What's special about "You and I" that gets so much love from GeePee?

[Hope 2,030]

All my friends (not fans, they don't care about her music; some of them don't even know that ARTPOP exists) like TF and TFM stuff along with only "You and I"(!) from BTW. Interestingly neither "Born this Way" nor "TEOG" is mentioned, but only "You and I". Some of them even say that they have so many good memories with this song.

But the ultimate question is: Why "You and I" is loved by GeePee but the homosexual monsters here underrate it so much?!

[Nino 12]

It's a brilliant timeless rock song in an age when they're very scarce.

[chromaticka 4,350]

My favorite song from Gaga due to its lyrics, I can relate to it very very well, her vocals sound really good, the country-pop-rock sound to it is adorable and it makes me feel warm inside. I love it very much.

 

EDIT: the GP is also a sucker for love songs

[MonsterJay 1,481]

One of my friends loves it too and when I asked her why she likes it she said "I love Gaga going countryrock! its so fun"
I cringed hearing her say that..

[U-GO-BOY 1,589]

it's not that typical dance sledgehammer-beat electropop that people are used from her

[weed 66,751]

idk the lyrics are cute and semi-relatable, it's a rock-y song.

[Voltaire 4,531]

It was my Dad's favorite.

Classic sound & classic style. Like a good Billie Joel song. Very glad she made it.

[Warholiness 927]

Maybe because it's not typical Gaga campiness, idk? Listening to the song makes me feel #Masc

[AnglerfishbraBENUS 4,816]

Are you kidding?  It has a beautiful melody and beautiful authentic instruments and it's about Love.  It's no 'Aphrodite lady seashell bikini' but it's one of her all time best. 

[Bloody 64,631]

Cause it's a classic love song that everyone could relate to.

I believe that this song will stay as one of gaga's best in her career and it will always be remembered. 

 

[venusian 4,686]

its my moms favorite song by her

everybody loves rock ig

[JazzGa 14,348]

The fact that it wasn't special and unique is why the peasants love it so much   Just kidding, it's my jam.

[deeman 189]

Sit back down on the grass where you belong. (my interpretation anyway)

http://www.liveloveraw.com/what-eco-living-housing-is-really-like-russia/

[Hope 2,030]

7 minutes ago, Nino said:

It's a brilliant timeless rock song in an age when they're very scarce.

My English stops here

What did you actually want to say with this?

[Benji 20,113]

It's my mum's favourite Gaga song too.

It's that great mix of country/pop music that Shania was renowned for, and Shania slays so there's your explanation really.