Million Reasons vs. You and I vs. Speechless

[Anderson123 31,225]

Very hard to pick just one but obviously You and I for me, followed by Speechless. Million Reasons is an amazing song but not as special as the other two.

[juju 18,907]

Speechless, always.

[Head Empty 22,577]

This will always be difficult for me because both You and I and Speechless are so much better live, that I barely ever listen to the studio versions .

Both are some of Gaga's best songs, but the studio versions don't live up to their potential.

[Arizona Sky 10,913]

Don't make me chose between Million Reasons and Speechless  They are in my Top 5 favorite Gaga songs of all time

I can surely say that Y&I is last though

[youandi 2,110]

In terms of theme, atmosphere, melody and metaphorical lyrics, I think Angel Down could be her best ballad

but 

You and I is probably my favourite song of hers 

[Rino 5,094]

Brown Eyes 

[Fernster7 7,837]

It's so hard for me to choose between Million Reasons and You and I. They are both flawless and in my top 10 Gaga songs, but I chose MR.

Speechless is nice but just not as good.

[SXXXDREAMS 72]

did not know what thread to put than on, but when Million Reasons came up, everybody guessed it within 1 second... skip to 5:12

[HANZ 4,380]

the one with a flawless music video

Speechless is second 

annd Million Reasons third

[Muh 144]

Speechless is just  > Joanne = Million Reasons > You And I > the rest

[Gagz 2,572]

Dope 

But out of your choices, I have to say You And I.

[Monsterious 26,867]

the iconic Million Reasons 

[blackcoffee 1,264]

This is hard, but definitely Yoü and I for me. Second favorite Gaga song of mine after TEOG.

Yoü and I is honestly one of her best written songs period...great lyrics, amazing production, and BRIAN MAY ON THE GUITAR! It's pop meets power ballad stadium rock, with a little country tinge, and oh so totally GAGA! The video makes it even better. It's a very beloved song of hers here in America by the GP and she definitely loves it too.

Speechless is in my Top 5 favorite Gaga songs too. Only Gaga could pull off an Elton John-inspired rock-pop piano ballad like that. So good.

MR is the bottom of my Top 10 Gaga songs and her iconic performances of this song really sold it for me (I always liked it, but those performances put it in my Top 10). It's a straightforward piano ballad that is so heartfelt and perfect.

[Nuggets 14,136]

Wow, speechless is so underrated

"I'll never talk again"

"Oh boy, you've left me speechless"

Omg..

 

[Phlop 4,773]

You and I