SFA is the worst song on Chromatica

[tyler k 3,011]

bye

[ToxicHot 6,425]

8 minutes ago, gabeoz said:

For me (personally, not trying to discount your opinion) I really love it. At the end, the way she sings about hearing the sine at the very end and the audio of the rainy street before the bass ending signifies the sine that she heard in reference in the song.

Oh no no I LOVE the ending too! I was just saying that I understand why the OP said they didn’t like the outro with the bass. Yes I agree with you!!! 

[MadreMonster 2,584]

I love the ending honestly. I wish she did more of those out-there unexpected things with her songs.

[pachinko 9,466]

I'll never forgive you for this. 

[KingRedd 3,139]

Fun Tonight exists... so give the good sis her respect and leave her achievement alone

[Zilla 13,343]

Because everyone has an opinion and someone else might think that your favorite song is the worst on Chromatica, that's how it works. 

I'm a SFA stan so I see no fault. 

[Yxcvbnm 839]

Plastic Doll is the worst,but Sine from Above is also in the skip category, I could make easily a Chromatica EP with 8 songs. 

[Ricardo 7,650]

not it's actually Fun Tonight 

[giskardsb 12,565]

5 hours ago, GeeYewWhai said:

 

Sine as metaphor for music just doesn’t work or make sense.

It's not a metaphor it's reality in physics. No Sine waves no music. 

[Bizcochito 5,313]

you spilled @GeeYewWhai

[Cello 49,529]

It took time to grow on me for sure. At first I didn't like the drop and thought it sounded like a Coldplay reject, but I always liked the outro. I appreciate it more now, especially since the Voce Viva version. I don't tend to skip it anymore. 

With regards to what you said about the sine wave, that's where I disagree. As others have pointed out, music is literally made up of sine waves. 

[HermesGr 669]

You need to listen 1000doves eternally

[M i K E Y 5,573]

The only thing that bothers me is the heavy drum ending 

[LittleMonster20 9,575]

It’s not the worst song in my opinion but it definitely isn’t in my top of the album. I must say I really LOVE the ‘I. Heard. One. Sine. From. A. Bove’ thing. It’s really beautifully done.

[Baby 271]

hi.

Lady Gaga – vocals, songwriter

Elton John – vocals, songwriter

BloodPop – producer, songwriter, guitar, keyboards, percussion, bass, drums

Klahr – producer, songwriter, guitar, keyboards, percussion, bass, drums

Axwell – producer, songwriter, guitar, keyboards, percussion, bass, drums 

Liohn – producer, songwriter, guitar, keyboards, percussion, bass, drums

Burns – producer, guitar, keyboards

Rami Yacoub – additional producer, songwriter

Benjamin Rice – songwriter, mixer, recording engineer, vocal producer

Ryan Tedder – songwriter 

Sebastian Ingrosso – songwriter

Vincent Pontare – songwriter

Salem Al Fakir – songwriter

Tom Norris – mixer

E. Scott Kelly – assistant mixer

Randy Merrill – mastering engineer

bye.