Ceremony: Billie Eilish - WHEN WE ALL FALL ASLEEP, WHERE DO WE GO?

[Blue Madonna 19,711]

#12. goodbye

Overall Score: 7.02

Highest Score: 10 - @TheSlash @Maleficent

Lowest Score: 3 - @DiamondKing @AMENiCURE

 

Comments:

Spoiler

@TheSlash (10) As Billie herself thought of the last three songs as a sentence I want to rate it that way, too The pure idea of it being one cohesive story and that sentence thing It gives me sad chills every time I reach this part of the album. listen before i go is so cinematic, i love you so sad and goodbye makes me so emotional as it really is a goodbye from the album 

 @Orangetrees (9) Such a good closure.

@Thomas P (8.5) I love albums that end the album connecting all songs together.

@LanaDelGrant (8) i guess just a few people noticed that she doesn't cite the previous songs in any other, but backwards, so that's like a nod for starting the album over again

@HausOfHarlow (9) Oddly, I love it. Very creative and artistic to use al one from each track. 

@Maleficent (10) i actually love this blend of all the songs—i think it sounds lush and beautiful!

@Oriane (7) I like it, it’s a good outro, but the end is a bit sudden.

@DiamondKing (3) A very creative way to end the album.

@halcyonpop (8.8) I love this kind of album conclusion, the reimagining of the main themes. She does it really well here.

@aaron l(9) Genuinely such a flawless ending to this album. From the moment this track begins, my emotions are already set on high and the way we get to experience the album once again, but all at once is an EXPERIENCE. Beautifully produced.

@Sam98 (9) Brilliant. First time I personally hear something like this as an album ending.

@lifeasgeorge (7) this song makes sense as a closer for the album but it's kind of weird to just listen to on it's own. if that makes sense lol

@rumours (8.25) A good way to end the album.

 

[aaron l 11,842]

@AMENiCURE giving !!!!!! a 10 and goodbye a 3

[PlastiscGuy 8,930]

1 minute ago, Blue Madonna said:

#12. goodbye

Overall Score: 7.02

Highest Score: 10 - @TheSlash @Maleficent

Lowest Score: 3 - @DiamondKing @AMENiCURE

 

Comments:

  Hide contents

@TheSlash (10) As Billie herself thought of the last three songs as a sentence I want to rate it that way, too The pure idea of it being one cohesive story and that sentence thing It gives me sad chills every time I reach this part of the album. listen before i go is so cinematic, i love you so sad and goodbye makes me so emotional as it really is a goodbye from the album 

 @Orangetrees (9) Such a good closure.

@Thomas P (8.5) I love albums that end the album connecting all songs together.

@LanaDelGrant (8) i guess just a few people noticed that she doesn't cite the previous songs in any other, but backwards, so that's like a nod for starting the album over again

@HausOfHarlow (9) Oddly, I love it. Very creative and artistic to use al one from each track. 

@Maleficent (10) i actually love this blend of all the songs—i think it sounds lush and beautiful!

@Oriane (7) I like it, it’s a good outro, but the end is a bit sudden.

@DiamondKing (3) A very creative way to end the album.

@halcyonpop (8.8) I love this kind of album conclusion, the reimagining of the main themes. She does it really well here.

@aaron l(9) Genuinely such a flawless ending to this album. From the moment this track begins, my emotions are already set on high and the way we get to experience the album once again, but all at once is an EXPERIENCE. Beautifully produced.

@Sam98 (9) Brilliant. First time I personally hear something like this as an album ending.

@lifeasgeorge (7) this song makes sense as a closer for the album but it's kind of weird to just listen to on it's own. if that makes sense lol

@rumours (8.25) A good way to end the album.

 

 

[Mudkip 36,067]

Imma need to check my rates again I forgot what scores I gave

also some of y’all never had Invisaligns and it shows

[AMENiCURE 7,833]

mind me for such ratings

by the way my ggd account got hacked somebody is threatening to get me hate on my taste I've worked really hard on. 

Spoiler

 

Edited May 2 by AMENiCURE

[aaron l 11,842]

goodbye slayed any outro any of our favs will put out in the next 3 years

Edited May 2 by aaron l

[PlastiscGuy 8,930]

Just now, aaron l said:

goodbye slayed any outro any of our favs will put out in the next 3 years

Except for LG6. We all know last track will be another live cover of La Vie en Rose 

[Blue Madonna 19,711]

4 minutes ago, aaron l said:

goodbye slayed any outro any of our favs will put out in the next 3 years

Agreed, except this:

It's actually the second-to-last song but it serves as an album summary just like goodbye. If you listen to the whole album you'll get it

[Blue Madonna 19,711]

6 minutes ago, AMENiCURE said:

mind me for such ratings

by the way my ggd account got hacked somebody is threatening to get me hate on my taste I've worked really hard on. 

Rita Ora teas

 

edit: nvm mess you posted it yourself 

Edited May 2 by Blue Madonna

[Blue Madonna 19,711]

The next one shocked and saddened me... 

any guesses?

Edited May 2 by Blue Madonna

[lifeasgeorge 5,502]

Am I the only one that didn't realize that Goodbye pulls lines from every song in reverse order until you guys told me just now 

Edited May 2 by lifeasgeorge

[rumours 37,465]

16 minutes ago, Blue Madonna said:

Reading this for the first time was an experience

I’m here now. 

And 

[rumours 37,465]

10 minutes ago, Blue Madonna said:

#12. goodbye

Overall Score: 7.02

Highest Score: 10 - @TheSlash @Maleficent

Lowest Score: 3 - @DiamondKing @AMENiCURE

 

Comments:

  Hide contents

@TheSlash (10) As Billie herself thought of the last three songs as a sentence I want to rate it that way, too The pure idea of it being one cohesive story and that sentence thing It gives me sad chills every time I reach this part of the album. listen before i go is so cinematic, i love you so sad and goodbye makes me so emotional as it really is a goodbye from the album 

 @Orangetrees (9) Such a good closure.

@Thomas P (8.5) I love albums that end the album connecting all songs together.

@LanaDelGrant (8) i guess just a few people noticed that she doesn't cite the previous songs in any other, but backwards, so that's like a nod for starting the album over again

@HausOfHarlow (9) Oddly, I love it. Very creative and artistic to use al one from each track. 

@Maleficent (10) i actually love this blend of all the songs—i think it sounds lush and beautiful!

@Oriane (7) I like it, it’s a good outro, but the end is a bit sudden.

@DiamondKing (3) A very creative way to end the album.

@halcyonpop (8.8) I love this kind of album conclusion, the reimagining of the main themes. She does it really well here.

@aaron l(9) Genuinely such a flawless ending to this album. From the moment this track begins, my emotions are already set on high and the way we get to experience the album once again, but all at once is an EXPERIENCE. Beautifully produced.

@Sam98 (9) Brilliant. First time I personally hear something like this as an album ending.

@lifeasgeorge (7) this song makes sense as a closer for the album but it's kind of weird to just listen to on it's own. if that makes sense lol

@rumours (8.25) A good way to end the album.

 

Not one of the good songs being out so early 

[Blue Madonna 19,711]

#11. xanny

Overall Score: 7.52

Highest Score: 11 - @aaron l

Lowest Score: 3 - @Gam

 

Comments:

Spoiler

@Thomas P (9) I think any good thing that can be said about this song has been said. The message is great, and her lyrics and vocals are beautiful. 

@LanaDelGrant (9.3) this song was a good showcase to that bass heavy chorus, i personally would have put it a little away from bad guy, i guess having them together might have given the impression that the album was going to revolve around the same sound 

@Maleficent(8) love this song—but the fact that a 16/17 yr old is singing about heavy drugs makes me mildly uncomfortable

@Trepadation (6.8) the jazzy verses are so good but the heavy bass makes it unbearable to listen to 

@Oriane (7.5) I like the magical atmosphere and the rhythm, the indie and rock vibes.

@DiamondKing (4) Great lyrics, but soundwise the song isn't my cup of tea.

@aaron l (11) Easily the best track and the most atmospheric. This track sucks me into a place of nostalgia, deep emotion, and even a little bit of regret. Billie hit me hard with xanny and expresses something I've never fully been able to put into words myself.

@Sam98 (7) Didn't vibe much with this, I enjoy it only during certain times and with certain feelings

@rumours (5.25) Part of her voice reminds me slightly of Bjork. This track is really frustrating because parts of it are wonderful… but the awful bass/fart sound ruins the chorus. It could have been a 8+ track, but it was ruined. Such a shame.

 

[TeenIdle 58,458]

Here and ready to witness wtpo snatching the crown 

goodbye is so creative. At first I was like this sounds reductive and familiar and then I realized it's a summary