opinion

#JusticeForComeToMama

Started by bowie1986 with 22 replies so far

I just can’t sit back anymore. Seeing the people who are defending Million Reasons and pushing for Dancin’ In Circles as a single are spurning hellfire in the deepest recesses of my soul.

How can anyone dislike Gaga’s voice meets Ronson/Winehouse reminiscent production meets Father John Misty lyrics?  I mean I don’t like that the song opens with “Everybody’s gotta love eachother”, but otherwise I would argue this is a top 5 Gaga song ever. It showcases her strengths as a vocalist, effectively uses her great collaborators (even though she stripped misty of his guitar riffs in the demo), and sounds like nothing in her discography.

These are the Gaga efforts that deserve praise and a single pre-presidential election.  Million Reasons was the nail in the coffin for this era. She should’ve pushed A-Yo harder and given Million Reasons the dust it deserves—nobody needs a country ballad as a single. Ever. And it’s a slap in the face to the good ballads she has performed (Brown Eyes, Speechless, Dope, etc). I hope it was her choice to promote MR, because anyone focused on charts or quality ought to know better with such a simple melody, shitty lyrics, and feigned emotion. But if it's personal, healing, what she wants to say-- then fine i guess. 

And Dancin’ In Circles. Don’t even get me started. You people crave her dance bops so much that you are settling for this??? Of all the art that draws from masturbation in the world, this song is like webcam ****. Shameless and poor quality. 

 

Oh and while I'm here, #JohnWayneThirdSingleOrBust

5 people like this

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites

i want to agree with you, but MR is her BEST ballad so...

1 person likes this

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites

Come To Mama sounds like a classic.

I would be here for it to be a single :giveup:

6 people like this

But I think with you I could spend my life.

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, TropicOfCANCER said:

i want to agree with you, but MR is her BEST ballad so...

:rip:

 

9 people like this

Your paradise is not for me

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites

AGREE! It's one of her best songs in her entire discography! She really needs to perform it during the SB!:giveup:


#PerfectIllusion

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites

#JohnWaynWontBeASingle

And before you come at me with spotify and itunes receipts: it was performed in full at VSFS, ofcourse people looked it up

2 people like this

Join us in QUIZWIZZ - Now in the Community Center

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites

come to mama is kinda boring  coughsinwholeboringjoannealbum and i mean the chorus :neyde:

maybe she can make it like a single for a week or something idk 

Edited by iFameMonzter

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's so great. I would love to hear more Gaga +  John Misty in the future, maybe a bit more stripped back.

2 people like this

They say it's the last song. They don't know us, you see. It's only the last song if we let it be.

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites

No. 


Here My sinner's Prayer i am what i am & I'm STRAIGHT 😇

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites

Also mess at you shading MR and DIC like that :awkney:

MR is one of her best ballads, and is doing amazing compared to the poor radio it gets (thanks PI, MTN, GUY)

DIC is an amzing song I dont even have to add arguments for this


Join us in QUIZWIZZ - Now in the Community Center

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, bowie1986 said:

I just can’t sit back anymore. Seeing the people who are defending Million Reasons and pushing for Dancin’ In Circles as a single are spurning hellfire in the deepest recesses of my soul.

How can anyone dislike Gaga’s voice meets Ronson/Winehouse reminiscent production meets Father John Misty lyrics?  I mean I don’t like that the song opens with “Everybody’s gotta love eachother”, but otherwise I would argue this is a top 5 Gaga song ever. It showcases her strengths as a vocalist, effectively uses her great collaborators (even though she stripped misty of his guitar riffs in the demo), and sounds like nothing in her discography.

These are the Gaga efforts that deserve praise and a single pre-presidential election.  Million Reasons was the nail in the coffin for this era. She should’ve pushed A-Yo harder and given Million Reasons the dust it deserves—nobody needs a country ballad as a single. Ever. And it’s a slap in the face to the good ballads she has performed (Brown Eyes, Speechless, Dope, etc). I hope it was her choice to promote MR, because anyone focused on charts or quality ought to know better with such a simple melody, shitty lyrics, and feigned emotion. But if it's personal, healing, what she wants to say-- then fine i guess. 

And Dancin’ In Circles. Don’t even get me started. You people crave her dance bops so much that you are settling for this??? Of all the art that draws from masturbation in the world, this song is like webcam ****. Shameless and poor quality. 

 

Oh and while I'm here, #JohnWayneThirdSingleOrBust

 

I agree with Come to Mama being amazing, and with the over obsession with the dance songs, and with DiC being a bad single choice, however, I disagree with everything else you have said. Million Reasons is amazing, and the reason it actually DOES WORK is because it's different from anything Gaga has released as a single, she has never released that kind of quieter song as a single, she never released a non-dance track as a single. A-Yo and John Wayne are along the lines of all the other electronic music she has released, it's great she took a risk with Million Reasons, to hell with the people who don't like it. She took a risk, which is admirable, too many people play it safe with music and with everything else these days, releasing another dance album would have been playing it safe, Monsters should stop expecting Gaga to play it safe with pop and dance music, she is a risk taker, Joanne was a risk, and it's hella admirable Gaga took such a risk. 

1 person likes this

BUY LG5!

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, mister max said:

#JohnWaynWontBeASingle

And before you come at me with spotify and itunes receipts: it was performed in full at VSFS, ofcourse people looked it up

John Wayne is the weakest Joanne song imo. :classy:

The verses are cool and all but that dat doo deet doe thingy is awkward. If they want an upbeat song they should choose DIC/Diamond Heart. Even A-yo would be better.

Edited by Swan Heart

They say it's the last song. They don't know us, you see. It's only the last song if we let it be.

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, iFameMonzter said:

come to mama is kinda boring  coughsinwholeboringjoannealbum and i mean the chorus :neyde:

maybe she can make it like a single for a week or something idk 

And what? You think dance pop music isn't boring? Puhleaze. 


BUY LG5!

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites

I absolutely love Come to Mama and I would be very happy if they chose it as a single... Dancin' in Circles and John Wayne are overrated fan favorites and they wouldn't have much success in my opinion.... funny how Gaga fans always praise Gaga for being a serious artist, but want the least serious commercial songs

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0