Replace 1 Bad Single For Another Song

[Twitter 14]

If you were able to pick only one Gaga single you thought was a bad choice and replace it for something else. What would you choose? Discuss Little Managers 

[gts14 1,577]

Venus instead of G.U.Y 

[River 90,488]

SHICD with Telephone

[Red Velvet 10,973]

Exchanging Beautiful Dirty Rich for Paparazzi

[Clever Username 0]

Replace GUY for Gypsy  

[ChavaWM 1,802]

Judas with HML

[Hades 27,980]

He said bad singles. In which world Telephone or Paparazzi were bad or flopped? Lmao

[actsleazy 6,550]

DITD with Speechless 

[Maleficent 6]

Judas with Schieße 

Applause with Aura 

G.U.Y with Sexxx Dreams 

Alejandro with Dance In The Dark 

[badgirlmeat 3,243]

G.U.Y. or Applause with Sexxx Dreams

[Tomiel25 2,028]

I love perfect illusion and is not bad but i would prefer Diamond Heart

[Anderson123 30,912]

Aura instead of Applause

Venus 2nd single, album release, Do What U Want.

[Irrelevant 20,272]

Scheiße instead of Judas

[NIghtmareElm 2,606]

Born This Way: 

Replace Judas with Bloody Mary

Replace Marry the Night with Scheibe

ARTPOP: 

Replace G.U.Y. with Sexxx Dreams

Joanne: 

Replace Perfect Illusion with Dancin' in Circles

 

 

[sexy 3,094]

Judas with Marry the Night

Judas was the single that really started Gaga's commercial decline. Completely unnecessary controversy. Put in Marry the Night instead of Judas and we likely would've had a Top 5 hit (instead of its peaking at #29 when it was released at the tail end of a dying era). 

With Marry the Night doing well as the second single, especially if it reached the upper echelons of the Top 5 (#3, #2, or even #1), we then would have had more momentum going into the third single – The Edge of Glory. At that point, if Gaga wanted to do a risky single like Judas, I think that would've been appropriate, or perhaps something like Scheiße. Then wrap up the era with a safe single like You and I.