Would Gaga lose her fanbase if she went very experimental?

[monster4life231 4,304]

It would separate the real fans and the fake fans. That’s the tea. 

[PedrinniSan 158]

She wouldn't lose me. 

I'm a fan of her experimentation with all kinds of music. If you just want regular pop bops go to listen Dua Lipa and let gagz to be creative  If she made the kind of music the fake fans want, she would be wasting her talent. We already have Bad Romance, Poker face, Just dance, Telephone, Alejandro, Judas... get over it.

[GagaUnderYou 4,915]

I grew to like everything she does, so she could give me anything. 

[Dunk96 2,526]

Gaga could literally breathe on a song and lose her entire fanbase. Her fans are never satisfied with anything she does unless it sounds exactly like The Fame,The Fame Monster,Born This Way,and ARTPOP. I'm over it.

[RAMROD 96,153]

Definitely!

Some people just want her to be basic and stay like its 2008-2010 when it is almost mid 2018 but their mind will never change, they will just be killjoys on every album eras until Gaga miraculously sounding like 2008 again probably. 

[tomsches 16,949]

I'm all here for it.

But  1) I don't Think thats the music she personally likes. And 2) I'm ñol sure whether she even can Make Songs like twigs or björk 

[River 90,369]

It's like GGD is divided to Conservative Gaga fans vs Liberal Gaga Fans.

One group wants Gaga to come back to her early sound and TFM 2.0 while the others wants her to continue pushing the boundaries..

[Reid LePage 4,773]

8 hours ago, Haroon said:

Some would leave and others would join  I'm hoping she doesn't go too far like FKA Twigs and Bjork because I really can't listen to their music, it just doesn't make any sense to me

but...

[sipthistea 21,099]

She should do what her heart tells her to do, not what her fans tell her to do. I wish she made lots of interesting stuff, but it's not my place to tell her because she's the one in charge of her career. 

[freebit 6,055]

People here would flip, and pop fans would be even more annoyed at her avoiding ~the bops~ than they were during her "country" album Joanne. 

Regardless, I feel like Gaga loves a good chorus too much to consider going too esoteric on us. I welcome experimentation though. 

[ltlmnstr 2,771]

I guess but I wouldn't care.

[whore 11,440]

With that example, FKA twigs is one of my favorite artists, so I would be in heaven tbh 

[Inferno 2,880]

Lets say she makes something that successfully breaks the mold in one way or another be it pop or whatever, I think she would lose some fans and definitely gain others. But in a positive way. Maybe she'd gain a more intellectual or musically inclined following and drop all the annoying people here that won't stop obsessing over bad unreleased ARTPOP material. I don't know.

[Inferno 2,880]

9 hours ago, River said:

It's like GGD is divided to Conservative Gaga fans vs Liberal Gaga Fans.

One group wants Gaga to come back to her early sound and TFM 2.0 while the others wants her to continue pushing the boundaries..

I personally feel that The Fame Monster pushed more boundaries sonically/aesthetically within the scope of her own career than Joanne or ARTPOP. Contrary to popular monster opinion I think The Fame Monster is a lot less basic than Joanne as well. Like if we're talking about conservative vs. liberal Joanne is ABSOLUTELY more on the conservative side musically vs. The Fame Monster.

[freebit 6,055]

38 minutes ago, Inferno said:

I personally feel that The Fame Monster pushed more boundaries sonically/aesthetically within the scope of her own career than Joanne or ARTPOP. 

How so? TFM is one of, if not, my favorite album of all time, but I don't feel it pushed her sonic boundaries in a big way, amazing as it is. I feel like she still has far to go, but is making strides here & there with every release.