Jump to content
Follow Gaga Daily on Telegram
press

Chromatica: Reviews Thread


Anveeroy

Featured Posts

Gerrard174

The critics liking Enigma :legend:

Enigma is among the best in the album while this forum largely disregard it

  • Like 1
  • Love 1
  • Thanks 3
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 1.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Anveeroy

    332

  • buzzkill

    86

  • Haldy

    81

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

They're always exceptionally harsh on established artists and very lenient towards newer, younger artists. Artists like Eminem, Gaga, Katy, Timberlake can barely crack 70 whereas Selena Gomez who

Welcome to the world of Chromatica Reviews! We will keep track on the Metacritic, and as well reviews from the publications.  Official Metascore: 79 (23 Reviews)  Album of the Yea

Ugh, you just reminded me that ARTPOP deserved better. I actually can't believe she doesn't have a higher metascore than 78

vedetegomes
6 minutes ago, Aarghya said:

Metascore: Will Change (Now 81) 

1) The AV Club - 75 (B) - Positive 

2) Clash Music - 80/100 - Positive 

3) musicOMH.com - 80/100 - Positive 

4) The Independent (UK) - 80/100 - Positive 

5) The Telegraph (UK) - 80/100 - Positive 

6) NME - 80/100 - Positive 

7) The Guardian - 80/100 - Positive 

8) PopMatters - 70/100 - Positive 

9) Sputnikmusic - 60/100 - Mixed 

10) Slant Magazine - 50/100 - Mixed 

11) Variety - 96/100 - Positive 

12) Exclaim - 80/100 - Positive 

13) Entertainment Weekly - 91/100

14) Pitchfork - 73/100 (NEW) 

No Ripcord - 60/100 - Mixed

http://www.noripcord.com/reviews/music/lady-gaga/chromatica

Link to post
Share on other sites
Anveeroy

No Ripcord - 6/10

And so to Lady Gaga. This reviewers' policy of reviewing the unknown is stretched a little here; Gaga is just about the most ubiquitous female artist there is. I operate on the basest level of knowledge of her actual music I probably could, only really being aware of Bad Romance and Poker Face, both of which I've discovered are from another decade now. Another reason for my picking up this review though is curiosity—I became aware she's an artist of considerable talent through her grandstanding reinterpretation of Sting's If I Ever Lose My Faith In You at the Kennedy Honours, and a bravura performance with Metallica at the 2017 Grammy Awards, adding a powerful vocal to Moth Into Flame. 

I'm reliably informed she has explored various genres and variations thereupon since her debut, but Chromatica, her sixth album, comes close to the sounds of her early work. It opens in curious fashion, with the first of three bookend orchestral excerpts, Chromatica I, quickly sweeping into electro-pop with Alice—all thumping backbeats and repeated vocal phrases. The album's track-listing is strikingly set up in a symmetrical structure, namely: orchestral bookend, three to four tracks including one collaboration, and repeat. Of this first block of tracks, Rain On Me has the most purpose and poise about it, with a rock-solid catchy chorus and tasteful use of its guest star Ariana Grande. These tracks sound surprisingly retro in places, with block piano chords and dance beats straight out of the 1990s making a great deal of the material.

Following the second orchestral break, Chromatica II, the album hits its stride with darker electro tracks and the sort of robotic, dispassionate vocal lines that Lady Gaga has used to such great success over her career. 911, Plastic Doll, and Sour Candy all have something about them, the deeper synth bass lines and altogether more angst-ridden lyrics achieving more depth and variety than the earlier upbeat offerings; her staccato verse delivery on the former and the chorus line of the latter are powerful earworms. This is the material Gaga seems to stretch out with, but once we are comfortable in this pocket we are whisked back into the 1990s with Enigma, a track that sounds in places like M People. This is not a bad thing in itself, but as an overall listening experience, it feels uneven.  

The final third includes a couple of the more curious tracks on the album, one of them being a collaboration with Elton John (Sine From Above)—his voice is placed in surroundings you'd never have previously imagined them, surrounded by thumping dance beats that are chopped up and processed to fit the staccato rhythms. The verses where his and Gaga’s vocal combine are very strong melodically, with a double-time outro breakdown rounding out a unusual, yet powerful and rewarding, collaboration. On Babybylon, Gaga splices the ancient world with more thumping electro as she confidently brandishes the play on words 'babble on' and 'Babylon' over a distinct and unusual blend of sounds, getting gets away with it by virtue of its position as the album closer.

By and large, though, there are two modes here: the dark neon center of the album surrounded by lighter electro-pop with a retro feel; and they almost all contain classic electro-dance builds closing with the hang from the last chord or vocal note. Likewise, the production is dead-on, polished to perfection. These are tracks that are built for individual consumption across a myriad of online platforms, so the composition of the album perhaps lessens in importance. Nevertheless, a couple more from the darker end like Free Woman' and Replay would achieve a bit more of the blend I suspect she was going for. Chromatica has its moments, but it isn't an album to play on repeat.

Stream Kylie-Janet Discographies!
Link to post
Share on other sites
BladeRunner

Of course Pitchfork gave her a 7.3. It isn't bad at all and the review reads like an 8, but they won't rate it over The Fame Monster. They know they reviewed that album when hating Gaga was kinda cool and giving it a 7.8 was a mistake, so yeah, it's about perspective. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Anveeroy

@JR Gg we got a new 60, so what will happen? 

Edited by Aarghya
Stream Kylie-Janet Discographies!
Link to post
Share on other sites
Anveeroy
Just now, Adarsh said:

I think we’ll stay above 75?

I hope so!

Stream Kylie-Janet Discographies!
Link to post
Share on other sites
Jennie Kim

7.3 from pitchfork is great, nothing to worry about. 

too bad we got that new 60.

 

Spoiler

I'm holding a prayer that they don't count the NYT article as a review

 

  • Thanks 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Anveeroy
Just now, Adarsh said:

I mean we can’t lose 5 points because of one mixed review 

honestly, sometimes i can't understand metacritic 

Stream Kylie-Janet Discographies!
Link to post
Share on other sites
JR Gg
8 minutes ago, Aarghya said:

@JR Gg we got a new 60, so what will happen? 

:billie: Drop to 78 maybe? Don't think the critic weighs particularly much, but with so less reviews, it's bound to go down 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Anveeroy
11 minutes ago, JR Gg said:

:billie: Drop to 78 maybe? Don't think the critic weighs particularly much, but with so less reviews, it's bound to go down 

I am targeting 77 

Stream Kylie-Janet Discographies!
Link to post
Share on other sites
Sneaky

Pitchfork's review is so well-written and fair! They even made sense out of Sine From Above for me lol. This is truly Gaga's best one

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Jase unpinned this topic

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...