Can we talk about how she chose MJH over BN?

[Saint Laurent 4,862]

Correct me if I'm wrong but up until the last minute Mary Jane Holland and Brooklyn nights were battling for a place on ARTPOP. 

Don't get me wrong I love MJH but Gaga girl, how you trying to pick it over the masterpiece BN...

[Jjang 2,262]

MJH is more fitting on ARTPOP.

[mariomania1234 11,368]

MJH fits better within the context of the album.

[Sunny 12,174]

MJH, it fits better 

[Gohan 15,128]

You guys tend to overrate any song that's unreleased like it's some piece of heaven

It's a good song, but it obviously didn't fit on ARTPOP at all, maybe on BTW? I'm not sure, but MJH totally deserved its position there on the album. During the process of making ARTPOP she referenced it A LOT and she even smoke weed to ease the pain she had in her hip :)

[GloZell Green 11,723]

BN was about a past relationship, maybe about Lüc. We should respect her decisions tbh, I mean, she knows what she's doing. MJH isn't that bad, and it fit ARTPOP better 

 

BN was being saved for ACT II anyways 

[Computer 10,966]

BN is a much better song for me

But I can see that it didn't make sense on ARTPOP

[Jesse Pinkman 4,660]

She made the right choice. MJH definitely fits the album better and she hyped it up while recording, and she knew we all would be anticipating it. Plus, the production is AMAZING. Madeon >>>

[ARTUNiCORN 367]

The best song of ARTPOP stays unbothered tho

[lego 44,165]

Masterpiece BN?

[Brooke Candy 3,970]

Brooklyn Nights was saved for ACT 2, so sit down. The song just didn't sound finished to her. 

[Swan Heart 7,382]

I prefer Mary Jane Holland, really.. The production is amazing, I love the lyrics and the whole ''f*cked up, broken happiness'' vibe is really something else, I just adore it.. AND it fits a lot better in ARTPOP. 

Brooklyn Nights is great too, but it will be so out of place if she included it.

[Morphine Prince 96,090]

BN is good but it doesn't sound polished and clearly is not album material. I haven't even listened to it in ages and quite frankly I'm tired of people overrating Gaga's unreleased material  

The songs are NEVER going to happen. Just enjoy them but get over it tbh. 

[ELECTRAHEARTPOP 93]

Brooklyn Nights felt more like a bridge between Born This Way and ARTPOP, and should really have been on the former, if anything - as much as I love it. Mary Jane Holland not only helps to tell ARTPOP's story far better, but it's also the better song.

Brooklyn Nights could have been a huge hit though, in my opinion. So it's swings and roundabouts.

[Bellatrix 34,639]

BN doesn't really fit on ARTPOP, however I strongly dislike MJH so I'm going with BN anyway.