

Heavy Metal Lover: 19

Bad Romance: 19

Paparazzi: 21

The Edge of Glory: 20

Link to post
Share on other sites

misanthrope

Gurl, bye Maybe video-wise but song-wise Judas murders Telephone. Gaga even has a hard time listening to Telephone.

Judas is overrated, Telephone is obviously underrated. Plus she only has trouble listening to it because recording it was a stressful experience for her. She has no objections to the song itself~

Link to post
Share on other sites

degenerate

Judas is overrated, Telephone is obviously underrated. Plus she only has trouble listening to it because recording it was a stressful experience for her. She has no objections to the song itself~

Subjective. I think it's a disaster of a song with 4 minutes of annoying generic dance beats with some of the most cheesy lyrics in Gaga's discography. It also lacks composition - the whole song just sounds the same to me. No ups, no downs, just.....eh. It's clear it was made for Britney, let's put it that way.

Telephone: 1

Monster: 8

Judas: 8

So Happy I Could Die: 9

Just Dance: 9

Alejandro: 10

Bloody Mary: 10

Poker Face: 10

Marry the Night: 11

Government Hooker: 12

Scheiße: 16

Dance in the Dark: 18

Heavy Metal Lover: 19

Bad Romance: 19

The Edge of Glory: 19

Paparazzi: 22

Link to post
Share on other sites

misanthrope

Subjective. I think it's a disaster of a song with 4 minutes of annoying generic dance beats with some of the most cheesy lyrics in Gaga's discography. It also lacks composition - the whole song just sounds the same to me. No ups, no downs, just.....eh. It's clear it was made for Britney, let's put it that way.

When people put it down for not being a conceptually knotted mess I shake my head. Its a fun pop song that serves its purpose and she executed it so well. I'd rather have an album of Telephone's than an album consisting of overly wrought and calculated attempts at being out of the box.

Link to post
Share on other sites

degenerate

When people put it down for not being a conceptually knotted mess I shake my head. Its a fun pop song that serves its purpose and she executed it so well. I'd rather have an album of Telephone's than an album consisting of overly wrought and calculated attempts at being out of the box.

I'd love an album full of fun dance tracks too. BTW was too try hard. Telephone was just a hit and a miss, IMO.

Link to post
Share on other sites

misanthrope

I'd love an album full of fun dance tracks too. BTW was too try hard. Telephone was just a hit and a miss, IMO.

Well as much as I like it at least we can agree on that. Plus i've always liked Britney Spears a lot which one could assume might play into why I don't turn my nose up to Telephone.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Pure Adrenaline

-Telephone: 0-

Monster: 8

Judas: 8

So Happy I Could Die: 9

Just Dance: 9

Alejandro: 9

Bloody Mary: 10

Poker Face: 10

Marry the Night: 11

Government Hooker: 12

Scheiße: 16

Dance in the Dark: 18

Bad Romance: 19

Heavy Metal Lover: 20

The Edge of Glory: 20

Paparazzi: 22

Finally we could say goodbye to another song...

It's much more fun to have hizophrenia... u never get lonely
Link to post
Share on other sites

degenerate

monster4ever is not playing by the rules.

gorl no one does. it would take literally years to finish this game if everyone voted once a week

Edited by degenerate
Link to post
Share on other sites

Just Dance: 8

Monster: 7

Judas: 9

Government Hooker: 12

Alejandro: 9

Bloody Mary: 10

Poker Face: 10

Marry the Night: 11

So Happy I Could Die: 10

Scheiße: 16

Dance in the Dark: 18

Heavy Metal Lover: 20

Bad Romance: 19

Paparazzi: 22

The Edge of Glory: 20

"My people… need to let our bitchiness out. Otherwise, it turns to bile and poisons us"
Link to post
Share on other sites

WhiplashCowboy

Just Dance: 8

Monster: 7

Judas: 9

Government Hooker: 12

Alejandro: 9

Bloody Mary: 10

Poker Face: 10

Marry the Night: 11

So Happy I Could Die: 10

Scheiße: 16

Dance in the Dark: 18

Heavy Metal Lover: 20

Bad Romance: 19

Paparazzi: 22

The Edge of Glory: 20

The round is already over. 5 songs (Hair,Lovegame, Y&I, BTW and Telephone) are eliminated

Link to post
Share on other sites

The round is already over. 5 songs (Hair,Lovegame, Y&I, BTW and Telephone) are eliminated

Oh lol sorry

"My people… need to let our bitchiness out. Otherwise, it turns to bile and poisons us"
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Mills locked this topic
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share


×
×
  • Create New...