Official 'A Star is Born' Reviews Megathread   Reviews that count toward Rotten Tomatoes / Metacritic:   The Guardian - 5/5 Telegraph - 5/5 Variety - 5/5 TheWrap - 90/100 Time - 90/100 Entertainment Weekly - B+ The Playlist - B+ The Film Stage - B+ Indiewire - B Hollywood Reporter - 4/5 Time Out - 4/5 Digital Spy - 4/5 Us Weekly - 3/4 Screen International - 70/100 Vulture - Positive