Who is the most robbed queen in Drag Race?

[Miel 15,009]

I'm back and forth on Manila. Regarding Season 3, I think she was as equally deserving as Raja (didn't they score nearly identical by the end?), and it boiled down to the nitty gritty details. Raja had a certain chutzpah that probably led to production choosing her (unless it was a premeditated choice, per Mariah's mirror message LOL).

Regarding All Stars 4, I definitely think she should have made it to the end (hell, even win, considering her three-win streak), and ultimately did not deserve to be chosen to leave home when she was eliminated. That said, it's all essentially fair game under that format, and I give credit to Naomi for actually creating the drama that the AS2-4 format oh so craved. It was kind of a chore to watch after that, though, and even Monique's endless charm couldn't save it.

To be fair, All Stars 4 was also kind of odd to watch? It all felt so calculated by production (Talent Show wins was a big red flag for me).

Other probably-popular opinions:

-Miss Talent Almighty BenDela Creme did that to herself, unfortunately

-the jury (jesus) screwed over Shangela and Bebe

-MKD...

[Luna Lovegood 16,827]

3 minutes ago, highlyreductive said:

Shange, hands down. Not that Trixie didn't deserve to win, I love her to death, but the way those other b!tches did her dirty... It has me fuming every time.

Also, Alaska is talented and iconic and based on that I would have loved for her to win. But her throwing the most immature tantrum and saving Roxxxy's aß for the 430958430958th time really left a bitter taste in my mouth. Katya is just so wholesome and is someone whose work I still follow to this day, which I can't say about many of the other queens. Alaska, on the other hand, is kinda... irrelevant and passé, idk.

I would’ve Katya but she was not robbed tbh. Alaska won fair and square. But I do agree Roxxxy should’ve gone home since episode 2.

[Miel 15,009]

The "Robbed Queen" narrative has really benefited a lot of these queens, though. Shangela even predated this with her underdog narrative, and she's doing fantastic. Ongina is revered by classic fans. Manila is hailed. Katya and Trixie are probably the most popular queens, I think.

On Divina, I wonder if production realized that she had such strong fan support, and wanted to milk that for a future season. Hmm.

[Beanybb 1,235]

They can't be robbed for a crown they never had 

[Beanybb 1,235]

BUT if I had to pick one it would be Nina Flowers for Season 1 &  Manila for All Stars 4

[not Chromatica 5,393]

12 minutes ago, River Phoenix said:

I would’ve Katya but she was not robbed tbh. Alaska won fair and square. But I do agree Roxxxy should’ve gone home since episode 2.

As I've said, Alaska's C.U.N.T. can't be denied. I do think her victory clearly shows how favorized she was by Ru & Co. In a situation like that one, where it was more or less a tie between the two, I think Alaska's behavior should have been the decisive factor and it wasn't.

Oh well, had Roxxxy gone home earlier, we wouldn't have gotten that iconic Read U, Wrote U verse. 

[RAMROD 96,386]

Manila and Shangie.

 AS 3 and 4 is not existent to me. 

[Bio 23,538]

6 minutes ago, highlyreductive said:

As I've said, Alaska's C.U.N.T. can't be denied. I do think her victory clearly shows how favorized she was by Ru & Co. In a situation like that one, where it was more or less a tie between the two, I think Alaska's behavior should have been the decisive factor and it wasn't.

Oh well, had Roxxxy gone home earlier, we wouldn't have gotten that iconic Read U, Wrote U verse. 

It was nowhere near a tie tho. Alaska won 4 challenges and was in the bottom two once. Katya won two and was in the bottom two multiple times. Even Detox had a better track record than Katya.

[COOOK 76,405]

26 minutes ago, highlyreductive said:

Alaska, on the other hand, is kinda... irrelevant and passé, idk.

Girl! Alaska is a well known Gaga fan with a good appreciation for ARTPOP, proof in her ‘Justice for ARTPOP’ show. Her Race Chaser podcast is lit and the Drag Race tea she and Willam spill is truly hot tea

[COOOK 76,405]

15 minutes ago, highlyreductive said:

Oh well, had Roxxxy gone home earlier, we wouldn't have gotten that iconic Read U, Wrote U verse. 

Same! But also imagine the slayage if Tatianna or Alyssa had a verse there ughh

[Lumi 3,512]

Jade Sotomayor. How tf did Rebeca win over her? One of the top 10 worst decisions of the show.

[Diamond Heart 4,400]

Shangela  
I will never forgive those queens for robbing her of her all star crown 

[Diamond Heart 4,400]

38 minutes ago, highlyreductive said:

Shange, hands down. Not that Trixie didn't deserve to win, I love her to death, but the way those other b!tches did her dirty... It has me fuming every time.

Also, Alaska is talented and iconic and based on that I would have loved for her to win. But her throwing the most immature tantrum and saving Roxxxy's aß for the 430958430958th time really left a bitter taste in my mouth. Katya is just so wholesome and is someone whose work I still follow to this day, which I can't say about many of the other queens. Alaska, on the other hand, is kinda... irrelevant and passé, idk.

What kind of lies? Alaska remains one of the most popular queens post Drag Race 
I wanted Katya to win too but this revisionist history is strange 

[not Chromatica 5,393]

3 minutes ago, COOOK said:

Same! But also imagine the slayage if Tatianna or Alyssa had a verse there ughh

Well that scenario belongs in the universe where Act II was released and we've been bopping to LG6 for a year already. Don't go there.

[not Chromatica 5,393]

9 minutes ago, COOOK said:

Girl! Alaska is a well known Gaga fan with a good appreciation for ARTPOP, proof in her ‘Justice for ARTPOP’ show. Her Race Chaser podcast is lit and the Drag Race tea she and Willam spill is truly hot tea

 

1 minute ago, Diamond Heart said:

What kind of lies? Alaska remains one of the most popular queens post Drag Race 
I wanted Katya to win too but this revisionist history is strange 

meh