Better Second Single?

[Twitter 14]

Which album do you think the possible second single choice was better than what originally happened? Discuss 

EDIT: These choices were based off all the hype between fans & Gaga herself during 2011, 2013, and 2016 

[YoungWildCanadian 263]

Scheiße would have been amazing 😉 but maybe then it wouldn’t be such a fan favourite 

[Lucas 20,603]

None actually. Sheisse would probably be edited to remove the gibberish parts and the song would lose its charm, Do What U Want screams smash hit and A-YO is too country and would never become a top 5 hit

[FfFfFfFF 54,014]

Are we suppose to vote the options based on our opinion if the switch was good? 

Edit: I should read the OP more patient.   

[John Wayne 4,215]

None actually. Schieße should always stay a fan favorite gem, DWUW proved Gaga is really suited for RnB and MR became like a mini Gaga anthem.

[Guest]

Scheiße is better than Judas

Venus is better than DWYW

But I think their choices were right 

[ArtGagaPop 61,940]

Schisse
DWUW
MR

[ryanripley 86,575]

scheisse would have been such a club banger  

[Twitter 14]

3 hours ago, GagaInTheZone said:

None actually. Sheisse would probably be edited to remove the gibberish parts and the song would lose its charm, Do What U Want screams smash hit and A-YO is too country and would never become a top 5 hit

Agreed and I forgot all about the radio chopping songs up. 

[juju 18,907]

Million Reasons and DWUW were both terrific follow-up singles.

Scheiße is the better song between it and Judas, and may have fared better in European territories, but I find the song too abrasive for American audiences, sadly.