Jump to content
Joanne World Tour
🎸 🎤 🤘 JOANNE TOUR TICKETS ON SALE NOW 🤘 🎤 🎸
question

Will Gaga always be queen of pop?

question

Featured Posts

Aussie   Paws Up 280
Aussie

Gaga shouldn't be classified as Queen of Pop, she isn't just pop. She is also a recording Jazz artist and who knows what her next album will be about. She isn't just put in brackets and placed in a box. Plus the likes of Katy Perry, Beyonce and Rihanna seem to be more 'relevant' to the mainstream crowd.

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
UK Monster   Paws Up 6,265
UK Monster
12 hours ago, MechaRaja said:

Agreed! TEOG was a hit and so was Applause but they weren't no.1 either. 

 

#1's don't matter its about longevity!!

Gaga has 4 UK #1's and Taylor Swift has 0 sorry just had to point that out lol.

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Melisandre   Paws Up 7,409
Melisandre
50 minutes ago, UK Monster said:

Gaga has 4 UK #1's and Taylor Swift has 0 sorry just had to point that out lol.

The only market that matters apparently is US.

  • Like 2

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
IsraeliUnicorn   Paws Up 18
IsraeliUnicorn

she is ****ing amazing  but she doesn't do Pop anymore 

she isn't realy a mainstream artist right now and that's okan. 

she will always be the crazy icon lady gaga - but - now she doesn't need to get on the top of the pops because she's already there.

my point is that it doesn't matter how you'll call her and what you'll say about her - she made the real revolution in music and took a big part of the social media risings back then.

if she will make a pop record, not like ARTPOP or tfm or whatever else she'd done before - she will make it the best and she will succeed just like Kp and rihanna and etc. 

why ? because she know how to do it

why she won't do it? - because she is a true artist

a true artist make its own art and won't work only for theducational GP satisfaction

she doesn't need to do that anymore

she became what she is now

 

Of ****ING COURSE I WANT TFM 2 AND 3 AND 4 

BUT IT WILL COME ONLY IF SHE WANTS 

 

THAT'S IT

Edited by IsraeliUnicorn
  • Like 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
gagzus   Paws Up 7,468
gagzus

Gaga reinvented what it means to be a popstars without her dance music wouldn't be on the radio and the cheap tricks and gimmicks that a lot of modern stars possess wouldn't matter or exist :classy:

Im happy to say she's nowhere near losing her title, but some people won't even use it until she either dies or in decades to come. But then again I wouldn't want her to be compared to Madonna, because Gaga's actually likeable, makes good music and has more than one good album in her discography already and doesn't act like a cheap mess onstage but anyways

Edited by gagzus

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
River   Paws Up 7,686
River

lol still talking about queen of pop and useless childish titles? :ladyhaha:

 

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
blackstar   Paws Up 5,094
blackstar
20 hours ago, Impostor said:

I'm curious :oprah:

Who?

Taylor Swift, Katy Perry :oprah: 

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
MonsterPaws   Paws Up 1,212
MonsterPaws

The number of people who take this **** seriously is staggering :toofunny:

 

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Impostor   Paws Up 3,272
Impostor
2 hours ago, blackstar said:

Taylor Swift, Katy Perry :oprah: 

:bye:

  • Like 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Josip   Paws Up 453
Josip

Let's cover some facts:

- being the Queen of Pop will probably always be subjective unless someone makes a staggering career which cannot be matched

- no one has done that yet (except maybe Michael Jackson and The Beatles, but that's another category)

- Madonna is and should be current Queen of Pop :madge:

- it is only a matter of time before she is dethroned

- the best example for that is Gaga achieving half the things she did in only 8 years :trollga:

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Helxig   Paws Up 11,411
Helxig

I guess first we need to determine what makes someone the 'queen of pop' before we can answer your question.

Is the 'queen of pop' someone who:

-Is the most talked about and well known?

-Is the most creatively driven and technically talented?

-Is played the most frequently on radio stations worldwide?

-Pushes the boundaries of what is considered pop music?

-Charts the highest and most consistently?

-Keeps up with the latest pop music trends consistently? 

-Makes the most money?

-Wins the most awards?

-Has the best connection with their fanbase and touches people's hearts the most deeply?

-Gets the best critical reviews?

 

If we can't solidly define the term 'queen of pop' then we aren't going to get an answer to your question, because everyone will have their own idea of what the term means to them and we will just argue argue in circles perpetually to no end.

 

Edited by Helxig
  • Like 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Helxig   Paws Up 11,411
Helxig
4 hours ago, IsraeliUnicorn said:

she is ****ing amazing  but she doesn't do Pop anymore 

she isn't realy a mainstream artist right now and that's okan. 

she will always be the crazy icon lady gaga - but - now she doesn't need to get on the top of the pops because she's already there.

my point is that it doesn't matter how you'll call her and what you'll say about her - she made the real revolution in music and took a big part of the social media risings back then.

if she will make a pop record, not like ARTPOP or tfm or whatever else she'd done before - she will make it the best and she will succeed just like Kp and rihanna and etc. 

why ? because she know how to do it

why she won't do it? - because she is a true artist

a true artist make its own art and won't work only for theducational GP satisfaction

she doesn't need to do that anymore

she became what she is now

 

Of ****ING COURSE I WANT TFM 2 AND 3 AND 4 

BUT IT WILL COME ONLY IF SHE WANTS 

 

THAT'S IT

I'm glad somebody with some sense has joined this site! We need more of you! And welcome newbie :hug:

  • Like 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Trepadation   Paws Up 3,373
Trepadation
18 hours ago, The Fame Joanne said:

Noone ever came close to Madonna. So as long as she's still in the business, she's the Queen. And even without Madonna, there would still be others ahead of Gaga 

Mdna & Rebel heart says hello

87Qqd_s-200x150.gif

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Impostor   Paws Up 3,272
Impostor

I thought this thread was a joke :oprah:

Are you guys really discussing who's the queen of pop? Isn't it obvious that Madonna rules the whole thing?

****ing bye

  • Like 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
UK Monster   Paws Up 6,265
UK Monster
23 hours ago, MechaRaja said:

The only market that matters apparently is US.

yeah but its fun for me seeing her do well here whilst others are complaining

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


×