This isn't a negative thread, it's my opinion as a Gaga fan and a 40 year old music fan who's been around since the 80's. She can't get away with rock because she's not a rock artist. Period. PI is a basic pop song disguised in a rock t-shirt. No amount of boots, shrill vocals, microphone waving can hide it. The audience can sense fakery from a mile away. The fact that she grew up with rock music and likes rock classics does not make her a rock performer. Gaga was successful with the J